1 / 15

CAS LX 522 Syntax I

CAS LX 522 Syntax I. Week 9.5. Relative clauses. Finishing up from last week…. Last week, we covered wh -movement in questions like: What i did Bill buy t i ? and What i did Mary think Bill bought t i ?

morrisa
Download Presentation

CAS LX 522 Syntax I

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. CAS LX 522Syntax I Week 9.5. Relative clauses

  2. Finishing up from last week… • Last week, we covered wh-movement in questions like: • Whati did Bill buy ti? • and • Whati did Mary think Bill bought ti? • And we looked at conditions on wh-movement, including Subjacency (you can’t move out of two bounding nodes in a single step) and the ECP (the trace of wh-movement must be licensed).

  3. Relative clauses • Another place where we see wh-movement, besides in explicit questions (either in the main clause or embedded) is in relative clauses. • The book which I read • The woman who(m) I met • These consist of a head noun (book, woman) and then what appears to be a wh-question that further specifies the referent of the head noun.

  4. Relative clauses • Relative clauses serve to modify the head noun. • Kind of like adjectives, or PP modifiers. • The unhappy students. • The students from Vancouver. • The students who solved the problem. • So where would you put them?

  5. Relative clauses DP D SS • The structure of a relative clause is like this. • A [+Q, +WH] CP is adjoined inside the NP, like an adjective, or a PP modifier. D NP the N N CP N DPi C man who C TP [+WH][+Q] I met ti

  6. Quirks • The “question” inside a relative clause has a couple of odd properties, not shared with regular main clause or embedded questions. • *The problem what I solved. • The problem which I solved. • The problem which I will solve. • The problem I solved. • The problem that I solved.

  7. Which/that/Ø • In addition to being able to say • The book which Mary read • We can also say • The book that Mary read • and • The book Mary read • And they all mean the same thing. So we expect that they would all have basically the same structure (they all have a question adjoined in the NP)—so where is the wh-word in the last two?

  8. Op • The secret to these last two kinds of relative clauses is Op, the silent wh-word. • That is, the book which Mary read and the book Mary read are really exactly the same except that in one case you pronounce the wh-word, and in the other, you don’t. • the book [CP whichi Mary read ti ] • the book [CPOpi Mary read ti ]

  9. Op • It is also possible to pronounce that with Op, giving us: • the book [CPOpi that [TP Mary read ti ]] • Why can’t we pronounce that with which? • *the book [CP whichi that [TP Mary read ti ]]

  10. Doubly-Filled COMP filter • The Doubly-Filled COMP filter is the traditional “explanation”. • Doubly-Filled COMP filter:*[CPwh-word if/that/for…] • You can’t pronounce both a wh-word and (a base-generated) C at the same time. Thus: • the book [CPOpi [TP Mary read ti ]] • the book [CPOpi that [TP Mary read ti ]] • the book [CPwhichi [TP Mary read ti ]] • *the book [CPwhichi that [TP Mary read ti ]]

  11. Op • Skeptical of Op? Is there really wh-movement of Op, a silent wh-phrase? • I read the book [CP whichi [TP Mary said [CP that [TP Bill bought ti ]]]]. • *I read the book [CP whichi[TPMary wonders [CP who[TPbought ti]]]]. • I read the book [CPOpi (that) [TP Mary said [CP that [TP Bill bought ti ]]]]. • *I read the book [CPOpi (that)[TPMary wonders [CP who[TPbought ti]]]].

  12. Op • So if we have a silent wh-phrase, why can’t we ask questions with it? • Wherei did Mary buy this book ti ? • Wheni did Mary buy this book ti ? • Whyi did Mary buy this book ti ? • Howi did Mary buy this book ti ? • *Opi did Mary buy this book ti ? • See why?

  13. Op • Recoverability condition:The content of a null category must be recoverable. • the place [Opi (that) Mary bought that book ti ] • the day [Opi (that) Mary bought that book ti ] • the reason [Opi (that) Mary bought that book ti ] • the way [Opi (that) Mary bought that book ti ] • In each case, we can tell what the wh-phrase is by looking at the head noun.

  14. Comment on C DP D SS • Notice that when you use Op, the C—despite being [+Q]—can be pronounced as that. • This seems to mean that that is just a way you can pronounce C if it would otherwise be unpronounced and pronouncing it wouldn’t violate the DFC filter. D NP the N N CP N DPi C man Op C TP [+WH][+Q] I met ti

  15.         

More Related