130 likes | 253 Views
Prospects of Identifying the Sources of the Galactic Cosmic Rays with IceCube. Alexander Kappes Francis Halzen Aongus O’Murchadha University Wisconsin-Madison 3 rd VLVnT Workshop April 22. - 24. 2008, Toulon France. Outline. Cosmic rays and gamma/neutrino production
E N D
Prospects of Identifying the Sources of the Galactic Cosmic Rays with IceCube Alexander Kappes Francis Halzen Aongus O’Murchadha University Wisconsin-Madison 3rd VLVnT Workshop April 22. - 24. 2008, Toulon France
Outline • Cosmic rays and gamma/neutrino production • Which are the accelerators of the Galactic cosmic rays? • Can we see them with neutrino telescopes (IceCube)? Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
The Cosmic Ray Spectrum • Cosmic ray spectrum measured over more than 12 decades • Spectrum steepens at ~3 PeV • Transition between Galactic and extra-Galactic component at 1016 - 1018 eV • Form of spectrum requires Galactic accelerators up to 3 PeV (PeVatrons) • Not identifiable with cosmic ray experiments(magnetic fields) galactic extragalactic Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
Hadronic neutrino and -ray production: p + p()→ p0 + X9 p + p()→ p + X9m+nm9 e + ne+nm ( ne: nm : nt ) ( : : 0 Norm: Index: Cut-off: The Cosmic-Ray Gamma/Neutrino Connection • Relation / spectrum parameters (pp interactions)(at Earth mixing leads to (1 : 1 : 1)) • Protons @ CR “knee” produce -rays of ~300 TeV Kappes etal: ApJ,656:870-896,2007 Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
Gabici, Aharonian: arXiv:0705.3011 at 1 Kpc 400 yr 2000 yr 8000 yr (104 solar masses) 2000 yr 8000 yr 32000 yr Cherenkov telescopes (e.g. HESS, Magic) Air shower arrays(Milagro) The Mystery of the Missing PeVatrons • SNRs best candidates for Galactic cosmic ray accelerators • But no SNR spectrum extends above a few 10 TeV • Possible reason: “Direct” high energy -ray emission only in first few hundred years • Detection still possible by observing secondary -rays produced in nearby clouds • Milagro better suited than Cherenkov telescopes Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
MGRO J2031+41 MGRO J1852+01 MGRO J2019+37 VERITAS observation MGRO J1908+06 MGRO J2032+37 MGRO J2043+36 2007 Milagro Sky Survey At 12 TeV Abdo thesis defense, March 2007 • MGRO 2019+37: not seen by VERITAS in first observation consistency requires < 2.2 • MGRO J2031+41: Magic measures E-2 spectrum Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
Gamma-ray Spectrum of MGRO J1908+06 • Again E-2 spectrum;extends up to 100 TeV ! • Strong indicator of proton acceleration in this source Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
The Role of Neutrino Telescopes • Air shower array currently only in Northern Hemisphere • Photon production ambiguous • Cherenkov telescopes have only small field of view (few deg2) • cover only small part of sky (at a time) • large photon background in star forming region (e.g. Cygnus)can hide sources • Neutrinos unambiguous sign for hadronic acceleration • Neutrino telescope properties fit well to air shower arrays • “all sky” sensitivity • increasing sensitivity with energy (small background) • angular resolution O(1º) Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
Neutrino spectra for all sources Gamma and Neutrino Spectra Spectra for MGRO J1908+06 • Assumed E-2 with Milagro normaliztion (MGRO J1908+06 index = 2.1) • spectrum cutoff @ 180 TeV MGRO J1852+01 MGRO J2019+37 MGRO J1908+06 MGRO J2031+41MGRO J2043+36 MGRO J2032+37 10-11 10-10 E2flux (TeV s-1 cm-2) E2flux (TeV s-1 cm-2) 10-11 gamma flux 10-12 10-12 neutrino flux 10-13 10-13 1 1 10 1000 100 10 1000 100 Ethresh (TeV) Ethresh (TeV) Halzen, Kappes, O’Murchadha: arXiv:0803.0314 Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
Significance for MGRO J1908+06 (5 years) • IceCube (80 strings) effective area (with quality cuts) • Search window: Halzen, Kappes, O’Murchadha: arXiv:0803.0314 1 # events p value observed events signal + atm. 10 2 calculated signal events 1 3 1 10 100 1 10 100 Ethresh (TeV) Ethresh (TeV) Milagro measurements favor lower sensitivity curve (dashed line) 2 - 2.5 after 5 years Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
Significance for all 6 Milagro sources after 5 years Halzen, Kappes, O’Murchadha: arXiv:0803.0314 • p-value = 10-4 after 5 years but large error band (not shown) • Optimal threshold @ 30 TeV (determined by loss of signal events) Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
# events (arb. units) Correlated Skymap Simulated Neutrino Skymaps IC80 (5 years) Not actual way to analyse data ! Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France
Summary • Cosmic ray sources (PeVatrons) should leave imprint on Milagro sky map • Milagro observes several hotspots with apparently hard spectra maybe first PeVatron(s) discovered (MGRO J1908+06) • If these are the cosmic ray sources IceCube will be able to see them with time (best sensitivity above several 10 TeV) • MGRO J1852+01 and MGRO J1908+06 also visible (50%)by Mediterranean detectors More information in Halzen, Kappes, O’Murchadha: arXiv:0803.0314 Alexander Kappes, 3rd VLVnT Workshop, Toulon France