280 likes | 459 Views
Volumetric Properties of High RAP Mixtures Based on Calculated Bulk Specific Gravities of RAP and Constituent Aggregates. Nassim Sabahfer Mustaque Hossain , Ph.D.,P.E . . Department of Civil Engineering Kansas State University. Outline . Background Problem Statement Objective
E N D
Volumetric Properties of High RAP Mixtures Based on Calculated Bulk Specific Gravities of RAP and Constituent Aggregates NassimSabahferMustaqueHossain, Ph.D.,P.E. Department of Civil EngineeringKansas State University
Outline • Background • Problem Statement • Objective • Methodology • Laboratory Testing • Results • Conclusions & Recommendations • Acknowledgements
Background - Reclaimed Asphalt Pavement (RAP) • Approx. 100 million tons of RAP produced each year and 80 million tons are reused • Useful alternative to virgin aggregates in HMA: • Reduces cost • 20% RAP with 5% binder • 1% savings in new binder • Enables recycling • Conserves energy RAP Stockpile at Shilling Construction Co., Manhattan, KS
Problem Statement • Superpave mix design is predominantly used now and permits use of RAP • Superpave volumetric mix design is highly dependent on properties like VMA, VFA, and Dust-to-Binder Ratio • These parameters need blend bulk aggregate specific gravity in the calculation process • RAP aggregate specific gravity is tricky
Objectives • Compare RAP aggregate bulk specific gravity (Gsb) obtained from various methods • Investigate influence of this Gsb on the calculated VMA • Investigate effect of asphalt absorption assumption • Study RAP maximum theoretical specific gravity (Gmm) as RAP Gsb
Methodology • Choose RAP sources (5) • Run maximum specific gravity tests (Gmm) on two replicates of each RAP • Obtain RAP aggregates via (a) extraction and (b) ignition oven burn off • Sieve into coarse (plus #4) and fine (minus #4) fractions • Run bulk specific gravity tests and compare • Compute VMA and compare
Measured RAP Properties * Ignition oven
RAP Aggregate Bulk Specific Gravity • Method #1 • Split extracted aggregates into coarse and fine fractions • Determine bulk specific gravity of each fraction • Method #2 • Same as #1; use burned off aggregates
RAP Aggregate Bulk Specific Gravity • Method #3 • Determine RAP Gmm • Determine RAP binder content • Calculate Gse of RAP: • Assume or know asphalt absorption, Pba • Calculate Gsb of RAP aggregate:
Statistical Analysis • Comparison of Gsb
VMA Obtained Using Gsb from Different Methods (Shilling RAP)
Conclusions • Gsbsobtained from the ignition oven and solvent extraction methods are similar but both are different from that based on Gse • Statistically RAP Gmm is not significantly different from Gsbobtained from the ignition oven or solvent extraction method • VMA obtained from Gse-based Gsb is significantly different from the VMA’s obtained from other Gsbs • Difference in VMA increases considerably as the RAP content increases
Recommendations • RAP aggregate Gsb using either from the extraction or the ignition oven test method should be used in design of Superpave mixtures with RAP
Acknowledgements • This study has been sponsored by the Kansas Department of Transportation (KDOT) • Project Monitor: Brian Coree, Ph.D., P.E.