1 / 16

Adverse Child Sex Ratios Challenges for Development

Adverse Child Sex Ratios Challenges for Development. International Workshop on Feminist Economics in China and India Mary E John. The Adverse Child Sex Ratio. Does the story begin with Amartya Sen? Colonial north west India and female infanticide

neveah
Download Presentation

Adverse Child Sex Ratios Challenges for Development

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Adverse Child Sex RatiosChallenges for Development International Workshop on Feminist Economics in China and India Mary E John

  2. The Adverse Child Sex Ratio • Does the story begin with Amartya Sen? • Colonial north west India and female infanticide • 1970s: Demographers discover long term declines in overall sex ratios; correlated with poverty, low health and work patterns • Women’s organisations and health activists discover abuse of amniocentesis testing for foetal abnormalities in 1982

  3. The 1990s • Joint activism by women and health groups results in first legislation against sex determination testing in Maharashtra in 1986 • 1991 Census data show a decline in both overall sex ratio to 927 and CSR (0-6) 945 • But north-western states CSR around 900 • National law to regulate pre-natal diagnostic techniques (PNDT Act) 1994

  4. A new moment: 2001 Census • For the first time national CSR drops to 927, below overall sex ratio (indeed overall sex ratio registers a small improvement to 933) • Huge drops in states in north west India and especially in urban areas • Wide scale adoption of sex selective abortion especially through ultrasound • Also high rates of female child mortality in selective areas

  5. Problems • Uneven regional patterns • “Prosperity Effect” • Correlations of high education, lower fertility with skewed child sex ratios • Two child norm • Impunity of Medical Establishment

  6. Responses • State: PCPNDT Act (revised) in 2004 • Various states launch Schemes for the “girl child” • Religious and caste organisations now join the fray, given very low CSRs among Sikhs and Hindus • New researches both macro and micro • NGO campaigns • International focus

  7. Planning Families, Planning Gender • Study conducted by a team of researchers in low CSR districts in PU, HA, HP, RA, MP • In depth analyses of contextual factors at work in these diverse contexts • Ranging from poverty to affluence • Low CSRs especially among some groups and sites • But not specific to particular castes and classes

  8. Patterns of low CSR • Diverse patterns • Sex selection most prevalent and growing • High female child mortality in pockets • Cases of infanticide

  9. Social Indicators • Widespread schooling for girls • Higher education in Pu, Hp, Ha, where girls even outnumber boys • Low work participation rates overall • Invisibility of women’s work • Rising ages at marriage – 16 in MP and 21 in HP

  10. Fertility Patterns • Stated preferences “one boy, one girl”, weak in MP strong in HP • Fertility declines everywhere to different degrees • Revealed preferences: growing proportion of families with one boy, one girl; but also two boys, two boys, one girl…

  11. Fertility (contd.) • Tiny proportion of families willing to have only girls • One son norm among families in Punjab • “At least one son, at most one daughter” • Not just son preference • Daughter aversion

  12. Why? • Intergenerational transfer of resources • New ‘costs’ of having a daughter with economic growth • Education, health, care till adulthood • Anxieties over daughter’s sexuality • Marriage remains the compulsory institution

  13. Problems and differences • Aggressive use of technology by medical establishment locally and globally, ever newer technologies • Shortage of “women” and “bare branches” • Traditional and/or new forms of gender discrimination • Ethics and language of choice • Sex selection and the right to abortion

  14. 2011 • Predictions and speculations about Census 2011 • A turnaround or peaking of the practice? • Or even more rampant effects of son preference and daughter aversion?

More Related