1 / 19

Reading Argument

Reading Argument. Chapter 1 Notes. Argument. The act of asserting, supporting, and defending a claim. The primary motive behind academic argument is to make others see the wisdom of a position or perspective. Rhetoric.

nida
Download Presentation

Reading Argument

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Reading Argument Chapter 1 Notes

  2. Argument • The act of asserting, supporting, and defending a claim. • The primary motive behind academic argument is to make others see the wisdom of a position or perspective

  3. Rhetoric • The process of recognizing and using the most effective strategies for influencing thought. • A study of how people are persuaded into their beliefs • A study of the ways in which different uses of language impact people in a variety of situations

  4. Argument Structure • CLAIM: The main argumentative position (thesis) being put forward • Support: comes in various forms and gives substance and legitimacy to the claim. The support convinces the audience to accept the claim.

  5. Reading an Argument • Noticing and then evaluating claims and their support • Some claims are easy to spot. Others are subtle. • Reading an argument requires looking for claims • What is the essay up to? • What is it trying to persuade me of? • What is the author’s purpose?

  6. Types of Claims • Claims of fact: a condition exists, has existed, or will exist • Claims of Value: something reflects a particular quality (good, bad, unfair, etc). It may assert approval or disapproval. • Claims of policy: argue that some action should be taken or some change made. A change in behavior, policy, approach, attitude

  7. Revelatory Claims • Attempts to do more that argue an opinion • Tries to reveal an unfamiliar topic or reveal a new layer of a familiar topic • Change readers’ thinking because they show something new.

  8. Support • Evidence: authorities, testimony, facts, stats • Examples: allusions, anecdotes, illustrations, scenarios • Appeals: to logic, emotions, character, value, need

  9. Evidence • A type of support that already exists • Must explain the relevance of the evidence • Authorities: experts who offer specialized knowledge • Support your own claims • Show opposing claims • Help to explain a topic • Help to give history or context to the argument

  10. Testimony • An eyewitness or 1st hand account • Gives a personal angle to the issue • Invites reader/audience in to the writer’s vision of the world

  11. Facts • Agreed upon bits of knowledge that do not require further support in an argument • Verified claims • Usually formally cited

  12. Stats • Figures drawn from surveys, experimentation, and date analysis • Stats can be used dishonestly • Origins should be revealed

  13. Examples: specific occurrences of a phenomenon • Allusions: references to some public knowledge from history, current events, pop culture, religion, or lit • Used to support ideas • By making connections to the culturally shared bit of knowledge, allusions link an argument to the world beyond it

  14. Anecdote • Short accounts of a particular event or incident • Given in the form of a brief story that supports a point • Draw a audience into a particular scene

  15. Illustrations • Graphic description or representations of an idea

  16. Scenarios • Fictional or hypothetical example • Help audience envision an abstract point • Signal the audience that they are in a hypothetical

  17. Counterargument • Refute claims or positions opposed to those of the writer/speaker • Must explain how the opposition is wrong

  18. Concession • Involves acknowledging or granting value to an opposing claim • Can actually strengthen an argument • Anticipates an opposing claim • Show that writer/speaker has a reasonable understanding of the situation

  19. Qualifiers • Focus on the arguer’s claims • Acknowledge the limits of those claims • Prevent arguers from making claims that are to extreme • Perhaps, maybe, seems, could • Be careful not to over-qualify

More Related