150 likes | 163 Views
Summary of Session #15 in Austin, aims for RevCom phase approval of P802.15.1, upcoming meetings, planned motions, and SBs summary.
E N D
IEEE 802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks™ TG1 Opening Report November 2001 Austin, TX USA Ian Gifford, Consultant
Contents • Summary • Motion Planning • Overview of Session #15/Austin • Objectives • Submissions • Session Graphic • RevCom Submission • [01462r1aP802-15_WG-P802.15.1-RevCom-Submission.pdf] • Project Planning Status • Next Meeting • Tentative Needs for Dallas • Objectives for Dallas • Drafting History Ian Gifford, Consultant
Summary [1 of 3] • Task Group 1 (TG1) is deriving a draft standard from the Bluetooth™ specification under IEEE PAR 802.15.1 • At Session #15, motion SEC, address WG & SEC comments, IF ANY • achieve majority approval from the WG & SEC motions and enter RevCom phase. Pre submitted 26Oct01. • During the Jul01/Nov01 between-session-period • SB1 ballot & resolution • SB2 ballot & RevCom Application for approval of P802.15.1 • IEEE-SA, PatCom, RevCom, and BSIG Ian Gifford, Consultant
Summary [2 of 3] • SB2 has 2 Disapproving Voters and 19 unresolved comments (comment #7 is resolved as the 3rd DISAPPROVING Voter changed to a YES w/ comments.) • The TG1 will update 00375r3P802-15_TG1-Project-Planning.pdf once SEC approval is achieved. ETA 17Nov01. Ian Gifford, Consultant
Summary [3 of 3] • The 802.15.1 submittal will be reviewed by RevCom. Preliminary comments will be sent to Project 802.15.1 by the middle of November. • Scheduled StB Committee Meetings 4-6Dec01: • http://standards.ieee.org/board/stdsbd/meeting-notice.html • 4Dec01 PatCom - 6.2 Letter of Assurance from Bluetooth SIG, Inc. for P802.15.1 • 5Dec01 RevCom - P802.15.1/D1.0.1 New: "Standard for Information Technology… Ian Gifford, Consultant
Planned Motions • Motions • #1 Wed, 14Nov01 to Full WG • #2 Fri, 16Nov01 to SEC Ian Gifford, Consultant
Session #15/Austin – Motion #1 to the Full WG • Move to submit P802.15.1/D1.0.1-2001 to 802 SEC for approval of submission to RevCom. Non Technical 50% (Procedural) Moved: ? Second: ? Y/N/A: // Note: TG1 pre-submitted D1.0.1 to RevCom on 26Oct01. Ian Gifford, Consultant
Session #15/Austin – Motion #2 to the 802 SEC • Move that the ExCom forward IEEE Draft 802.15.1/D1.0.1 to RevCom. Non Technical 50% (Procedural) Moved: ? Second: ? Y/N/A: // Note: TG1 pre-submitted D1.0.1 to RevCom on 26Oct01. Ian Gifford, Consultant
Session #15/Austin – Graphic Ian Gifford, Consultant
IEEE 802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks™ Sponsor Ballots (SBs) Summary Report Ian Gifford, Consultant
SBs Summary Report • Sponsor Ballot #1, passed @89% • 30 Day Electronic Ballot • 27Jul01 Opened • 25Aug01 Closed • Sponsor Ballot #2, passed @89% • 10 Day Electronic Recirculation Ballot • 2Oct01 Opened • 11Oct01 Closed The BRC continues to communicate to the three (3) DISAPPROVING Balloters and we are happy to report that one (1) DISAPPROVING Balloter has reviewed the resolutions and changed his initial and recirculation vote from DISAPPROVING to YES WITH COMMENTS (see –01/420r10 Comment #7) on 12Oct01. This 3 to 2 change to the sponsor ballots up the affirmation to 93%. Ian Gifford, Consultant
SB1 Summary Report • P802.15.1/D0.9.2 • Closing date: 2001-08-25 • The report is the result from the group: 0000130 • 1. This ballot has met the 75% returned ballot requirement. • 33 eligible people in this ballot group. • 26 affirmative votes • 3 negative votes • 1 abstention votes • 30 votes received • 90% returned • 3% abstention • 2. The 75% affirmation requirement is being met. • 26 affirmative votes • 3 negative votes • 29 votes • 89% affirmative Source: -01/420r10 Ian Gifford, Consultant
Generalization of Negative Comments • Proposed standard operates in the same band as 802.11 • Coexistence not addressed • Optional power level of 100mw • Normative vs. Informative SDL • Technical disagreements (how it works vs. how it might work better) Ian Gifford, Consultant
Tentative Needs for Jan02 Interim • 21-25Jan02 (5 Days) • ~0 People TG1 leadership is not planning to attend the Jan02 Interim. Ian Gifford, Consultant
In conclusion, the Project 802.15.1 would like to leave you with this slide Ian Gifford, Consultant