340 likes | 892 Views
ANKLE INSTABILITY AND ASSOCIATED PATHOLOGIES. Brian A. Weatherby, MD Assistant Professor University of South Carolina School of Medicine Greenville Hospital System University Medical Center. Case Presentation. 16 y/o Female Cheerleader
E N D
ANKLE INSTABILITY AND ASSOCIATED PATHOLOGIES Brian A. Weatherby, MD Assistant Professor University of South Carolina School of Medicine Greenville Hospital System University Medical Center
Case Presentation • 16 y/o Female Cheerleader • Multiple twisting injuries to ankle while stunting/tumbling • Tx = RICE, PT, bracing, taping • CANNOT perform 2° to pain with impact loading & repeated instability (in brace) • Recent onset of pain and “pinching” with walking
Case Presentation • Physical Exam • PROM Ankle (comparison) Limited DF • Pain at extreme DF • PROM Subtalar & Transverse Tarsal (comparison) WNL
Case Presentation • Physical Exam: • + Anterior Drawer Exam (comparison) • Reproduction of Pain Intra-articular Pathology
Case Presentation • Physical Exam: • + Talar Tilt (comparison)
Case Presentation • Physical Exam • TTP over antero-lateral ankle joint • TTP over antero-medial joint (intra-articular?)
Case Presentation • Physical Exam • + Single Leg Squat Test
Case Presentation • Physical Exam • NO Posterior Impingement
Case Presentation • Physical Exam • NO Cavus Foot deformity • NO Generalized Ligamentous Laxity
Ankle Sprains • Incidence = 1 in 10,000 persons per day • 21% of athletic injuries ankle • 45% of those basketball • Majority = Inversion & PF • 15-20% Pain & Dysfunction
Initial Treatment • Functional Rehabilitation Protocol • Renstrom et al. Sports Med 1999 • “Functional treatment produced no more sequelae than casting with or without surgical repair. Secondary surgical repair, even years after an injury, has results comparable to those of primary repair.” • Pihlajamaki et al. JBJS 2011 • Return to pre-injury level same for FRP & Surgery • Surgery did ↓ re-injury but had ↑ incidence of arthritic changes
Initial Treatment • Bracing • Orthotics (Cavus Foot)
Surgical Indications • Failed APPROPRIATE non-op treatment • Persistent instability/recurrent Gr II/III sprain • Activity related pain > 3 months • Correlate with MRI findings • Instability episodes with ADL’s • Continuous bracing not possible (work/skin) • NOT isolated pain • OCD • Loose body • Impingement
Surgical Repair • Brostrom-Gould Technique (Modified Brostrom) • Hamilton et al., FAI 1993 • 96% good to excellent • Lee et al., FAI 2011 • 94% good to excellent (w/out CFL)
Surgical Repair • Brostrom-Evans • Girard et al., FAI 1999 • > 250 lbs • > 10 years instability • Ligamentous Laxity • Heavy laborer
Associated Pathology • Soft Tissue Impingement • Wolin et al (1950) • “mensicoid lesion” • Ferkel et al (1990) • “meniscoid tissue” = hyaline cartilage with degenerative change and fibrosis • Synovial hyperplasia, subsynovial capillary proliferation
Associated Pathology • Soft Tissue Impingement • Bassett et al (1990) • Fibrotic thickening of the inferior slip of AITFL • Chronic rubbing may result in chondromalacia on talus
Associated Pathology • Osseous • Osteochondral Defect of Talus (postero-medial) • Bony Impingement • Loose Bodies Repetitive Subluxation Episodes (coronal & sagittal)Micro Trauma to bone/chondral surface Inflammatory Rxn/Insult ????
Associated Pathology • Taga et al., AJSM 1993 • 95% intra-articular pathology • Komenda & Ferkel, AJSM 1999 • 93% intra-articular pathology • Choi et al., AJSM 2008 • 96% intra-articular pathology
Associated Pathology • Okuda et al., AJSM 2002 • 63% chondral lesions • Hintermann et al., AJSM 2005 • 66% chondral lesions ANKLE ARTHROSCOPY VITAL ADJUNCT PROCEDURE
Associated Pathology • Tarsal Coalition Resection/Arthrodesis • Dislocating Peroneal Tendons Repair
Associated Pathology • Cavovarus Foot • Subtle Cavus Foot Correction • Ligamentous Laxity Augmented repair
Summary • Chronic ankle instability WILL develop in a certain # of athletes sustaining sprains • Mainstay in treatment is FRP & bracing • ALWAYS be aware of, recognize, and address associated pathologies • Ankle Ligament Reconstruction + Ankle arthroscopy is the GOLD STANDARD for surgical treatment