90 likes | 107 Views
Working with Witnesses in Regulatory Investigations. John D Fitzgerald BL. Regulatory. Regulatory crime vs Traditional/ ‘real’ crime Complexity Volume and scope of investigation Differences in evidence and penalties Natural justice applies. Investigations.
E N D
Working with Witnesses in Regulatory Investigations John D Fitzgerald BL
Regulatory Regulatory crime vs Traditional/ ‘real’ crime • Complexity • Volume and scope of investigation • Differences in evidence and penalties • Natural justice applies
Investigations • What is the difference between an investigation and an inspection? • When does an investigation begin? • Do the same rules apply?
Witnesses • What is the difference between a witness and a suspect? • When does a witness become a suspect? • Is there a difference between a suspect and a potential suspect? • Should I tell a witness that they may be under suspicion? • How much should I tell them of the nature of that suspicion?
Taking Statements • When should the statement be taken? • Can they be accompanied or legally advised? • Must every word be recorded? • What to leave out – irrelevant vs exculpatory material • What to put in – relevant vs suggested/coached material • Drafts and re-drafts • Disclosure
Search Warrants • When do I need a warrant? • How much information should I put forward in seeking the warrant?
What Powers Does the Warrant Give me? • Execution vs trawling exercise • Power to search place or people present • To what extent can the co-operation of those present be required – passwords, search terms etc.? • Can material that is not relevant to the search be taken away? • If the material is taken away for analysis, can the subject of the search be present for the analysis?
Search Warrants – What Problems Can Arise? • Commercial Sensitivity • Data Protection • Privacy • Privileged material