1 / 40

Fostering Geometric Thinking in the Middle Grades

Fostering Geometric Thinking in the Middle Grades. Education Development Center Newton, MA. Horizon Research, Inc. Chapel Hill, NC. Project supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant ESI-0353409. Knowledge for Teaching Geometry. Geometry content central to the middle grades

oria
Download Presentation

Fostering Geometric Thinking in the Middle Grades

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Fostering Geometric Thinking in the Middle Grades Education Development Center Newton, MA Horizon Research, Inc. Chapel Hill, NC Project supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant ESI-0353409

  2. Knowledge for Teaching Geometry • Geometry content central to the middle grades • Development of student geometric thinking related to this content • Related student conceptual hurdles and what research says about them • Middle-grades geometry as groundwork for high school geometry

  3. Fostering Geometric Thinking (FGT) • Identify productive ways of thinking in geometry (G-HOMs) • Create professional development materials based on G-HOMs • 40 hours  20 two-hour sessions • Group-study materials • Structured Exploration Process (Kelemanik et al. 1997) • Stages: Doing mathematics; Reflecting on the mathematics; Collecting student work; Analyzing student work; Reflecting on students’ thinking • G-HOMs framework is a lens for analysis • Create a multimedia book

  4. Fostering Geometric Thinking (FGT) • Field Test Research Questions: In what ways does the use of professional development materials that target students’ geometric ways of thinking… • Q1: …increase teachers’ content knowledge and understanding of student thinking in geometry and measurement? • Q2: …affect instructional practice in geometry?

  5. FGT Field Test • Groups randomly assigned to 2 conditions: Treatment (N=137), Wait-Listed Control (N=140) • Measures • Geometry Survey—pre/post • Multiple choice geometry problems • Open-ended questions about approaches to a problem • Open-ended questions about analyzing student work • Observations • Classrooms and teacher groups • Embedded task

  6. Geometric Habits of Mind (G-HOMs) • Reasoning with Relationships • Investigating Invariants • Generalizing Geometric Ideas • Balancing Exploration with Reflection

  7. Reasoning with Relationships Actively looking for relationships (e.g., congruence, similarity, parallelism, etc.), within and between geometric figures, in 1, 2, 3 dimensions, and using the relationships to help understanding or problem solving.

  8. Internal questions (that is, questions problem solvers ask themselves) Include: • "How are these figures alike?" • "In how many ways are they alike?"   • "How are these figures different?" • "What else here fits this description?" • "What would I have to do to this object to make it like that object?" • "What if I think about this relationship in a different dimension?“ • “Can symmetry help me here?”

  9. Which two make the best pair?

  10. Generalizing Geometric Ideas Generalizing in mathematics is “passing from the consideration of a given set of objects to that of a larger set, containing the given one." (Polya) This GHOM is characterized by wondering if “I have them all,” and by wanting to understand and describe the "always" and the "every" related to geometric phenomena.

  11. Internal questions include: • "Does this happen in every case?" • "Why would this happen in every case?“ • "Have I found all the ones that fit this description?" • "Can I think of examples when this is not true, and, if so, should I then revise my generalization?” • "Would this apply in other dimensions?"

  12. In squares, the diagonals always intersect in 90-degree angles:

  13. Investigating Invariants An invariant is something about a situation that stays the same, even as parts of the situation vary. This habit of mind shows up, for example, in analyzing which attributes of a figure remain the same and which change when the figure is transformed in some way (e.g., through translations, reflections, rotations, dilations, dissections, combinations, or controlled distortions).

  14. Internal questions include: • "How did that get from here to there?" • "Is it possible to transform this figure so it becomes that one?" • "What changes? Why?" • "What stays the same? Why?" • "What happens if I keep changing this figure?" • "What happens if I apply multiple transformations to the figure?"

  15. “No matter how much I collapse the rhombus, the diagonals still meet at a right angle!”

  16. Balancing Exploration with Reflection Trying various ways to approach a problem and regularly stepping back to take stock. This balance of "what if.." with "what did I learn from trying that?" is representative of this habit of mind. Often the “what iffing” is playful exploration tempered by taking stock. Sometimes it is looking at the problem from different angles—e.g., imagining a final state and reasoning backwards.

  17. Internal questions include: • "What happens if I (draw a picture, add to/take apart this picture, work backwards from the ending place, etc.….)?" • "What did that action tell me?" • “How can my earlier attempts to solve the problem inform my approach now?” • "What intermediate steps might help?" • "What if I already had the solution….What would it look like?"

  18. Sketch if it’s possible (or say why it’s impossible): A quadrilateral that has exactly 2 right angles and no parallel lines

  19. "I'll work backwards and imagine the figure has been drawn. What can I say about it? One thing: the two right angles can't be right next to each other. Otherwise, you’d have two parallel sides. So, what if I draw two right angles and stick them together…."

  20. Knowledge for Teaching Geometry • Geometry content central to the middle grades • Development of student geometric thinking related to this content • Related student conceptual hurdles and what research says about them • Middle-grades geometry as groundwork for high school geometry

  21. Knowledge for Teaching Geometry • Geometry content central to the middle grades • Three FGT content strands: Properties of geometric objects; Geometric transformations; and Measurement of geometric objects • Example: a problem from the last of these strands

  22. Finding Area in Different Ways • Work on the problem (both parts, if you have time) • Compare with 1 or 2 people around you. What content is featured here? Can you identify some of the G-HOMs you were using, or hear in the account of others’ thinking?

  23. One group’s thinking "We figured the area of the pentagon was 25 square units, by cutting it up into little triangles. Then we thought 'Well, that is the area of a 5x5 square. Let's try to make that square out of the pentagon.' Then we started cutting and rotating and matching pieces."

  24. An indicator of Balancing exploration and reflection “Describes what the final state would look like."

  25. Knowledge for Teaching Geometry • Development of student geometric thinking related to this content • Looking for potential, not just deficit • G-HOM framework as a lens • Internal questions as bridges to practice

  26. Looking at student work • In pairs or trios, look at the samples and discuss, citing evidence: • Where might there be potential in the thinking? • Are there any signs of conceptual misunderstandings? • What G-HOMs seem to be at play in the thinking? (Use your G-HOM descriptors and lists of internal questions.)

  27. Knowledge for Teaching Geometry • Related student conceptual hurdles and what research says about them • Research summaries for the 3 content strands • A questioning framework, with particular attention to assessing questions

  28. Example: Understanding area • Mental structuring of space is essential to understanding area. Students go through several stages of structuring space. • Even as they move through the stages, they may not connect their structuring of space to the area formula.

  29. They may just see computing the area of a 4- unit by 7-unit rectangle as 4 times 7 rather than an array of 4 rows of 7 units in each row.

  30. Transcript • First consider the problem the students are engaged in. How would you think about it? • Read the transcript once to understand the flow of the interaction. • Using the Questioning Framework, find a teacher question you think is an Assessing question. • Compare notes with neighbor. Discuss “What is the payoff for the teacher in asking this and other questions here?” “What are the costs?”

  31. Knowledge for Teaching Geometry • Middle-grades geometry as groundwork for high school geometry • Proof: explanation, verification, discovery (De Villiers) • Reasoned conjectures (Herbst) • Multimodal communication (Chval, Khisty)

  32. Contact Information Mark Driscoll mdriscoll@edc.org Rachel Wing rwing@edc.org Fostering Geometric Thinking website www.geometric-thinking.com

  33. .

More Related