1 / 22

DISCOH Scientific Workshop 29-31 March 2012

Sustainability of the Peruvian anchoveta -based supply chains from sea to plate ANCHOVETA-SC PROJECT status report Angel Avadi , IRD, Université Montpellier II. DISCOH Scientific Workshop 29-31 March 2012. Outline. The ANCHOVETA-SC project Supply chain modelling and evaluation

paco
Download Presentation

DISCOH Scientific Workshop 29-31 March 2012

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Sustainability of the Peruvian anchoveta-based supply chains from sea to plateANCHOVETA-SC PROJECT status reportAngel Avadi, IRD, Université Montpellier II DISCOH Scientific Workshop 29-31 March2012

  2. Outline • The ANCHOVETA-SC project • Supplychainmodelling and evaluation • Modelling • Sustainabilityindicators • Initial LCA results

  3. ANCHOVETA-SC • Project financed by IRD and project partners • Coordinator: Pierre Fréon, IRD • Location: Peru • Duration: 4 years (01.2010 - 12-2013) • Theme: Environmental and socio-economic assessment of major international supply chains consuming Peruvian anchoveta (aligned to WP5 DISCOH) • Outputs: • Sustainability assessment • Policy and sustainability suggestions • PhD thesis (plus other theses)

  4. Focus • Characterisation of biophisicalflowsalongthesupplychains (SC) • Featuringecosystem-SC interactions • Comparison of scenariosbasedondifferentfishingintensities and “fate” of landings (DHC vs IHC) • Sustainabilitycomparison of chains/scenariosbasedupon: • Energy performance • Environmentalimpacts (LCA) • Seafood-specificimpactcategories • Nutritionalvalue • Selected socio-economicindicators

  5. 1) Simplified SC diagram Inputs Anchoveta, predators Canned, cured, frozen Ecosystemdynamics DHC processing Inputs Emissions Fisheries Con-sumption Inputs (includingcrops) Emissions Inputs Inputs Chinesefinfish? Europeansalmon? Shrimp? Reduction Aquafeed Aquaculture Anchoveta Emissions Emissions Emissions

  6. Modellingecosystem-SC interactions EcopathwithEcosym Trophic model Umberto Material and energyflowmodel

  7. 2) Scenarios and 3) Indicators Harvest Fate Indicatorsrationale • To compare feed ingredients, feed formulations and seafood products: • Grossenergycontent (MJ/kg) • EdibleproteinEnergyReturnOnInvestment (%) • BioticResource Use (g C/kg) • EcologicalFootprint (ha/t) • To compare intermediate and final seafood products, and competing supply chains: • LCA impactcategories • Socio-economicindicators (tobedefined) Status quo (maximum anchoveta stock exploitation) Status quo (1-2% DHC) Status quo (maximum anchoveta stock exploitation) Increase in DHC (10-15% DHC) Diversification (reduction of anchoveta catches + increase of predator catches) Mixedmodelwith anchoveta DHC/IHC and anchoveta predators DHC

  8. LCAscarriedout • Twofishmealplants: • a conventional one producing only Fair Average Quality (FAQ) fishmeal and using mainly heavy fuel as energy source • a more modern steam plant producing both FAQ and prime quality fishmeal and using both heavy fuel and natural gas • Detailedinventories of industrial anchoveta fleetunderprocessing • preliminary LCA of representative “average“ 395 m3 vesselcategory • Twoaquafeedplants (Iquitos) • A pilotfacility and a workingcommercialfacility • Oneaquaculturefarm (Iquitos) • PeruvianAmazonianspecies

  9. Iquitos Colossomafarm • Colossomamacropomum (Gamitana), a largeAmazonianfish • Farm: 30 ha, convertedfrom rain forest, 11.2 ha of ponds (no wastewatertreatment), production: 100 t/a, feed: 150 t/a

  10. Network: Colossomafarm

  11. Characterisation: Colossomafarm • Mainimpactcontributors: feed and rain foresttransformation FRY

  12. Iquitos Aquafeedplants • 2 plantsvisited: • 30 t/a IIAP plant • 8 t/m commercialplant (competingwith Purina, etc.) • < 6% Peruvianfishmealcontent in feeds • > 33% Boliviansoymealcontent • > 45% local cornmealcontent

  13. Network: Aquafeedplant (8 t/m)

  14. Characterisation: Aquafeedplant • Mainimpactcontributor: use phase LCA FISHMEAL PLANT

  15. Aquafeedplant use phase • Impactcontributors in use phase: • oil-poweredelectricity • feedingredients, mainlyBoliviansoymeal (duetoclearcutting in Bolivia)

  16. Network: Hypothetical trout feed plant (43% fishmeal)

  17. Comparison of feedplants

  18. Network: Fishing vessel 395 m3

  19. Designremarks • Key aquacultureproductshaven’tbeencharacterisedforPeruvianconditions • E.g.Peruvian rice and corn. • Proxieswereused and adaptationsintroducedwhenpossible (e.g.BoliviansoymealadaptedfromBrazilian) • Key industrial productshaven’tbeencharacterised, yetit’scompositionisknown/estimated • E.g.electric and combustionengines

  20. LCA results • Construction and maintenance of (reduction, feed) plants contributes negligibly • Fuel use is the main contributor to impacts in all activities (fishing, reduction, feed processing) • Feed provision is the main contributor to impacts in extensive Peruvian aquaculture • The sourcing of feed ingredients is a critical factor for associated environmental impacts of feeds • E.g. Brazilian soymeal performing much worst than Bolivian one, due to clear cutting of rain forest vs. of shrublands.

  21. Further (ongoing) work • EwEscenariosdefinition and integrationwithUmberto • Selection of and data gatheringfor socio-economicindicators • Statisticalprocessing of fleetinventories and comprehensive LCA of fleetcategories • FurtherLCAs: • Canning, curing and freezing plants • Carnivore fish and shrimp aquaculture farms • Gatheringsupplychainsoperative data and LCIs • Backgroundprocessesforprovision of feedingredients • Published LCI/LCA data mustberecalculatedtoensureconsistency

  22. Gracias por su atención… Preguntas, comentarios? XXXX XXXX

More Related