1 / 20

Invoking learner voice & developing leadership: what matters to learners?

Invoking learner voice & developing leadership: what matters to learners?. Callie Grant Edu-lead Conference 13 – 15 April 2015. MACRO CONTEXT. ELM an emerging field; popular & expanding Absence of clear boundaries & unified, cumulative knowledge base

patia
Download Presentation

Invoking learner voice & developing leadership: what matters to learners?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Invoking learner voice & developing leadership: what matters to learners? Callie Grant Edu-lead Conference 13 – 15 April 2015

  2. MACRO CONTEXT • ELM an emerging field; popular & expanding • Absence of clear boundaries & unified, cumulative knowledge base • Field of diversification & fragmentation; privileges practice over theory • Troubled field • Research productivity a growing concern • “A great deal of (unfocused, unstructured & uncoordinated) small-scale & qualitative research” (NRF, 2009) • Challenge: build scholarship & credibility • Strategic research agenda • My particular research interest: educational leadership

  3. LEADERSHIP & LEARNER VOICE • Leadership well studied – although contested • Research regarding adolescent development is limited (Whitehead, 2009) • In SA, learner leadership rarely features on research agenda & voices of learners are often ignored • ‘Student voice’ describes ways in which learners share in decision-making in schools • It’s about true democracy within schools • However, schools tend to teach learners to be passive participants – adults tend to speak too readily on behalf of learners (Fielding, 2001)

  4. B ED HONOURS (ELM ELECTIVE) • RU service learning initiative • Focus: leadership development of learners • Learner leadership clubs • Purpose: develop learner ‘voice’ and ‘hear them’ • “Learn how to become citizens prepared to actively engage in their communities & participate in democracy” (Mitre & Gross, 2009) • Informed by work of Mitre & Gross (2009) – pyramid of student voice • i) being heard • ii)collaborating with adults • iii) building capacity for leadership

  5. Pyramid of student voice (Mitre & Gross, 2009)

  6. B ED HONOURS (ELM ELECTIVE) CONTINUED • Honours elective: Five weekly contact sessions per year – four phases of the intervention • Critical reflexivity of teachers as leaders • Research focus: (How) can learner leadership clubs contribute to the development of leadership in learners? • As researcher: Track the development of leadership during the 10 month period • Methods: Reflective journaling; interviewing • Assessment: Seminar presentation & development of a journal article (plus coursework component & DP)

  7. WHAT ARE WE TRYING TO DO? • Programmatic approach • Track Honours ELM elective over 4 years • Longitudinal qualitative (multi-case) study • Is leadership developed &, if so, in what ways? • Phase 1:Hons students; Course facilitators; Methods: Documents (exam equivalents), interviews, self-reflective journals • Phase 2: School visits: Learners, SMT; Methods: questionnaires, observation, interviews • Framing; distributed leadership & CHAT

  8. WHAT HAVE WE LEARNT ABOUT ‘WHAT MATTERS TO LEARNERS’ AFTER TWO CYCLES?

  9. The SA case study (2013)

  10. The Namibian case study (2014) [LL&TL]

  11. Club activities

  12. LEARNING FROM THE TWO CASE STUDIES • 1. Phenomenon of learner leadership not common across case studies I enjoy this because it’s a brand new angle for me; I never had to learn about learner leadership. It’s always, as a teacher you must do this, but it’s never about the learner. So that was something new (FGI, 2013)

  13. LEARNING FROM THE TWO CASE STUDIES • 2. Clubs offered a space for development of learner voice & leadership - NB of healthy relationships But now I’m looking at my learners from another angle: that they have souls; they are human beings; they have the potential. It’s just that I have to make sure they have to discover who they are, so basically my growing or my growth will enable them to grow as well (FGI, 2013) - relational power – building of trust – powerful people (Smyth, 2006)

  14. LEARNING FROM THE TWO CASE STUDIES • 3. Learners have leadership potential - generative & non-threatening space - articulate what good leaders need to know, do & be - development of voice 1st step in development of leadership - ‘invoke’ rather than ‘invite’ student voice (Angus, 2006) - conscious process requiring modelling & teaching

  15. LEARNING FROM THE TWO CASE STUDIES • 4. Issues which ‘mattered’ to learners • Physical environment of schools • Focus on English proficiency amongst learners • Improved learner conduct • Developments pertaining to the extra-mural curriculum • Leadership training initiatives • Similar to what matters to teachers? • We need to really ‘listen’ • Allies

  16. LEARNING FROM THE TWO CASE STUDIES • 5. Take-up as a whole school initiative problematic - staff “distanced themselves from the whole process” (FGI, 2014) - “It must not disturb the programme of the school” (FGI, 14) • Need for more preparatory work by university lecturers • Unit of change: the whole school (Smyth, 2006) • “Should not act as an adjunct to an institution’s activities, but needs to be woven into all aspects of the institution … towards a leadership model that is increasingly student-led” (Shuttle, 2007, p. 45)

  17. External examiner’s comment • These projects have the potential for being published to share the results with a wider community of leaders and educational leadership practitioners and to be further investigated at a higher level of research engagement as a way of contributing to this body of knowledge (External examiner’s report, November 2013)

  18. Researching learner leadership: future directions • Publication opportunities emerging from Phase 1 - descriptions of 44 clubs - across the case studies: a meta-analysis - A further two case studies (2015 & 2016) - intersection of teacher & learner leadership • Research opportunities emerging from Phase 2 - In-depth analysis of levels of success of a sample of clubs from Phase 1 - Continuation of some clubs from Honours through to Masters

  19. CONCLUDING COMMENTS • If we hope to provide quality education for all, development of authentic learner leadership critical • Requires “courageous forms of leadership that fearlessly promote student ownership & student voice in respect of learning” (Smyth, 2006) • Necessitates a transformative approach based on dialogue & strong relationships & the ability to facilitate critical inquiry (Shields, 2004)

  20. Prof Callie GrantFaculty of EducationRhodes University046 6223089c.grant@ru.ac.za

More Related