240 likes | 577 Views
10-2. Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Rewards. Intrinsic = Inside. Feeling of Job Well Done. Pride. Sense of Achievement. Extrinsic = Outside. Praise. Salary Increase. Status. Recognition. Promotions. Gifts. . . . . . . 10-3. Most Commonly Used Extrinsic Rewards. Source: Incentive Federation. 10-4. Evolution of Human Relations Management Concepts.
E N D
1. 10-1 Nickels McHugh McHugh
2. 10-2 Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 1: Explain Taylor’s scientific management.
See text page: 260
Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Rewards
This slide illustrates visually to students that intrinsic rewards come from within an individual, whereas extrinsic rewards come from outside a person.
Intrinsic means from within, when you have a drive to succeed whereby workers are motivated by purpose, passion, and mission.
Extrinsic rewards are often temporary and driven by money, recognition and results.
Explain to the students that intrinsic rewards are long-lasting and managers should promote the following environment to foster those feelings:
Work is more fun.
Employees know the work they do is meaningful and worthwhile.
Problems are viewed as challenges, not as restraints.
It’s OK for employees to try new ways of doing tasks and to do new tasks that interest them.
Employees know when they’ve done a good job.
Empowerment increases motivation by giving the authority to set goals, make decisions, and solve problems.
(Source: Issacous)Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 1: Explain Taylor’s scientific management.
See text page: 260
Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Rewards
This slide illustrates visually to students that intrinsic rewards come from within an individual, whereas extrinsic rewards come from outside a person.
Intrinsic means from within, when you have a drive to succeed whereby workers are motivated by purpose, passion, and mission.
Extrinsic rewards are often temporary and driven by money, recognition and results.
Explain to the students that intrinsic rewards are long-lasting and managers should promote the following environment to foster those feelings:
Work is more fun.
Employees know the work they do is meaningful and worthwhile.
Problems are viewed as challenges, not as restraints.
It’s OK for employees to try new ways of doing tasks and to do new tasks that interest them.
Employees know when they’ve done a good job.
Empowerment increases motivation by giving the authority to set goals, make decisions, and solve problems.
(Source: Issacous)
3. 10-3 Most Commonly Used Extrinsic Rewards Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 1: Explain Taylor’s scientific management.
Most Commonly Used Extrinsic Rewards
This slide displays the most common rewards used by companies to motivate employees.
Extrinsic Rewards include the following:
Pay
Improved working environment or conditions
Status
Security
While these rewards do offer some value, there is much research that indicates many problems with extrinsic motivation. Share with the students some of those ideas:
Extrinsic rewards do not produce permanent changes
Extrinsic rewards reduce intrinsic interest
The use of extrinsic rewards can be controlling
Reinforcement of extrinsic rewards can lead to expectations of permanence in the form of job rewards.Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 1: Explain Taylor’s scientific management.
Most Commonly Used Extrinsic Rewards
This slide displays the most common rewards used by companies to motivate employees.
Extrinsic Rewards include the following:
Pay
Improved working environment or conditions
Status
Security
While these rewards do offer some value, there is much research that indicates many problems with extrinsic motivation. Share with the students some of those ideas:
Extrinsic rewards do not produce permanent changes
Extrinsic rewards reduce intrinsic interest
The use of extrinsic rewards can be controlling
Reinforcement of extrinsic rewards can lead to expectations of permanence in the form of job rewards.
4. 10-4 Evolution of Human Relations Management Concepts Scientific
Taylor
Gantt
Gilbreths Behavioral
Mayo
Maslow
Herzberg
McGregor
Ouchi
Vroom See Learning Goal 2: Describe the Hawthorne studies, and relate their significance to management.
See text pages: 262-263
See Learning Goal 3: Identify the levels of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, and relate their importance to employee motivation
See text pages: 263-265
See Learning Goal 4: Distinguish between the motivators and hygiene factors identified by Herzberg.
See text pages: 265-267
See Learning Goal 2: Describe the Hawthorne studies, and relate their significance to management.
See text pages: 262-263
See Learning Goal 3: Identify the levels of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, and relate their importance to employee motivation
See text pages: 263-265
See Learning Goal 4: Distinguish between the motivators and hygiene factors identified by Herzberg.
See text pages: 265-267
5. 10-5 Hawthorne studies Conducted by Elton Mayo (1927-1933)
First Experiment: Determine if lighting was a factor in productivity.
Next Experiments: Determine if other factors affected productivity.
These studies encouraged the study of human motivation. See Learning Goal 2: Describe the Hawthorne studies, and relate their significance to management.
See text pages: 262-263See Learning Goal 2: Describe the Hawthorne studies, and relate their significance to management.
See text pages: 262-263
6. 10-6 Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 3: Identify the levels of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, and relate their importance to employee motivation
See text pages: 263-265
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs
This slide reproduces the illustration of Maslow’s Hierarchy from the chapter.
Most people in the class may be familiar with Maslow and the premise of human needs recognition.
Use this opportunity to relate Maslow’s need theory to the work environment:
Workers require competitive salaries, benefits and clean work environments.
Employees have the need for security against termination in their jobs and the feeling of being safe against bodily harm while performing their job functions.
On the job workers have the need to feel a part of a successful group, driven by achievement.
Employees seek opportunities for advancement, empowerment, recognition, and responsibilities through additional work-related performance. Companies must attempt to satisfy these needs through opportunities within the organization.Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 3: Identify the levels of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, and relate their importance to employee motivation
See text pages: 263-265
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs
This slide reproduces the illustration of Maslow’s Hierarchy from the chapter.
Most people in the class may be familiar with Maslow and the premise of human needs recognition.
Use this opportunity to relate Maslow’s need theory to the work environment:
Workers require competitive salaries, benefits and clean work environments.
Employees have the need for security against termination in their jobs and the feeling of being safe against bodily harm while performing their job functions.
On the job workers have the need to feel a part of a successful group, driven by achievement.
Employees seek opportunities for advancement, empowerment, recognition, and responsibilities through additional work-related performance. Companies must attempt to satisfy these needs through opportunities within the organization.
7. 10-7 Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 4: Distinguish between the motivators and hygiene factors identified by Herzberg.
See text pages: 265-267
Herzberg’s Theory
This slide illustrates an additional “need” theory regarding workers and their job needs.
This theory is based on what an organization can do to fulfill the individual needs of workers while motivating them to excel.
The key component of Herzberg’s work was the opposite of “satisfaction” is “no satisfaction.” If the basic hygiene factors were not in place, a worker is not satisfied. To have a satisfied, motivated workforce, a company needs to provide the following:
Achievement
Recognition
Work Itself
Responsibility
Advancement
GrowthAlso available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 4: Distinguish between the motivators and hygiene factors identified by Herzberg.
See text pages: 265-267
Herzberg’s Theory
This slide illustrates an additional “need” theory regarding workers and their job needs.
This theory is based on what an organization can do to fulfill the individual needs of workers while motivating them to excel.
The key component of Herzberg’s work was the opposite of “satisfaction” is “no satisfaction.” If the basic hygiene factors were not in place, a worker is not satisfied. To have a satisfied, motivated workforce, a company needs to provide the following:
Achievement
Recognition
Work Itself
Responsibility
Advancement
Growth
8. 10-8 How to Develop the Truly Loyal Employee? Care for workers
Fairness of pay and evaluations
Accomplishment feeling
Satisfaction with daily activities
Appreciation of ideas Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 4: Distinguish between the motivators and hygiene factors identified by Herzberg.
How to Develop the Truly Loyal Employee?
This slide presents the top five drivers of loyalty when it comes to employees’ personal experiences of their workplaces.
According to the research report published by the Walker Information, a research company specializing in loyalty and satisfaction measurements, only 30% of the respondents met the criteria of loyal workers. About 34% of the respondents were classified as a high risk employees (not committed nor planning to stay) and 31% were qualified as trapped (not attached but no other job prospects either).
Ask the students: Reflecting on your work experiences (actual or potential), would these drivers of loyalty work for you?
Source: CIO, October 1, 2003Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 4: Distinguish between the motivators and hygiene factors identified by Herzberg.
How to Develop the Truly Loyal Employee?
This slide presents the top five drivers of loyalty when it comes to employees’ personal experiences of their workplaces.
According to the research report published by the Walker Information, a research company specializing in loyalty and satisfaction measurements, only 30% of the respondents met the criteria of loyal workers. About 34% of the respondents were classified as a high risk employees (not committed nor planning to stay) and 31% were qualified as trapped (not attached but no other job prospects either).
Ask the students: Reflecting on your work experiences (actual or potential), would these drivers of loyalty work for you?
Source: CIO, October 1, 2003
9. 10-9 Job-Oriented Motivational Techniques Job Enrichment/Redesign
Skill Variety
Task Identity/Significance
Autonomy
Feedback
Job Simplification
Job Enlargement
Job Rotation See Learning Goal 5: Explain how job enrichment affects employee motivation and performance.
See text pages: 267-269See Learning Goal 5: Explain how job enrichment affects employee motivation and performance.
See text pages: 267-269
10. 10-10 McGregor’s Theories Theory X- Autocratic
Dislike Work
Avoid Responsibility
Little Ambition
Force/Control/ Direct/Threaten
Motivated by Fear & Money Theory Y- Democratic
Like Work
Naturally Works Toward Goals
Seeks Responsibility
Imaginative, Creative, Clever
Motivated by Empowerment Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 6: Differentiate among Theory X, Theory Y, and Theory Z.
See text pages: 269-271
McGregor’s Theories
This slide presents McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y.
Theory X suggests that employees dislike work, avoid responsibility, have little ambition, and are motivated by threat and fear.
Theory Y argues that people like work, seek responsibility, and are motivated by empowerment.
If a manger hold a theory X or Theory Y values, s/he would tend to treat the employees accordingly.
Ask the students – are they X or Y as a supervisor? As an employee? How do they believe the employees should be treated? (As employees, majority if not all would argue to be treated as a theory Y individual. However, it should be pointed out to the students that it is generally dictated by the situation. A manager may hold a theory Y values but may have to use theory X perspective depending upon the situation with the employee.)Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 6: Differentiate among Theory X, Theory Y, and Theory Z.
See text pages: 269-271
McGregor’s Theories
This slide presents McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y.
Theory X suggests that employees dislike work, avoid responsibility, have little ambition, and are motivated by threat and fear.
Theory Y argues that people like work, seek responsibility, and are motivated by empowerment.
If a manger hold a theory X or Theory Y values, s/he would tend to treat the employees accordingly.
Ask the students – are they X or Y as a supervisor? As an employee? How do they believe the employees should be treated? (As employees, majority if not all would argue to be treated as a theory Y individual. However, it should be pointed out to the students that it is generally dictated by the situation. A manager may hold a theory Y values but may have to use theory X perspective depending upon the situation with the employee.)
11. 10-11 Ouchi’s Theory Z Long-Term Employment
Collective Decision-making
Individual Responsibility
Slow Evaluation/ Promotion
Implicit Informal Control with Explicit, Formalized Control
Specialized Career Path
Holistic Concern for Employees See Learning Goal 6: Differentiate among Theory X, Theory Y, and Theory Z.
See text pages: 271-272See Learning Goal 6: Differentiate among Theory X, Theory Y, and Theory Z.
See text pages: 271-272
12. 10-12 Goal-Setting Theory (MBO) Goal-Setting Theory
Management By Objectives (1960s) See Learning Goal 7: Explain goal-setting theory and how management by objectives (MBO) exemplifies the theory.
See text page: 273See Learning Goal 7: Explain goal-setting theory and how management by objectives (MBO) exemplifies the theory.
See text page: 273
13. 10-13 Impact of Mentors Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 7: Explain goal-setting theory and how management by objectives (MBO) exemplifies the theory.
Impact of Mentors
This slide presents the results of mentoring’s impact on career success, according to the Development Dimension International (DDI) Leadership Forecast of over 4500 respondents from 42 countries.
Over 90% of the respondents indicated that mentoring or coaching has a moderate to great impact on an individual’s career success.
Ask the students: Have you had any mentors in your previous or current work places? What impact have they had? Has mentoring been a positive experience for you? Explain. (This should generate an interesting discussion on mentoring based on students’ experiences. If they have not had any personal experiences, ask them to project what they would like from a mentor.)
Source: USA TodayAlso available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 7: Explain goal-setting theory and how management by objectives (MBO) exemplifies the theory.
Impact of Mentors
This slide presents the results of mentoring’s impact on career success, according to the Development Dimension International (DDI) Leadership Forecast of over 4500 respondents from 42 countries.
Over 90% of the respondents indicated that mentoring or coaching has a moderate to great impact on an individual’s career success.
Ask the students: Have you had any mentors in your previous or current work places? What impact have they had? Has mentoring been a positive experience for you? Explain. (This should generate an interesting discussion on mentoring based on students’ experiences. If they have not had any personal experiences, ask them to project what they would like from a mentor.)
Source: USA Today
14. 10-14 Employee-Oriented Motivational Techniques Expectancy Theory
Reinforcement Theory
Equity Theory See Learning Goal 8: Describe the key principles of expectancy, reinforcement, and equity theories.
See text pages: 274-276See Learning Goal 8: Describe the key principles of expectancy, reinforcement, and equity theories.
See text pages: 274-276
15. 10-15 Expectancy Theory: Employee Questions
Can I accomplish the task?
If I do accomplish it, what is my reward?
Is the reward worth the effort? See Learning Goal 8: Describe the key principles of expectancy, reinforcement, and equity theories.
See text page: 274
Expectancy Theory: Employee Questions
Let us define what exactly Expectancy Theory means: A belief that an individual (Employee) will act in the way his or her supervisor wants if that person believes he or she will be rewarded.
The three questions listed on the acetate are motivational forces directing:
Specific behavior to alternatives
Probability that effort will lead to good performance
A perceived probability that good Performance will lead to desired outcomes or rewards
Examples of some questions a person may ask when using the Expectancy Theory:
If I get a better grade on tomorrow’s math test will I get an “A” in math?
If I produce more than anyone else in the plan, will I get a bigger raise?
If my foul shooting improves will I have a shot at team MVP?
If I make more sales will I get a bonus?See Learning Goal 8: Describe the key principles of expectancy, reinforcement, and equity theories.
See text page: 274
Expectancy Theory: Employee Questions
Let us define what exactly Expectancy Theory means: A belief that an individual (Employee) will act in the way his or her supervisor wants if that person believes he or she will be rewarded.
The three questions listed on the acetate are motivational forces directing:
Specific behavior to alternatives
Probability that effort will lead to good performance
A perceived probability that good Performance will lead to desired outcomes or rewards
Examples of some questions a person may ask when using the Expectancy Theory:
If I get a better grade on tomorrow’s math test will I get an “A” in math?
If I produce more than anyone else in the plan, will I get a bigger raise?
If my foul shooting improves will I have a shot at team MVP?
If I make more sales will I get a bonus?
16. 10-16 Steps to Improve Performance Determine Rewards Valued
Determine Standards
Ensure Standards are Attainable
Tie Rewards to Performance
Are Rewards Considered Adequate? See Learning Goal 8: Describe the key principles of expectancy, reinforcement, and equity theories.
See text page: 274See Learning Goal 8: Describe the key principles of expectancy, reinforcement, and equity theories.
See text page: 274
17. 10-17 Teamwork & Open Communication Create culture that rewards listening
Train supervisors and managers to listen
Remove barriers to open communication Actively undertake efforts to facilitate communication See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
See text pages: 276-277See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
See text pages: 276-277
18. 10-18 Building Quality into Teams Getting Started
Initial Phases
Team Building
Mutual Coaching
Statistics
Projects
Building Quality
Role Change See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
Team Quality
This slide presents ideas on how to build quality in existing teams.
Getting started and initial phases are delicate and requires habit forming through practice.
Team leader must create the right environment where everyone feels comfortable (team building) and providing mutual support (coaching).
Statistics refers to measuring improvements and any plan to improve quality must be treated as a project with clarity of purpose.
Building quality is a question of attitude.
As the team develops fully with integrated quality, the leader’s role changes to that of a facilitator.
Source: www.see.ed.ac.uk
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
Team Quality
This slide presents ideas on how to build quality in existing teams.
Getting started and initial phases are delicate and requires habit forming through practice.
Team leader must create the right environment where everyone feels comfortable (team building) and providing mutual support (coaching).
Statistics refers to measuring improvements and any plan to improve quality must be treated as a project with clarity of purpose.
Building quality is a question of attitude.
As the team develops fully with integrated quality, the leader’s role changes to that of a facilitator.
Source: www.see.ed.ac.uk
19. 10-19 High Performance Teams Participative Leadership
Responsive
Aligned on Purpose
Communicative
Task Focused
Problem Solving
Shared Responsibility
Innovative Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
High Performance Teams
This slide presents eight characteristics of high performance teams.
This list is compiled from over 50 studies on high performance teams.
Ask the students in teams to explore these 8 characteristics as they relate to their own team. Which of these characteristics apply to their team and which are lacking? What modifications do they need to make to move towards being a high performance team?Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
High Performance Teams
This slide presents eight characteristics of high performance teams.
This list is compiled from over 50 studies on high performance teams.
Ask the students in teams to explore these 8 characteristics as they relate to their own team. Which of these characteristics apply to their team and which are lacking? What modifications do they need to make to move towards being a high performance team?
20. 10-20 Tips for Motivating Employees Thank employees for good job
Listen to employees
Give feedback
Give rewards
Keep them informed
Allow for input
Training opportunities
Remember important dates
Have and abide by policies
Celebrate goal accomplishment Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
Motivating Employees
This slide offers simple tips for motivating employees in your business.
In reality these tips can be applied to any interpersonal relationships.
A motto to remember is the Golden Rule: Treat others like you want to be treated.
Ask the students to use the different motivational theories such as Maslow’s or Herzberg’s to see how these tips would get classified. Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
Motivating Employees
This slide offers simple tips for motivating employees in your business.
In reality these tips can be applied to any interpersonal relationships.
A motto to remember is the Golden Rule: Treat others like you want to be treated.
Ask the students to use the different motivational theories such as Maslow’s or Herzberg’s to see how these tips would get classified.
21. 10-21 Warning Signs ofEmployee Stress Drops in productivity
Chronic lateness
Absenteeism
Careless with details
Unable to work with others
Negative attitudes about work
Withdrawal from co-workers
Easily upset/angered Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
Warning Signs of Employee Stress
Employers can often spot impending stress or on-the-job stress by understanding the signs listed in the acetate.
Ask the students: Have you experienced any of these symptoms when trying to juggle your academic, professional, and personal lives? What did you do to cope with the rigors of stress?
Share the following tips for reducing stress:
Learn to plan.
Recognize and accept limits.
Be a positive person.
Learn to tolerate and forgive.
Avoid unnecessary competition.
Get regular exercise.
Learn a systematic, drug-free method of relaxing.
Change your thinking.
Source: UTexas.eduAlso available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
Warning Signs of Employee Stress
Employers can often spot impending stress or on-the-job stress by understanding the signs listed in the acetate.
Ask the students: Have you experienced any of these symptoms when trying to juggle your academic, professional, and personal lives? What did you do to cope with the rigors of stress?
Share the following tips for reducing stress:
Learn to plan.
Recognize and accept limits.
Be a positive person.
Learn to tolerate and forgive.
Avoid unnecessary competition.
Get regular exercise.
Learn a systematic, drug-free method of relaxing.
Change your thinking.
Source: UTexas.edu
22. 10-22 How Stressed Are You? Rate 1-5 Conditions at work are unpleasant or sometimes even unsafe.
I feel that my job is making me physically or emotionally sick.
I have too much work or too many unreasonable deadlines.
I can’t express my opinions or feelings about my job to my boss. My work interferes with my family or personal life.
I have no control over my life at work.
My good performance goes unrecognized and unrewarded.
My talents are underutilized. Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
How Stressed Are You? Rate 1-5
This slide identifies several examples of stress a worker may experience in their organization.
This slide offers a perfect time for the Instructor to set the class up in groups, and have them rate each question individually; then have the group to decide the best answer for each situation. Share with the rest of the class via group presentation their results.
This exercise will provide the class an opportunity to share their thoughts and understand they are not alone when dealing with these work related issues.Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
How Stressed Are You? Rate 1-5
This slide identifies several examples of stress a worker may experience in their organization.
This slide offers a perfect time for the Instructor to set the class up in groups, and have them rate each question individually; then have the group to decide the best answer for each situation. Share with the rest of the class via group presentation their results.
This exercise will provide the class an opportunity to share their thoughts and understand they are not alone when dealing with these work related issues.
23. 10-23 Putting it Together at Nucor Steel Pay for Performance
Listen to the Frontline
Push-Down Authority
Protect Your Culture
Try Unproven Technologies Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
Putting it Together at Nucor
This slide presents the best-practice model at Nucor Steel which places a premium on teamwork and idea sharing.
On average, two-thirds of a Nucor steelworker’s pay is based on a production-bonus.
According to the Execs at Nucor, all of the best ideas come from the factory floor. These ideas are acted upon and authority is pushed down the line.
In every acquisition of another company, a special attention is paid to how employees and managers interact and how the company would fit into the Nucor culture.
Nucor realizes the importance of taking risks and trying new technologies.
Source: Business Week, May 1, 2006Also available on a Transparency Acetate
See Learning Goal 9: Explain how open communication builds teamwork, and describes how managers are likely to motivate teams in the future.
Putting it Together at Nucor
This slide presents the best-practice model at Nucor Steel which places a premium on teamwork and idea sharing.
On average, two-thirds of a Nucor steelworker’s pay is based on a production-bonus.
According to the Execs at Nucor, all of the best ideas come from the factory floor. These ideas are acted upon and authority is pushed down the line.
In every acquisition of another company, a special attention is paid to how employees and managers interact and how the company would fit into the Nucor culture.
Nucor realizes the importance of taking risks and trying new technologies.
Source: Business Week, May 1, 2006