270 likes | 289 Views
Explore the challenges hindering portfolio investment in Africa. Analyze frontier equity markets, firm sizes, and asset allocations of global emerging market funds, with a focus on South Africa. Learn how to target regional funds, leverage the JSE, and address supply constraints to promote firm entry and growth.
E N D
Todd Moss, Vijaya Ramachandran, and Scott Standley Why Doesn’t Africa get More Portfolio Investment? Frontier Stock Markets, Firm Size, and Asset Allocations of Global Emerging Market Funds
Frontier equity markets • 15 mkts • SA dominates • Others small, low liquidity • Few large blocks available • But not unusual
South Africa GEM investment, 1996-2004 (3 year moving averages)
GEM investment in Frontier SSA (1996-2004, 3yr moving averages)
Share of GEM investment vs. Log market capitalization No country with market cap under $50 bn receives more than 1% of total GEM investment Market cap = $50 bn
Share of GEM investment vs. Log value traded No country with value traded under $10 bn receives more than 1% of total GEM investment Value traded = $10 bn
Share of GEM funds vs. Log market capitalization >90% of funds and >$150 bn market cap <10% of funds and <$20 bn market cap Outgrown asset class
Share of GEM funds vs. Log value traded >90% of funds and >$75-100 bn value traded <10% of funds and <$2 bn value traded Outgrown asset class
Why are SSA firms small? Cost Structures, Firm-Level Average by Country (Eifert, Gelb and Ramachandran, 2005)
Why are SSA firms small? Gross and Net Value Added per Worker, $ Adjusted(Eifert, Gelb and Ramachandran, 2005)
Why are SSA firms small? Percentage of Annual Revenues Lost in Unofficial Payments (World Bank Investment Climate Assessments, various)
Conclusions • Target regional funds • Leverage JSE • Focus on supply constraints/barriers to firm entry and growth • Privatization? • Private equity? • SME finance?
END • END
Share of GEM investment vs. Log market capitalization No country with market cap under $50 bn receives more than 1% of total GEM investment Market cap = $50 bn
Share of GEM funds vs. Log GDP >90% of funds and >$200 bn GDP 10%-90% of funds and $60-$200 bn GDP <10% of funds and <$60 bn GDP Outgrown asset class
Share of GEM investment vs. Log GDP No country with GDP under $100 bn receives more than 1% of total GEM investment GDP = $100 bn