250 likes | 258 Views
California Municipal Treasurer’s Association. Investing Bond Proceeds. Lauren Brant Senior Managing Consultant PFM Asset Management LLC. Lester T. Wood Managing Director Bond Logistix, LLC. April 20, 2004. Noticing the Obvious. FINISHED FILES ARE THE RE- SULT OF YEARS OF SCIENTIF-
E N D
California Municipal Treasurer’s Association Investing Bond Proceeds Lauren Brant Senior Managing Consultant PFM Asset Management LLC Lester T. Wood Managing Director Bond Logistix, LLC April 20, 2004
Noticing the Obvious FINISHED FILES ARE THE RE- SULT OF YEARS OF SCIENTIF- IC STUDY COMBINED WITH THE EXPERIENCE OF MANY YEARS
Investing Bond Proceeds • Financial Requirement • P & I Payments • Earning Assets • BondProceeds • Use ofEarnings • Debt Service • Objective • Reduce Borrowing Costs
Overview • Who’s Involved in the Decision Making Process? • Arbitrage Considerations. • Fun with Funds! • Mixing and Matching Investments. • Case Study.
Arbitrage Considerations • What is arbitrage? • Exceptions, Exemptions, Elections • How does arbitrage factor into the investment strategy for my bonds? • How will I keep track of the arbitrage of my bond issue? • Planning Ahead
What is Arbitrage? 9.0 Positive Arbitrage 8.0 Yield 7.0 Bond Yield (tax-exempt) 6.0 Investment Yield (taxable) Negative Arbitrage 5.0 4.0 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 • 100% tax on earnings in excess of bond yield
Loopholes • Exceptions • Project fund spending • Exemptions • Small issuer • Elections • Penalty in lieu of rebate
Investment Strategy • Factors to consider prior to issuance: • IRS regulations • Marketplace vs. arbitrage yield • Interest rate trends • Ongoing strategy considerations: • Arbitrage is cumulative from day one, across all funds
How do I Keep Track? Transaction Transaction Transaction Future Value Future Value Date Days Type Amount Factor Cash Flow --------------- -------- ------------------ --------------------- ------------------ ----------------------- 5/12/98 1800 Deposit 236,491,000.00 1.29199835 305,545,981.15 5/12/98 1800 Withdrawal (39,947,000.00) 1.29199835 (51,611,457.98) 6/30/98 1752 Withdrawal (25,949,000.00) 1.28320184 (33,297,804.46) 9/30/98 1662 Withdrawal (14,175,000.00) 1.26686948 (17,957,874.92) 12/31/98 1572 Withdrawal (20,475,000.00) 1.25074500 (25,609,003.95) 3/31/99 1482 Withdrawal (20,100,000.00) 1.23482575 (24,819,997.66) 6/30/99 1392 Withdrawal (19,050,000.00) 1.21910912 (23,224,028.78) 9/30/99 1302 Withdrawal (19,050,000.00) 1.20359253 (22,928,437.66) 12/31/99 1212 Withdrawal (19,600,000.00) 1.18827343 (23,290,159.16) 3/31/00 1122 Withdrawal (20,650,000.00) 1.17314930 (24,225,533.12) 6/30/00 1032 Withdrawal (19,600,000.00) 1.15821768 (22,701,066.49) 9/30/00 942 Withdrawal (12,200,000.00) 1.14347610 (13,950,408.41) 12/31/00 852 Withdrawal (5,150,000.00) 1.12892215 (5,813,949.06) 3/31/01 762 Withdrawal (1,000,000.00) 1.11455344 (1,114,553.44) --------------- -------- ------------------ --------------------- ------------------ ----------------------- 15,001,706.05 Calculation Date 5/12/03 Days Since Inception 1800 Earnings Yield 5.600000% Arbitrage Yield 5.190000% Future Value at Earnings of 5.19% $15,001,706.05 Future Value at Earnings of 5.60% $16,486,923.58 Arbitrage Rebate Liability 5/12/03 $1,485,217.53
Planning Ahead At Issuance • Calendar of Important Dates • Expenditure benchmarks • Yield restriction • 5-year payment date • Filing • Data Collection • Segregated funds • Refunding issues • Transferred proceeds
Fun with Funds! • Project (Acquisition/Construction) • Match to Draw Schedule • Debt Service Reserve • Covenant to Maintain Fixed Amount • Semi-Annual Availability • Capitalized Interest
Fun with Funds! • Debt Service Principal & Interest • Capitalized Interest • Cash Flow Thereafter • Escrows
Surety Bonds or L.O.C. • Insurance with Recourse • Replace Cash Funded DSR • Debt Cap Problem at Time of Issuance • Over Budget on Project Costs After Issuance
Cost of Surety or L.O.C. • Premium Cost • Lost Ability to Earn Positive • Current/expected arbitrage position
Mixing & Matching Investments • Typical bond proceeds investments: • Liquidity Pools • Structured Portfolios • Investment Agreements
Considerations • Liquidity requirements • Yield objectives (arbitrage yield vs. market) • Purpose of funds • Agency’s tolerance for risk • Bond document investment language (boilerplate) • Net/Gross funding for construction fund
Liquidity Pools • Money market funds • County pool • Local Agency Investment Fund (LAIF) • Joint powers authority Features • Liquidity within restrictions of investments • Ease in administration Issues to consider • Variable investment rate • No customization to draws
Structured Portfolios Features • Customized investment strategy • Portfolio initially structured to match expected draw schedule • Active trading can improve yield • Portfolio restructured as draw schedule changes and to adjust for market changes • Ability to lock in higher yield on longer-term funds Issues to consider • Can be time consuming to monitor and manage • Slightly higher transaction costs may be incurred • Mark-to-market risk for Reserve Fund • Reduced liquidity
Investment Agreements • Guaranteed Rate • Withdrawals at Par • Shift Reinvestment and • Market Rate Risks to Provider • Issuer Assumes Credit Risk on IAs
Investment Agreement Providers • Banks • Primary Dealers • Private Placements • Insurance Companies
Investment Agreements • Standard With Collateral • Downgrade • Collateralized • Puts • Forward Delivery
Uses of Investment Agreements • Construction / Acquisition • Full flex draws • Debt Service Reserves • Semi-annual draw • Debt Service Float • Monthly window
Conclusion • Consider the risks/rewards of all options. • Develop an investment strategy for all proceeds prior to issuance. • Revisit each fund’s strategy on a frequent basis. By doing these things, you increase your chances of reducing your borrowing costs.