170 likes | 391 Views
Youth, youth leisure, and youth policy. Andries van den Broek, Koen Breedveld, Jos de Haan, Frank Huysmans, & Elke Zeijl Social and Cultural Planning Office. Youth, youth leisure, and youth policy. * policy theory * facts and figures * tenability of policy claims. Sources.
E N D
Youth, youth leisure, and youth policy Andries van den Broek,Koen Breedveld,Jos de Haan,Frank Huysmans,& Elke ZeijlSocial and Cultural Planning Office
Youth, youth leisure,and youth policy • * policy theory • * facts and figures • * tenability of policy claims
Sources • * policy documents • Youths deserve the future (1993) • Youth policy in equilibrium (1999) • * Research among pupils
Policy theory • * inter-sector youth policy presupposes a relation between leisure participation and development: without certain types of participation, chances for development are supposed to be missed • * yet cultural policy aims at culture as such, not at culture as an instrument • * not at stake here: prevention policy
Policy practice • * youth policy is a rather weak player, influencing its network is its main armory • * youth policy is highly de-centralized, both to sectors and to local government • * policy targets suffer lack specification (due to weak theoretical and practical basis?)
Towards measurement 1 • * social participation: • sport • culture • media • political participation and volunteering • * implicit assumption that participation in ‘own’ youth culture is devoid of positive effects
Towards measurement 2 • * state of development: • cognitive (school) • emotional (emotional problems) • social (parents & peers) • physical (subjective well-being)
Effects of sport * cognitive: school n.s. * emotional: problems -.07 * social: parents .05 * social: peers .05 * physical .12
Effects of (canonized) culture * cognitive: school .04 * emotional: problems .06 * social: parents .06 * social: peers n.s. * physical n.s.
Effects of media (reading) * cognitive: school .04 * emotional: problems n.s. * social: parents .08 * social: peers -.04 * physical n.s.
Effects of volunteering * cognitive: school - * emotional: problems .03 * social: parents .04 * social: peers -.08 * physical .12
Counter-test:Effects of youth culture (hanging out) * cognitive: school -.06 * emotional: problems .04 * social: parents -.09 * social: peers n.s. * physical n.s.
Activities fostered * sport * amateur cultural activities * canonized cultural visits * reading * membership associations * volunteering
Activities not fostered * movies, rock concerts * bars, discotheques * watching telly * computer, internet * telephoning
Overall effects of fostered and non-fostered activities f. n.f. * cognitive: school .05 n.s. * emotional problems n.s. -.04 * social: parents .10 n.s. * social: peers .03 .15 * physical .08 n.s.
And so: ??? • * no support for youth policy !!! • * is policy theory inadequate ??? • * are our measurements inadequate ???