190 likes | 454 Views
Ethanol vs. Gasoline. By: Erica Tucker. Intro to the fuels. Gasoline: Produced from petroleum Non-renewable Types: Pure gasoline Gasohol (combination of gasoline and ethanol). Intro to the fuels (cont.). Ethanol: Derived from plants Renewable Types: Corn-based Sugarcane
E N D
Ethanol vs. Gasoline By: Erica Tucker
Intro to the fuels • Gasoline: • Produced from petroleum • Non-renewable • Types: • Pure gasoline • Gasohol (combination of gasoline and ethanol)
Intro to the fuels (cont.) • Ethanol: • Derived from plants • Renewable • Types: • Corn-based • Sugarcane • Cellulosic (made from the sugar substrate of plants)
thesis • After each side of the argument is presented, my thesis is: • The BEST combination of each fuel needs to be used to improve environment and maintain necessary resources.
Main points • Benefits and downfalls to both gasoline and ethanol • The new forms of ethanol being researched • What these new forms bring to the table for the U.S. • The need for alternative fuels • New technology
Benefits of gasoline • Cheaper than ethanol in the long run • Engine burns it more efficiently
Downfalls to gasoline • Worse for environment • Releases more Hydrocarbons and Carbon Dioxide • Non-renewable • This issue leads to a need of alternative fuels
Benefits of ethanol • Cheaper to produce • Made from corn- renewable resource • Better for the environment • Emissions released are less harmful
Downfalls to ethanol • Using corn to produce ethanol would decrease amount used for feeding the people of the world • World doesn’t produce enough corn as it is • May be more expensive in the long-run than gasoline • Less-efficient burning in engine
New forms of ethanol • Sugarcane Ethanol: • Made from sugarcane • Renewable • More needs to be produced, this space is available • Benefits: • Reduction of carbon emissions by 66 million tonnes • “tonne” here means 1000 kilograms
What this means for u.s. • U.S. was tenth in sugarcane production as of 2005 • Need to either produce or import more sugarcane • Car manufacturers need to produce engine to run efficiently on sugarcane • Although promising, has downfalls • Also uses valuable food sources that could be feeding the starving people of the world
New forms of ethanol (cont.) • Cellulosic Ethanol • Produced by breaking down sugar substrate of plant material • Cellulose makes up between 75 and 85 percent of plant material • If broken down too, corn could be used more efficiently and less would be needed to produce the same amount of fuel
gasohol • 90% gasoline and 10% corn-based ethanol • Same price at pump, but emissions are not as harmful • Downfall • “Expensive and energy intensive to produce” (Columbia)
Need for alternative fuels • Nations need to keep up with demand of food sources for ethanol, but also maintain adequate production of crops for feeding the world • Need for fuel that is safe for the environment and also competitive with gasoline’s efficiency in engines
Additional goal: reduce overall use of energy sources • New technology has surfaced • Electric cars • Run on electricity and gasoline • More beneficial to environment because they release less harmful emissions than a car that runs only on gasoline • Chevy Cruze Eco • Better gas mileage
Making progress • Benefits of Electric Cars: • Require less fuel therefore reducing needed amount of depleting petroleum • If progress continues • Electric-ethanol cars? • 100% electric cars? • Resolve problem of overuse of petroleum and remove harmful emissions
in conclusion… • Despite positives of gasoline, long-term survival of society requires use of alternative fuels. • Due to drawbacks, society is not yet ready to completely replace gasoline because of greedy consumption of petroleum • Many hurdles to conquer and further research and analysis is necessary for reduction of petroleum-based products and increase in alternative fuels
Works cited • “Economic and Social Department the Statistics Division.” Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations. 2005. Web. 01 Nov. 2011. < http://www.fao.org>. • “Ethanol is More Expensive than Gasoline over Time.” US News. Daily News, 03 June 2008. Web. 01 Nov. 2011. <http://usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/cars-trucks/daily-news/080603-Ethanol-is-More-Expensive-than-Gasoline-Over-Time/>. • “Gasohol.” Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia, 6th Edition 1.1 (2011): 1. Vocational and Career Collection. Web. 01 Nov. 2011. • Goldemberg, José. “The Ethanol Program in Brazil.” Environmental Research Letters 1.1 (2006): 4. IOP Science. Web. 01 Nov. 2011. • Ho, Mae-Wan. “Ethanol from Cellulose Biomass Not Sustainable nor Environmentally Benign” Institute of Science in Society Science Society Sustainability. (2006): n. pag. Web. 02 Nov. 2011. • Lerner, Ivan. “The New Ethanol.” ICIS Chemical Business 277.22 (2010): 24-25. Vocational and Career Collection. Web. 02 Nov. 2011. • Weeks, Linton. “Big Question: Can Grain Ever be the Future of Fuel?” National Debate Archives. (2006): G29. TOPICsearch. Web. 01 Nov. 2011.