580 likes | 799 Views
HKN Dinner, November 2, 2004. Crop-Circles, Skepticism, and Snow-Sculpting. Carlo Séquin, EECS, CS Division. From “CONTACT” Meeting NASA Ames Campus, Palo Alto, 2003. A sign from extra-terrestrial intelligence ??. The Face on Mars. Picture taken by Viking Orbiter in 1976.
E N D
HKN Dinner, November 2, 2004 Crop-Circles,Skepticism, andSnow-Sculpting Carlo Séquin, EECS, CS Division
From “CONTACT” MeetingNASA Ames Campus, Palo Alto, 2003 A sign from extra-terrestrial intelligence ??
The Face on Mars • Picture taken by Viking Orbiter in 1976
Face on Mars Close-up • High-res. photo, Global Surveyor, 4/8/2001
How Do We Make Sense of the Unknown? Different people have • different mental frameworks, belief systems • and/or use them with different priorities to come up with possible “explanations”.
My Attempt at Classification Created by: Intelligence Nature Meaningfulmessage, or object Artistic, or playfulartifact Randomone-timeoccurrence Systematic, repeatableprocess
Self-Test I will display some intriguing(?) pictures: Check yourself, how you interpret them... Possible Answers, with respective probabilities: Artistic, or playfulartifact Randomone-timeoccurrence Meaningfulmessage, or object Systematic, repeatableprocess
Nazca, Peru • Are these ancient landing strips ?
Petroglyphs But what does it mean ?
Faces on the Rocks Mt. Rushmore
Panorama from Mars Rover “Opportunity” Miracles of Photoshop ?
Clouds in the Sky UFO ?
Volcanic Vent Hole ? Art by Andy Goldsworthy
“Turning a Snowball Inside-Out” • A model of theMorin Surface = Half-way point of sphere eversion • The challenge is to turn a sphere inside-out: • Surface may pass through itself, • but no ripping, puncturing, creasing allowed,e.g., this is not an acceptable solution: PINCH
Sphere Eversion Process • But there are more contorted paths that can achieve the desired goal. • Bernard Morin figured out one such path. • Charles Pugh made models from chicken wire. • Nelson Max made a first computer simulation.
Gridded Models for Transparency 3D-Print from Zcorp SLIDE virtual model
Shape Adaption for Snow Sculpture Restructured Morin surface to fit block size: (10’ x 10’ x 12’)
Day5 Honorable Mention: “Most AmbitiousDesign”
All this effort for a short-lived artifact ? The joy of creating something of your own design … The pride of astounding people ... Why Do People Do Such Things ??
Milk-Hill Design Analysis 409 Circles Milk Hill crop formation is exactly the same design as the interior of the Raelian Symbol which Raelians have been wearing publicly since 1990. http://bcornet.homestead.com/files/MilkHill/milkhill.htm
Crop Circle Construction Probably not of extraterrestrial origin ! 26 person-hours of crop squashing, http://www.geocities.com/pduchesne3/
What Is the Message ? Prof. Velvel Kahan, early 1980’s: • Why are you giving this talk ? • Who is the audience you are trying to reach ? • What is the message you want to get across ? ( “If you don’t have answers to these questions,you may as well forget giving your talk !” )
Message #1 Don’t blindly believe everything you see or hear - even if it comes from an authoritative source such as the President of the most powerful nation in the world … • Use common sense • Check the facts • Look for other explanations • Apply “KISS” principle