1 / 14

OIL REVENUE TRANSPARENCY : THE CURRENT REGULATORY SITUATION

NOT AN OFFICIAL UNCTAD RECORD. OIL REVENUE TRANSPARENCY : THE CURRENT REGULATORY SITUATION. Stéphane Brabant Avocat at the Paris Bar. 8 th Africa Oil and Gas, Trade and Finance Conference and Exhibition 26 th -30 th April 2004 - Marrakech. I - Oil revenues.

rock
Download Presentation

OIL REVENUE TRANSPARENCY : THE CURRENT REGULATORY SITUATION

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. NOT AN OFFICIAL UNCTAD RECORD OIL REVENUE TRANSPARENCY : THE CURRENT REGULATORY SITUATION Stéphane Brabant Avocat at the Paris Bar 8th Africa Oil and Gas, Trade and Finance Conference and Exhibition 26th-30th April 2004 - Marrakech

  2. I - Oil revenues • Oil revenues are , directly or indirectly ,central and/or local states’ revenuesfrom oil project (concessions and/or PSAs) : • Tax Revenues (Corporate tax, royalty, rentals etc.) • Customs Revenues • Bonuses • Profit Oil • States’ participation in Joint Venture • Indirect Revenues (Municipalities, contractors, etc.)

  3. Concession and PSA systems in North and West Africa MOROCCO(ONAREP) ALGERIA(SONATRACH) LIBYA(NOC) EGYPT(EGPC) MAURITANIA SUDAN (SUDAPEST GPC) MALI CHAD SENEGAL(PETROSEN) NIGERIA(NNPC) CAME-ROON EQUATORIAL GUINEA(GEPETROL) GABON CONGO(SNPC) ANGOLA(SONANGOL) Concessionary system PSC system Dual system

  4. II - Oil revenues : a curse or a blessing ? • ·a blessing: In Africa, the development of natural resources is often the main source of revenues for the State • Most of the producing countries use a PSA system • NOCs hold an important share of the profit oil • Collection of proportional petroleum royalty even under PSAs • In Concession system, income taxes are usually high • In all case, signature bonuses

  5. ·a curse: paradoxically adverse effects of oil and gas development on the social and economic achievements of certain countries • Conclusion: not a curse, simply a problem relating to the use of oil revenues

  6. III - States’, NOCs’ or IOCs’ curse? ·Most oil revenues belong to the State and the NOCs (Budget issue with taxes, royalties, profit oil…) • Thus, subject to sovereignty • Little redistribution / allocation to local authorities · But, State interventionism decreases • The problem is now left at the IOCs’ doors and possibly at the NOCs’ doors

  7. IV - The use of oil revenues in Africa became an international community concern • Oil revenues should benefit the country’s development • First reaction : Creation of soft law

  8. V - From soft Law to binding legislation V.1 - "Political Declarations" • Western Governments and International Organisations such as the United Nations are concerned : • Comments of George Soros (June 2002) • Comments of Tony Blair (September 2002) • Recent declarations of the United Nations

  9. V.2 - The rising of NGOs • Transparency International • Amnesty International • CAFOD • Christian Aid • Friends of the Earth • Global Witness • Oxfam • Save the Children • EITI (Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative) • Human Rights Watch • Publish what you pay Coalition • IISD – International Institute for Sustainable Development • Open Society Initiative for West Africa • G8 Statement • World Council for Sustainable Development, etc.

  10. V.3 - From Best Practices to a Voluntary Framework • Best practice • Indirect ways of helping the community during oil and gas production : requirement to train local personnel, use local products etc. • Helping the community in ways totally unrelated to oil and gas production : building schools, hospitals, roads, etc. • Voluntary framework • Oil Industry oriented initiatives (IPIECA …) • Initiatives of individual oil companies • Desire to identify practical guidelines / framework in order to improve specific company practices • IFC and World Bank Guidelines

  11. V.4 - From a Voluntary Framework to Conditionality • Banks and Multinational Investment Agencies • Equator Principles • Most International Organisations would like : • bilateral and unilateral development assistance, resource-backed loans from banks, and export credit agency funding • Institutional investors

  12. V.5 - From Conditionality to Regulation • Most of the NGOs, International Organisations and National Authorities: • believe that only a regulatory framework could ensure that all IOC have to publish the net revenues they pay to governments as a requirement of being listed on major stock exchanges • are supporting governments to reform national laws, policies and institutions to promote investment and development of extractive industries in developing countries • E.g. : Restrictive methods : restricting the use of all or part of revenue paid to the Government (e.g Chad-Cameroon pipeline) • IFC recommendation conditionality implementation of national law • E.g. : IMF efforts to promote a Code of good practices on Tax Transparency • Mandatory Approach

  13. Why should oil companies care? VI - Court action • ·Increasing risk of legal claims • ·Cause of these actions = universal jurisdiction • E.g.: The Alien Tort Act 1789 (US) • Legal claims based on crimes against humanity • Allegations from claimants that companies are: • aiding and abetting corruption, wasting public funds • aiding and abetting apartheid • conspiring with the military

  14. Some conclusion • ·Potential creation of a customary law based on precedents • ·Possibility of the implementation of compulsory regulations by the legislator and not by the industry sector • ·AIPN initiative: “Contractual tools to facilitate management of energy project impact”.

More Related