1 / 30

High Reliability Organizations in Major League Baseball

High Reliability Organizations in Major League Baseball. Bryan Berg QM 290 November 29, 2012. Definition of Quality. Problems in Baseball. Over-reliance on old methods Afraid to make mistakes Poor talent evaluation Few self-checks One bad contract kills a team. MLB GMs in Free Agency.

Download Presentation

High Reliability Organizations in Major League Baseball

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. High Reliability Organizations in Major League Baseball Bryan Berg QM 290 November 29, 2012

  2. Definition of Quality

  3. Problems in Baseball • Over-reliance on old methods • Afraid to make mistakes • Poor talent evaluation • Few self-checks • One bad contract kills a team

  4. MLB GMs in Free Agency

  5. Defects • Anything that prevents a team from reaching its potential • Overpaying for talent • Injuries • Age • Unrealistic expectations SELF-INFLICTED

  6. High-Reliability Organizations • Sensitivity to Operations • Preoccupation with Failure • Deference to Expertise • Commitment to Resilience • Reluctance to Simplify Interpretations

  7. Sensitivity to Operations • Everyone understands the big picture • Knowledge sharing throughout organization • System-wide knowledge of operations

  8. The Problem • MLB teams have no top-down identity • Teams are thrown together • No attention to cohesiveness or culture • Moves are made based on whims • Reactions instead of proaction

  9. The Solution • All teams should have a core identity • Young players • Forward-looking statistics • Teams should communicate its policy with players • All members of organization should have the ability to offer suggestions • Players • Front office staff • Stadium concierge staff

  10. Preoccupation with Failure • Failure is always possible • Small mistakes may become catastrophic • Active evaluation of operations • Identify errors before they happen

  11. The Problem • Teams routinely shoot themselves in the foot • Improper evaluation of talent • Bad contracts • Ill-conceived signings • Poor talent evaluation • Teams think too much about what could be • Not enough about what actually is • The mistakes of today have tremendous future consequences • Instant gratification • Contract year syndrome

  12. The Cost of a Bad Contract WAR: Wins Above Replacement Average Starter: +2 WAR

  13. The Solution • Make sure all talent fits the bill • Don’t force square pegs into round holes • Only sign affordable talent • No aging/injury prone players • Consider intangibles • Media pressure • Ability to handle success/money

  14. Deference to Expertise • Decisions should be made by people with the most relevant expertise • Those with the most knowledge make the decisions regardless of rank • Blindly following the hierarchy can lead to mistakes

  15. The Problem • Baseball talent evaluation favors the wrong stats • Wins • RBI • Batting Average • Teams are unwilling to embrace new methodologies • Teams act before they think

  16. The Solution • Bring in stats experts from outside of baseball • New perspective • Incorporate new stats • New methods + common sense • Give the “numbers guys” a voice

  17. Advanced Stats • On-Base Percentage (OBP) • Patience and discipline • Ultimate Zone Rating (UZR) • Advanced look at fielding • Batting Average on Balls in Play (BABIP) • Quantifies luck for pitchers • Wins Above Replacement (WAR) • Measures a player’s true value

  18. Statistics – Old vs. New

  19. Commitment to Resilience • All errors cannot be prevented • Minimize the escalating consequences of unpreventable errors • Anticipate errors • Don’t be caught by surprise

  20. The Problem • Most people believe defects cannot be predicted • Teams quickly stray from plans when adversity strikes • Rebuilding efforts • Financial responsibility • Teams listen too much to outside sources • Media • Fans

  21. 2012 Boston Red Sox • Record: 69-93 • Last in AL East • Worst season in franchise history • Opening Day Payroll: $173,186,617 • Traded $73 million of salary during season • 2013 Outlook • “I know that we'll have a very strong payroll, a large payroll… I'm confident in saying that we'll be amongst the larger payrolls in the game.” –Ben Cherington, Red Sox GM

  22. The Solution • Tunnel vision • Stick to the budget • Keep statistical analysis above all else • Don’t listen to critics • Communicate plan with fans • Treat fans like shareholders • Convince them to buy into your plan

  23. Reluctance to Simplify Interpretations • Don’t accept simple answers to complex questions • Drill down to find the real heart of the matter

  24. The Problem • Teams often act impulsively • “Gut” feelings • Focus on getting “a” player instead of “the” player • Whack-A-Mole mentality

  25. The Solution • Bring in only necessary players • No “second choices” • Focus on the whole team • Not just one position • Look for new ways to interpret data • Advanced stats

  26. Threats to High Reliability • Revenue Sharing • Every team gets a piece of a leaguewide pool • Teams don’t have to work to make money • Miami Marlins • TV Money • Teams receive tens of millions each year • Payments have increased exponentially

  27. TV Money – Texas Rangers • 2010 • Declared bankruptcy • Reached World Series • Payroll: $55,250,544 • Payroll Rank: 26 out of 30 • Signed 20-year TV deal • Pays $80 million annually • 2012 • Lost Wild Card play-in game • Payroll: $120,510,974 • Payroll Rank: 6 out of 30

  28. TV Money – LA Dodgers • Declared bankruptcy in 2011 • Taken over by Major League Baseball • Purchased for $2 billion in 2012 • Previous record purchase: $700 million (Chicago Cubs, 2009) • Payroll • Start of 2012 season: $95,143,575 • Current payroll: $198,314,286 • TV Deal • Negotiating with Fox Sports • Rumored Deal: 25 years, $6 billion total

  29. Conclusion • High reliability is the way of the future • Yankees: 1 World Series since 2000 • Rays: 3 playoff appearances in last 5 years • Patience and smarts trump money • Embracing HRO now is ideal • TV money has potential to ruin baseball • Teams must be smart with added funds

  30. Questions?

More Related