180 likes | 821 Views
Have we been able to operationalize mental disorders?.
E N D
1. DSM-IV TRSchizophrenia & Other Psychotic Disorders
Saeed Moradian
September2008
2. Have we been able to operationalize mental disorders? “Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, Text Revision” (DSM-IV-TR)
Published by the American Psychiatric Association
Primarily used in the United States
Includes information only on mental illnesses
Classifies mental illnesses into different types of disorders (Mood disorders, psychotic disorders, eating disorders, etc.)
International Classification of Diseases (ICD)
Created by the World Health Organization
Used throughout the rest of the world
Includes information on both mental and physical illnesses
3. What is the DSM-IV-TR? Multiaxial Classification Axis I – Clinical disorders- comparable to general medical disorders (Like adjustment disorder with anxious mood)
Axis II –Personality disorders and mental retardation (obsessive-compulsive personality)
Axis III –General medical conditions, general medical illnesses or injuries ( Crohn’s disease, acute bleeding episodes)
Axis IV –Psychosocial and environmental problems (recent remarriage, death of father)
Axis V –Global assessment of functioning (GAF) (GAF=80)
4. Assumptions of the DSM How was the DSM developed? DSM-I (1952)
Created around the same time as ICD-6
Purpose: “create a classification that was a consensus of contemporary thinking”
Diagnoses were created by committees and revised by 10% of the members of the American Psychological Association
Included approximately 60 disorders
Definitions were vague, wordy descriptions
Based on psychoanalytic theory
5. How was the DSM developed? DSM-II (1968)
Created around the same time as ICD-8
Purpose: “created to promote international consensus in the realm of mental health”
Similar to DSM-I in terms of its development and the presentation of disorders
180 disorders were included
Homosexuality was included as a psychological diagnosis
6. How was the DSM developed? DSM-III (1980) & DSM-III-R (1987):
First attempt to use research in the development of diagnostic categories, but still mostly based on clinical judgment
Definitions were changed to be more specific
Both inclusion and exclusion criteria
Homosexuality no longer considered a mental disorder
7. How was the DSM developed? DSM-IV (1994) & DSM-IV-TR (2000):
Attempted to systematize the way diagnostic criteria are developed
175 psychologists did literature reviews of the research on each diagnosis
Field trials were conducted that tested the reliability of the diagnoses
There is still the criticism that the diagnoses are based on the clinical judgment of a few psychologists in the individual field
Added Culture Bound Syndromes to address cultural differences in presentation of symptoms
8. Evaluation of the DSM-IV-TR Is each diagnosis unique and distinct???
Fluidity of diagnoses –
Comorbidity
Two or more disorders occurring in the same individual
Disorders co-occur at rates greater than expected by chance alone
9. Evaluation of the DSM-IV-TR Homogeneity: Do all people with the disorder have similar symptoms, follow a similar course, etc?
10. Evaluation of the DSM-IV-TR Specificity and Sensitivity: Can we use these definitions to distinguish between people who do and do not have the disorder?
11. Schizophrenia & Other Psychotic Disorders 295.XX Schizophrenia
.30 Paranoid Type
.10 Disorganized Type
.20 Catatonic Type
.90 Undifferentiated Type
.60 Residual type
295.40 Schizophreniform Disorder
295.70 Schizoaffective Disorder
297.1 Delusional Disorder
298.8 Brief Psychotic Disorder
297.3 Shared Psychotic Disorder 293.XX Psychotic Disorders due to GMC
.81 with Delusions
.82 with Hallucinations
(. . .)Substance induced Psychotic Disorders
(Refer to substance specific codes)
298.9 Psychotic Disorders NOS
DSM-IV TR
12. Psychotic Symptoms
Presence of Delusions and Hallucinations
Severely disorganized behavior, speech and thought
Also occurs in Mood Disorders
May be associated with substance use
May be due to medication side effects
May be due to Delirium, GMC
DSM-IV TR
13. DSM-IV-TR Criteria for Schizophrenia 295.XX A – Characteristic symptoms - *two or more of the following, one month, less if treated:
Delusions
Hallucinations
Disorganized Speech
Disorganized or Catatonic Behavior
Negative symptoms
B – Social/Occupations Dysfunction
*One or more areas of functioning, work, self care or interpersonal relationship.
C – Duration
continuous signs of disturbance for six months
Continuous criteria for a month, less if treated
May also include Prodromal / residual symptoms
14. DSM-IV-TR Criteria for Schizophrenia (Cont’d) D – Schizoaffective and mood disorder exclusion
- if present, duration is very brief
E – Substance and GMC exclusion
F – Relationship to PDD
- Diagnosis of schizophrenia made if criteria A is met.
15. DSM-IV-TR Diagnostic Criteria for Schizophrenia Classification of Longitudinal course (at least one year has elapsed since the initial onset)
Episodic with Interepisode Residual symptoms
As above, with prominent negative symptoms
Episodic with no interepisode residual symptoms
Continuous with or without negative symptoms
Single episode – Full/partial remission
Single episode - with or without negative symptoms
Other or unspecified pattern
DSM-IV-TR
16. Subtypes of Schizophrenia
Pure types are less common
Mixtures of symptoms more common
Catatonic type – rare
Disorganized type *speech, behavior, affect
Paranoid type *diagnosis of exclusion
Undifferentiated type
Residual type
17. Case Study Young female, poor functioning
Lives with parents, unemployed
Two previous hospitalizations
Antipsychotics recently reduced
Can control behavior of others
Others can read her mind and being watched
Multiple voices, threatening in nature
Low energy, motivation, unable to think
Unable to care for herself
Depressed, decreased appetite and sleep DSM-IV-TR
18. Case Study (Cont’d) Enemy knew her thoughts
She could control other people’s activities
Thoughts were “stopping in mid stream”
Mind was “going blank”
Felt listless, depressed, unable to concentrate
Social contacts parents and boyfriend
Symptoms responded to Trifluoperazine readmitted following non-compliance
Overtly suspicious
Felt threatened by voices
Sad, exhausted, unable to enjoy anything
Chronically apprehensive “incapable of working”
Symptoms responded to Trifluoperazine
Returned home with parents
Switched to Risperidone as an outpatient
DSM-IV-TR