1 / 17

MIS 3090: IT for Financial Services

MIS 3090: IT for Financial Services. The Brokerage Industry. These slides are based on a previous presentation given by Chip Roame of Tiburon Strategic Advisors at the MMI Annual Convention (April 20, 2004). November 18, 2014. Market Segments. Facts & Perceptions by Segment.

Download Presentation

MIS 3090: IT for Financial Services

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. MIS 3090:IT for Financial Services The Brokerage Industry These slides are based on a previous presentation given by Chip Roame of Tiburon Strategic Advisors at the MMI Annual Convention (April 20, 2004) November 18, 2014

  2. Market Segments Facts & Perceptions by Segment High Net Worth Market Super Affluent Market Mass Market Affluent Market • Definition: <$100,000 of investable assets • Facts: • 80 million households • Still many un-served households • Being abandoned by full-service brokers and even some discount brokers • Need to watch profitability closely so as not to over-serve • Definition: $100,000 to $1,000,000 of investable assets • Facts: • 24 million households • Growing rapidly • Being courted by discount brokers and others • Definition: $1 to $5 million of investable assets • Facts: • 4 million households • Being courted by many full-service brokers, most bank trust departments, and many fee-only advisors • Growing very rapidly • Definition: $5+ million • Facts: • 250,000 households • Mostly locked into long-term relationships • Growing at moderate pace Source: 11/29/01 Senior Consultant Letter (Winks); 11/01 Financial Advisor; Tiburon Research & Analysis

  3. Clients’ Changing Needs • Solutions or life events-oriented • Versus returns-oriented • Seek tailored investments to meet goals, not earn returns • Income & protection-orientation • Versus accumulation & appreciation-orientation of their 40s and 50s • Suggests positive outlook for fixed income, fixed income annuities, principal protected products, disability insurance, long-term care insurance, and liability insurance • Sudden money events may change needs further • Tax orientation will increase with more assets • Sales will require forethought • Family office services and elder care to become more important • Life planning to grow as more wealth allows reconsideration of goals • Estate planning focus to increase with age • Suggests positive outlook for trusts, insurance, and charitable giving

  4. Wealth Buckets US Consumer Net Worth ($ Trillions) $46.5 $6.8 $9.6 $39.7 $12.4 $7.5 $17.1 Investable Assets Retirement Plan Assets Total Household Assets Total Household Net Worth Personal Assets Other Illiquid Assets Total Household Liabilities Note: Retirement plans include $1.9 trillion of 401k plans; IRAs though of $2.6 trillion are included in the investable assets number Note: For perspective, it is fun to consider that Bill Gates has approximately $40 billion in Microsoft and his total investable assets peaked a little above $100 billion in 1999 Note: Other sources suggest that investable assets total either $14.7 trillion or $18.1 trillion, and total household liabilities are $4.1 trillion Source: 1/22/04 McKinsey Quarterly; 5/22/02 Wachovia Presentation (Spectrem; McKinsey & Co.); 5/9/02 Wachovia Bank Wealth Management Presentation (Blythe); 5/9/02 Spectrem Presentation; 8/14/01 Wall Street Journal; 7/01 Registered Rep (Cerulli); 6/19/00 Investment News; 12/97 Federal Reserve Bank Flow of Funds Accounts and Consumer Finance Survey; 12/97 First Manhattan Consulting Group; 12/97 Sanford Bernstein Research; 12/97 Access Research; 12/97 ACLI; Tiburon Research & Analysis

  5. Some clients are wealthier than others Investable Assets by Market Segment Source: Tiburon Research & Analysis

  6. Need for Wealth Management Baby Boomer Life Phases & Key Events Peak Earnings & Savings Years Golden Years Early Stage Liquefaction Approximate Ages Key Life Events • 30s-40s • Marriage • Children • Early earnings years • Business ventures • Wealth accumulation • Early divorces • 50s • Late divorces • Peak earnings • Peak savings • Vacation homes • Children's college • Children’s marriage • Aging parents • Grand children • 60s-70s • Retirement • Liquefaction • Rollovers • Stock options • Sales of homes • Wealth transfer (received) • 80s-90s • Long-term care • Disability • Death of spouse • Wealth transfer (sent) • Charitable giving Source: 2/10/04 SEI Email (Smith); 1/7/04 SEI Conversation (Smith); 9/23/03 SEI Presentation (Smith); Tiburon Research & Analysis

  7. Preserve Wealth Build Wealth Goals change with age Primary Investment Goal Source: 5/9/02 Spectrem Presentation; Tiburon Research & Analysis

  8. Transfers into IRAs Annual IRA Rollovers ($ Billions) Note: One source calculated that $500 billion will roll into IRAs every year staring in 2010 Source: 8/14/01 American Banker; 8/01 Money (Cerulli); 7/13/01 Cerulli Presentation (EBRI; Pensions & Investments); 7/01 Registered Rep (Cerulli); Tiburon Research & Analysis

  9. Competition Competitive Playing Field Full-Service Brokers Discount Brokers • Segmenting offers • Moving to fee-based accounts • Adding help & advice • Moving up market Retail Banks • Up-selling banking customers • Rebuilding trust departments Emerging Affluent & Wealth Management Business Independent Advisors • Expanding investment offers • Extending services to wealth management Private Banks & Money Managers Insurance Companies CPA & Law Firms • Entering the business • Relying on fee-account programs • Moving down market • Testing new models • Entering the business • Relying on fee-account programs at the high-end Source: 5/22/02 Wachovia Presentation; Tiburon Research & Analysis

  10. Control of Investable Assets Consumer Investable Assets Independent Advisors $2.1 Trillion (12%) Bank Trust Departments $1.0 Trillion (6%) Wirehouse, Regional, & Boutique Brokers$6.2 Trillion (36%) Retail Banks $4.4 Trillion (26%) Discount Brokers $1.4 Trillion (8%) Insurance Companies$0.3 Trillion (2%) Mutual Fund Companies $1.7 Trillion (10%) Note: This chart excludes all double and triple counting; all dollars are only counted once in the customer-facing channel; excludes corporate, pension, and foreign investments and deposits Note: Another source suggested that brokerage firms manage $6.5 trillion and that the five wirehouses have $4.0 trillion in assets Source: 8/13/01 On Wall Street Web Site; 7/13/01 Cerulli Presentation (SIA); 11/6/00 Investment News (Cerulli Associates); 12/97 Securities Industry Yearbook; 12/97 S&P’s Securities Dealers of North America; 7/22/97 American Banker; 6/97 Financial Planning; 6/97 Dow Jones Investment Advisor; 5/12/97 Pensions & Investments; 4/12/97 American Banker; 3/26/97 American Banker; 3/97 Federal Reserve Bulletin; 12/96 ICI Complex Assets; 12/96 ACLI Life Insurance Factbook; 11/95 Best’s Review; 10/95 VitalSigns Database; Tiburon Research & Analysis

  11. Fee-Only seems better Annual Net New Assets ($ Billions) Source: 2/5/04 TD Waterhouse Conversation (Petrilli); 2/2/04 Investment News; 12/02 Investment Advisor; Tiburon Research & Analysis

  12. Schwab Emerges as a Leader Retail Customer Assets ($ Billions) Source: 8/16/01 US Bancorp Piper Jaffray Email (Bjorklund); 8/14/01 Wall Street Journal; 8/13/01 Investment News; 8/12/01 US Bancorp Piper Jaffray Web Site; 8/01 Business 2.0; 1/18/01 Wall Street Journal; Tiburon Research & Analysis

  13. Managers per Account Number of Managers Used Per Client 5 or More Managers 10% 4-5 Managers 15% 1 Manager 40% 2-3 Managers 35% Source: 11/7/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Rosenfield); 11/7/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Castle); 11/7/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Graham); 11/6/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Barnhill); 11/6/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Davidov); 11/6/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Lopez); 11/5/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Rafalko); 11/5/03 McDonald Advisor Conversation (Battaglia); 11/4/03 McDonald Advisor Conversation (Sikorski); Tiburon Research & Analysis

  14. Little customization on offer… Full-Service Broker Clients Who Customize Their Separately Managed Accounts Customize Separately Managed Accounts 18% Don’t Customize Separately Managed Accounts 82% Note: One source indicated that only 15% of separately managed accounts are customized at the time of set-up Note: Another source also noted that only 30% of accounts receive any special year-end tax treatment Note: Another source indicated that proprietary programs sponsors customize 25%-35% of separately managed accounts Source: 11/7/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Rosenfield); 11/7/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Castle); 11/7/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Graham); 11/6/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Barnhill); 11/6/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Davidov); 11/6/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Lopez); 11/5/03 Legg Mason Advisor Conversation (Rafalko); 11/5/03 McDonald Advisor Conversation (Battaglia); 11/4/03 McDonald Advisor Conversation (Sikorski); 6/03 On Wall Street; 7/2/02 Bob Veres Newsletter (Business Week); Tiburon Research & Analysis

  15. Detailed Checklist to Consider… Checklist by Segment High Net Worth Market Super Affluent Market Mass Market Affluent Market • Focus on mutual funds, annuities, and bank products • May evolve to include mutual fund wrap accounts and MSPs • Focus on financial planning, individual securities, mutual funds, mutual fund wrap accounts, MSPs, and separately managed accounts • May evolve into real estate products soon • Core & explore strategies using combinations of index funds & separate account managers may win out • Separately managed accounts (of course) • Want institutional products such as alternative asset classes (hedge funds, venture capital, real estate) • May see use of custom core index products • Wealth management becomes more important than investment management • Family office services emerging • Already seeing use of custom core index products • Already accessing institutional products (e.g., 55% own hedge funds) • Further seeking institutionally-oriented long-term investments – e.g. timber (yes, trees!) • Wealth management clearly is key offering and family office services growing in importance Source: Tiburon Research & Analysis

  16. Conclusion • Fee-only financial advisors (one of the booming channels) are questioning the SMA model, in favor of low cost funds, including index funds and ETFs as the core & explore model continues to gain steam… • Discount brokers will thrive… Schwab is adding accounts fast and now is back over $1 trillion with an average account size over $100,000… • Banks… some clients still love them… • CPAs and lawyers may have trust positions with the ultra affluent… and could act as trusted advisors

  17. For Next Class… • Read • Read Charles Schwab case carefully • Read through the articles listed on the class website

More Related