200 likes | 602 Views
Impact of Alcohol Dependence on Women’s Parenting Sense of Competence. Meghan Andreycak, Casey Farmer, Katherine Gardes, Erin Gilbert, Jessica Henkel, Mary LaBella, Joanne Stein, and Kate Werley 12.20.2004. Introduction.
E N D
Impact of Alcohol Dependence on Women’s Parenting Sense of Competence Meghan Andreycak, Casey Farmer, Katherine Gardes, Erin Gilbert, Jessica Henkel, Mary LaBella, Joanne Stein, and Kate Werley 12.20.2004
Introduction • At least one out of every five pregnant women smokes, drinks, and/or uses drugs. • Although women represent 40% of the nation’s alcoholics, women make up only 28% of all people who receive treatment • Only about 10% of treatment programs are designed specifically for women
Background and Significance • Alcoholism: • Genetic factors • Physiological factors • Neuropsychological factors • Environmental factors • Alcohol dependence and parenting: • Concerns of women alcoholics • Difficulty “working a selfish program” • Women in gender-specific alcohol treatment programs have better success
Background and Significance • Belsky’s Model of the Determinants of Parenting: • Psychological characteristics • Child characteristics • Sources of stress and support
Background and Significance • Gaps in literature: • Research has traditionally focused on men • Heterogeneity of women with alcohol dependence • Lack of research specific to parental status
Study Aims and Hypothesis • Is there a difference in the parental competence of women with alcohol dependence problems and those without alcohol dependence problems? • We hypothesize that those with alcohol dependence problems will have lower levels of parental competence
Methods: Sample • Convenience sample (n = 204) • Married • Caucasian and African-American mothers • Ages 18 to 68 years • Average of two children • Some post-secondary education • Employed full-time • Earn an average household income of over $50,000
Methods: Measures • Parenting Sense of Competence Scale • 17-item paper and pencil scale • Developed to assess the level of new parents’ sense of competence • Two subscales: • Skill/Knowledge • Value/Comfort
Methods: Measures • Parenting Sense of Competence Scale cont. • Six point scale spanning from strongly agree (1) to strongly disagree (6) • Reverse scoring • Internal consistency reliability for both subscales and convergent and discriminant validity are reported • Change in focus of scale
Methods: Measures • Alcohol Dependence Scale • 25-item scale • Administered via paper-and-pencil or interview • Four key factors for measuring alcohol dependence • Internal consistency reliability and validity • Predictive of DSM-IV-TR diagnosis • Helpful in determining intensity of treatment
Methods: Measures • Alcohol Dependence Scale cont. • Each possible response for the 25 items corresponds with a number • Scores range from 0 to 47 • Four quartiles • Modifications
Methods: Procedure • Part of a larger effort at the UMB School of Social Work • Pilot test • IRB • Survey distribution • Data entry/ data cleaning • Protecting human research subjects
Results • Global Scale • An independent sample t test yielded unexpected results • The null hypothesis was supported • Respondents with alcohol dependence problems (M = 49.02, SD = 10.38) report statistically greater scores on the PSOC scale than do respondents with no reported alcohol dependence problems (M = 43.81, SD = 9.52), t(152) = -2.935, p = .004 (two-tailed)
Results • Skill/Knowledge Subscale • Those with alcohol dependence problems (M = 24.92, SD = 6.47) report higher scores than those with no reported alcohol problems (M = 22.92, SD = 6.46) • However, the difference is not significant, t(181)= -1.861, p = .064 (two-tailed)
Results • Valuing/Comfort Subscale • Those respondents with reported alcohol dependence problems (M = 24.78, SD = 6.63) have statistically significant higher scores than those with no reported alcohol dependence problems (M = 20.97, SD = 5.22), t(156)= -3.745, p = .000 (two-tailed)
Discussion • The data indicated the reverse relationship between parenting and alcohol dependence: those with higher levels of dependence scored higher on the global scale for parenting competence and the valuing/comfort scale • Potential explanations
Discussion • Study Strengths: • Pilot test • Range of maternal ages • Measures
Discussion • Limitations: • Altered cut-off • Minimization of drinking behaviors • Lack of standardization of survey administration
Discussion • Further research and implications for social work practice • Directing future studies • Importance of examining the relationship between alcohol dependence and mother's parental competence