E N D
1: Pharmacologic & Surgical Approaches Nancy F. Krebs, MD, MS, FAAP
3: Pharmaco-therapy For severely overweight children, the risk of complications is great
Adjunctive therapy may be helpful in achieving weight loss & in treating co-morbidities
Must be used in conjunction with behavioral, dietary, and activity approaches
Cost effectiveness: coverage for drugs, not for conservative measures?
4: Use of Pharmacotherapy Potential for significant adverse effects:
Hypertension
Pulmonary hypertension
Psychological effects
Currently available for pediatric use:
Sibutramine (Meridia)
Orlistat (Xenical)
(Metformin)
5: Anorectic Agents: Limit food intake Should complement diet/exercise program
Modest effects on total weight loss
Variable responses (may reflect heterogeneity in etiology)
Most benefit achieved within first 4 mo
Regain of weight the norm when drug therapy stopped
6: Sibutramine (Meridia) Non-selective inhibitor of neuronal reuptake of serotonin and norepinephrine: appetite suppressant
7: Sibutramine Berkowitz et al. JAMA 289:1805, 2003
82 obese adolescents
(13-17 yr; BMI Z-score + 2.4)
All received behavior (& diet) therapy
Randomized to sibutramine vs. placebo
74 completed first 6 months, 62 completed 1 year) (after 6 mo, open label)
8: Sibutramine + Behavior Therapy
9: Sibutramine -Side Effects 19/43 with mild hypertension and tachycardia; 5 required discontinuation
Other side effects
Insomnia, anxiety, headache, depression, risk of serotonin syndrome in combination with other CNS drugs
No data in absence of behavioral intervention
**FDA Approved for patients over age 16
10: Orlistat (Xenical) Pancreatic lipase inhibitor: fat malabsorption
12: Orlistat Inhibits pancreatic lipase and increases fecal fat losses
20 adolescents, BMI 44.1 ± 12.6, with at least one comorbidity; behavioral therapy + orlistat in open-label fashion x 3 mo
13: Orlistat-Clinical Trial Inclusion criteria:
Male or female
12–16 years
BMI: minimum 28.5 – 32 (age dependent)
Exclusion criteria:
BMI ? 44 kg/m2
Body weight ? 130 kg or < 55 kg
Diabetes mellitus
539 subjects studied
• all received lifestyle intervention
• randomized to orlistat vs. placebo x 1 year
14: Change in Weight
15: Orlistat Clinical Trial Modest responses (+ 0.53 kg vs +3.14 kg at 1 yr); slight ? BMI vs ? in placebo)
Wt loss ? 5%: 26% vs 16%
Wt loss ? 10%: 13% vs 4.5%
Dropout rates ~ 1/3 both groups
No significant differences in lipid profiles or glucose tolerance/insulin
Weight loss associated w/ greater fat loss
16: Orlistat Clinical Trial No apparent differences in response by sex or ethnic/racial group
Side effects:
no micronutrient (f.s. vit) deficiencies
GI Symptoms:
50% w/ fatty stools
29% w/ oily spotting ? ? to 8.5%
8.8% w/ fecal incontinence ? ? to 2.0%
Requires education of patients
**FDA approved for children over age 12
17: Metformin
18: Metformin ? hepatic gluconeogenesis and glucose production; ? hepatic insulin sensitivity
Attenuates lipogenic state of hyperinsulinism
(obesity ? ? insulin resistance/hyperinsulinism)
? food intake
? fat stores (SQ > visceral?), improves lipid profiles
25 % reduction in cumulative 3 yr incidence of T2DM in adults; ? CV morbidity & mortality in adults w/ T2DM
19: Metformin in Obese Adolescents Freemark et al. Pediatrics 107:e55, 2001
32 obese adolescents with insulin resistance and positive family history of T2DM (29 completed)
Double-blind, randomized to metformin vs. placebo x 6 months
No dietary restriction
20: Metformin in Obese Adolescents
22: Metformin in Obese Adolescents Side effects:
Transient abdominal discomfort or diarrhea (< 1 mo)
(Lactic acidosis (rare) in adults with chronic cardiac, hepatic, renal or GI disease)
Urinary losses of B vitamins: use daily MVI in all metformin patients
**Approved for Type 2 diabetes mellitus; not yet approved for obesity
23: Metformin in Obese Adolescents Remaining questions:
Effects on weight (fat mass) loss w/ medication +/- lifestyle changes
Effects on hyper/dys-lipidemia unclear
Longer-term studies w/ larger “n” underway – safety & efficacy
24: Sibutramine: beware CV effects; acts on CNS
Orlistat: highly motivated, h/o significant fat intake; GI effects may be limiting fx
Metformin:
obese adolescent with insulin resistance
obesity due to psychotropic drugs ? Summary: Medication Choices
25: Summary - Medications Additional (to behavioral + lifestyle Rx) positive effect of medication is modest on average, substantial for some
Reimbursement?
Lifestyle: often “no”
Medications: more likely?
Access: medications vs (+/-) lifestyle
Duration of treatment? Compliance?
Predictors of optimal choice?
26: Summary – MedicationsPediatric Nutrition Handbook (5th Ed): “Drug therapy in children is not recommended…currently no Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved medications for use in children < 16 years of age.
“However, in some extremely obese adolescent patients with life-threatening morbidities, this approach may be necessary with the warning that…studies of the effectiveness of these drugs in children have not yet been reported.”
27: Medication Quandry: Is the glass ˝ full or ˝ empty? Reserve meds for the “extreme” situation &/or use only as “experimental”?
or
View as part of the armamentarium, knowing effect will be greater for some than others?
(e.g. –24% vs +1% ? BMI)
28: Bariatric Surgery
31: Bariatric Surgery for Severely Overweight Adolescents: Concerns and Recommendations Criteria :
Failed at least 6 months of organized weight management (as per PCP)
Attained (or nearly) physiologic maturity
BMI >40 with serious obesity-related comorbidity or BMI >50 with less severe comorbidities
33: Bariatric Surgery for Severely Overweight Adolescents: Concerns and Recommendations Criteria (cont):
Commitment to comprehensive medical and psychologic evaluations before and after surgery
Avoid pregnancy at least one year after surgery
Be capable and willing to adhere to nutritional guidelines postoperatively
Provide informed assent to surgical treatment
Demonstrate decisional capacity
Have supportive family environment
38: Advantages:
Significant weight loss or lower BMI (~33%) one year post-op; generally sustainable (14 year f/u)
Deterrence to carbohydrate ingestion
Enhanced satiety
Risks:
Perioperative death (0.5%) (vs ABG: [.05%]) (adults)
Other: intestinal leakage, thromboembolic disease, SBO, incisional hernia, cholelithiasis, PCM
Micronutrient deficiencies: Fe, Ca, B1, B12, folate
Late deaths also reported (up to 6 years post-op)
Late weight regain? (up to 15% of pts)
39: Bariatric Surgery: Experience Counts
43: Advantages:
Minimally invasive placement (laparoscopic)
Less nutrient effect compared with RNYGB
Adjustable (by MD – encourages f/u)
Removable
Disadvantages:
? Slower weight loss (max at 2-3 yr p-op)
Finite lifetime (needs to be replaced)
Long term results are unknown (only available for <10 years)
Not yet approved by FDA for <18 y/o (not covered by insurance)
46: Surgical Outcomes (primarily based on adult data) ? mortality:
Morbidly obese diabetic adults – 9 yr obs:
28% vs 9% w/o vs w/ bariatric surgery
Improvement in dyslipidemia: 80% pts
Hypertension: resolves 65%, improves 80%
(may not be longstanding)
T2DM: 75% pts remission; 85% pts ? disease burden
? Obstructive sleep apnea
Psychological: ? depression, ? self concept/QOL
47: Research Considerations & Future Directions Long-term outcomes of bariatric surgery in adolescents remain to be defined
Risk/benefit & timing of intervention: earlier “correction” of metabolic derangements (how early is too early?)
Future efforts directed at determination of physiologic mechanisms
alteration in appetite
feeding behavior
energy balance
48: Acknowledgements Mel Heyman, MD, FAAP
Thomas Inge, MD
Many, many colleagues!
49: GG 9-1/2 yr old girl, healthy
Cc: Parents:
concern about ?’g wt & effects on health
Want pt to become more committed to health
What is the problem?
“She loves food; watches food network on cable, cookbooks, etc”
Pt: eating makes her “feel better”
50: 9 yr old GG Diet hx:
Brk: 2 sl pizza + ice cream (2 scoops)
Lunch: double cheeseburger & fries
Dinner: hamburger, bun, 2 scoops of ice cream
Few limits; “doesn’t know when to stop eating”
Often skips lunch, eats through evening
51: GG Activity history:
Competitive jump roping, soccer – 2-4x/wk
< 2 hr TV/d; computer < 1x/wk
PMHX: benign; h/o hyperlipidemia
FHx: BMI: Dad 26; Mom 22; + hx T2DM, obesity, hypertension, g.b. disease
SHx: dad in health care admin; mom home full time
ROS: mild joint c/o; o/w negative
52: GG: School Aged Child
54: GG Wt: 72 kg, Ht 146
Exam: positive acanthosis nigricans, o/w unremarkable except for overweight status
Assessment:
BMI = 33.7 (190% of ideal, c/w severe o.w.)
At risk for insulin resistance, hyperlipidemia
Multiple dietary problems
Excessive portion sizes
Lack of structure/limits on eating
High risk foods in household
55: Setting the Agenda: A Joint Proposition
56: GG: Recommendations Diet & Eating
? portions/size of breakfast (max 2-3 pancakes or 1 piece french toast;
Eat only in the kitchen, w/ adult present
“Close the kitchen” between meals/snacks
Keep ice cream out of house
Activity – continue soccer & jump rope
Behavior
Kept “health calendar”
Weigh self q 2 wk (set a start date)
57: GG: School Aged Child
58: Diet Control Stop all sugar beverages (soda AND juice)
Drink water and low fat milk
Healthy snack = protein + fruit/veg (e.g. peanut butter and banana)
Wait 20 min for second helpings
Reduce TV time