1 / 29

Proposal Evaluation Results

2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results. 2. . . Overview of Proposal Review Process. FIRST ROUNDFocus: Meeting the requirements and intent of the RFPCombination of 3 internal and external reviewersScoring instrument that reflects criteria in RFPRanked on basis of average score. S

sezja
Download Presentation

Proposal Evaluation Results

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

    1. Proposal Evaluation Results Presented to Ohio Third Frontier Commission December 17, 2009

    2. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 2 Overview of Proposal Review Process FIRST ROUND Focus: Meeting the requirements and intent of the RFP Combination of 3 internal and external reviewers Scoring instrument that reflects criteria in RFP Ranked on basis of average score SECOND ROUND Focus: Quality of the Investment for Ohio Customized set of questions and written responses Face-to-face meeting (90 minutes) Risk-benefit scoring Technical Risk Commercial Risk Mission Impact Ranked on basis of fit to ODOD targets

    3. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 3 Second Round Scoring Methodology

    4. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 4 Competition Metrics

    5. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 5 Funding Available

    6. 2010 Third Frontier Fuel Cell Program

    7. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 7 TFFCP Recommendations for Funding

    8. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 8 2010 Third Frontier Fuel Cell Program Energy Technologies, Inc. (TFFCP 10-207 / Rank: 1)

    9. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 9 2010 Third Frontier Fuel Cell Program Rolls-Royce Fuel Cell Systems (US), Inc. (TFFCP 10-203 / Rank: 2)

    10. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 10 2010 Third Frontier Fuel Cell Program NexTech Materials, Ltd. (TFFCP 10-211 / Rank: 3)

    11. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 11 2010 Third Frontier Fuel Cell Program Wellman Products Group (TFFCP 10-210 / Rank: 4)

    12. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 12 2010 Third Frontier Fuel Cell Program Lockheed Martin MS2 Integrated Defense Technologies (TFFCP 10-231 / Rank: 5)

    13. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 13 2010 Third Frontier Fuel Cell Program UltraCell Corporation, Ohio Manufacturing Operations (TFFCP 10-218 / Rank: 6)

    14. 2010 Third Frontier Photovoltaic Program

    15. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 15 TFPVP Recommendations for Funding

    16. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 16 2010 Third Frontier Photovoltaic Program Xunlight Corporation (TFPVP 10-415 / Rank: 1)

    17. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 17 2010 Third Frontier Photovoltaic Program Ferro Corporation, Electronic Material Systems (TFPVP 10-424 / Rank: 2)

    18. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 18 2010 Third Frontier Photovoltaic Program Glasstech, Inc. (TFPVP 10-409 / Rank: 3)

    19. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 19 2010 Third Frontier Photovoltaic Program SCI Engineered Materials, Inc. (TFPVP 10-420 / Rank: 4)

    20. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 20 2010 Third Frontier Photovoltaic Program Five Star Technologies, Inc. (TFPVP 10-412 / Rank: 5)

    21. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 21 2010 Third Frontier Photovoltaic Program Replex Plastics (TFPVP 10-416 / Rank: 6)

    22. 2010 Third Frontier Advanced Energy Program

    23. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 23 TFAEP Recommendations for Funding

    24. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 24 2010 Third Frontier Advanced Energy Program Ershigs (TFAEP 10-325 / Rank: 1)

    25. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 25 2010 Third Frontier Advanced Energy Program R. W. Beckett Corporation (TFAEP 10-358 / Rank: 2)

    26. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 26 2010 Third Frontier Advanced Energy Program Avtron Industrial Automation (TFAEP 10-396 / Rank: 3)

    27. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 27 2010 Third Frontier Advanced Energy Program Novolyte Technologies, Inc. (TFAEP 10-319 / Rank: 4)

    28. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 28 2010 Third Frontier Advanced Energy Program GrafTech International Holdings, Inc. (TFAEP 10-342 / Rank: 5)

    29. 2010 TFFCP / TFPVP / TFAEP Proposal Evaluation Results 29 2010 Third Frontier Advanced Energy Program quasar energy group (TFAEP 10-375 / Rank: 6)

More Related