1 / 19

Priority Issues – H-1B, L-1 & Offshore Outsourcing

Priority Issues – H-1B, L-1 & Offshore Outsourcing. Ron Hira, Ph.D., P.E., Chair Career & Workforce Policy Committee. IEEE-USA Leadership Workshop 19 March 2004. Guest-Worker Visas – H-1Bs & L-1s. What is the issue? Programs are being used outside intent of law and they need to be reformed

siran
Download Presentation

Priority Issues – H-1B, L-1 & Offshore Outsourcing

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Priority Issues – H-1B, L-1 & Offshore Outsourcing Ron Hira, Ph.D., P.E., ChairCareer & Workforce Policy Committee IEEE-USA Leadership Workshop19 March 2004

  2. Guest-Worker Visas – H-1Bs & L-1s • What is the issue? • Programs are being used outside intent of law and they need to be reformed • Lobbyists (Immigration Lawyers & Industry) do not want reform, in fact they want to expand the programs exposing them to more misuse • What IEEE-USA would like: • Reform the H-1B & L-1

  3. Guest-Worker Visas – H-1B Problems • H-1Bs • Intent of Law: • When an American worker cannot be found for a particular position, companies can petition to hire a foreign national on a temporary non-immigrant visa • Protection of American workers through ‘prevailing wages’ and other safeguards • Cap on maximum number of H-1Bs in a particular year • Problem With Law • Companies can and do prefer foreign workers over US workers • Protections don’t protect • Sneaking in expansion in Free Trade Agreements

  4. Guest-Worker Visas – L-1 Problems • L-1s – ‘Intra-company’ Transfer • Intent of Law: • Multinational Companies can bring their foreign workers to the US for up to 5 years • Only workers with ‘specialized’ knowledge can come • knowledge specific to the company, • not generic skills like a common programming language • Problems With Law • Companies, such as Tata, bring rank-and-file workers in to work at a customer’s site essentially as a contract workers • NO Protections for US Workers – e.g., no prevailing wage • NO Cap • Sneaking in expansion in Free Trade Agreements

  5. H-1B Examples That Meet Intent of Law Source: R. Hira Analysis US Dept of Labor LCA Database: www.flcdatacenter.com

  6. H-1B Examples Stretch Intent of LawOffshore Outsourcing Companies Use Is Order(s) of Magnitude Greater Source: R. Hira Analysis US Dept of Labor LCA Database: www.flcdatacenter.com

  7. Offshore Outsourcing Companies Pay Low Wages to H-1Bs Source: R. Hira Analysis US Dept of Labor LCA Database: www.flcdatacenter.com

  8. Offshoring Definitions • Outsourcing – Classic Make or Buy Decision • Procter & Gamble contracts with HP for IT services • Offshore Outsourcing • Sending work to outsourcers who operate overseas • Offshore Sourcing aka Off-shoring • Daimler Chrysler has an R&D center in Bangalore • On-site Offshore Outsourcing • Tata Consultancy Services, Infosys, Wipro, Satyam • Blended Sourcing Near Shore, Best Shore, etc

  9. Why Do Companies Utilize Overseas Technology Talent? • Cost • Exceptional Talent? • Shortage of U.S. workers? Ph.D.’s? • Politics & Access to the Local Market • Trade, e.g., China & Russia – Boeing engineers • Developing Countries’ Strategy • Tax Holidays & Incentives • 24/7 Capabilities • Collaborative Engineering Technology • Companies Aware Of Possibility & Believe It Helps Their Performance

  10. Overseas Engineers Can Afford To Be Paid Less

  11. How Much Engineering Work Has Moved Offshore? • No One Knows • No one in government is collecting data • Commerce Department has pilot study underway - $300k • Companies are reluctant to reveal their plans • US workers unwittingly training their replacements • Many believe it is only ‘low-level’ work • No data to support or refute this claim • Estimates Abound from Self-Interested Research Firms • The Forrester Report is most-cited but also dated • Completed in November, 2002

  12. Domestic IT Labor Market RecordUnemployment(source: IEEE-USA from BLS)

  13. 1983-03 Tech Unemployment Rates

  14. Jobs Moving OverseasPredicted Impacts • Job Dislocation • Creates immediate problems for US engineers who are displaced • Job market is still soft so displacement generally leads to un(der)employment • Not creating jobs • No one knows why • Change in Mix of Domestic Occupations • Longer term questions on whether we will have a healthy technology workforce in the US

  15. Job Dislocation During Low Job Creation

  16. Offshoring Policies • Need to get an objective count of nature and scale of jobs moving offshore • Reform H-1B & L-1 visa programs • accelerating off-shore outsourcing • No coincidence major offshore outsourcers are heavy users of H-1B & L-1 • Cognizant, Tata, Wipro, Infosys, Satyam, IGate, etc. • Help displaced workers • Ensure healthy US technology workforce • Begin open & sober dialogue about implications of off-shoring • Dialogue has been rife with misinformation

  17. What IEEE-USA Can Do • Continue to engage congressional staff by providing them objective information • formally (hearing testimonies) and informally (staffer to staffer) • Engage the press and provide objective information • Facilitate IEEE members’ engagement in the policy process

  18. What You Can Do • Meet with your Congressperson in the district office • Go to IEEE-USA’s Legislative Action Center website and write to your legislators • Respond to ‘Action Alerts’ • Russ Harrison, IEEE-USA staffer, can help • Write to state legislators

  19. What You Can Do • Enlist members of Regions/Sections/ Chapters/PACE • To be effective, we need large numbers • Spread the word amongst colleagues, family and friends • Provide IEEE-USA with individual stories • We want to better understand the situation of members • Back up the statistics with individualized stories to get an effective message out

More Related