230 likes | 315 Views
Nations, States and Autonomy. Nation vs. State. Nation State. A modern state (L. Mair). Territoriality Centralization of decision making Differentiation of functions Sovereignty. A modern state (T. Parsons). Judiciary across lineages Codified, written-down laws Standing military
E N D
Nation vs. State • Nation • State
A modern state (L. Mair) • Territoriality • Centralization of decision making • Differentiation of functions • Sovereignty
A modern state (T. Parsons) • Judiciary across lineages • Codified, written-down laws • Standing military • Differentiation of a distinct class of priests • Breakdown of the fusion of religion and society • Differentiation of technical skills
A modern state (M. Weber) • End of patrimonialism • Officials paid by the center • Non-particularistic bureaucracy
Where state and nation do not meet… • Stateless nations • Multi-national states • Multi-state nations • Can you name some examples?
Constructing the Nation • Language • Print-Capitalism • War • Genocide
Benedict Anderson’s Imagined Communities (1983) • National identity replacing religious communities and dynastic realms • Three conceptions lost their grip: • Driven by vernacular print-capitalism seeking a larger market
The Rise of the State • Leviathan (Hobbes) • Natural Rights (Locke) • Social Contract (Rousseau via Tilly) • Stationary Bandit (Olson) • Transaction Costs (North) • Division of labor (Durkheim) • Class Conflict (Marx)
Historical Challenges Lipset and Rokkan identify four conflict-creating challenges to state formation in European history: • State building • The Reformation • Industrial Revolution • Democracy
Recurrent Challenges • Succession of Leadership • Ethnic & Regional Conflict
Creating political obligation • Results • Habit or Tradition • Personality or Charisma • Identity • Procedures • Socialization • Agenda and Framing • Political Recruitment
The 30 Years War • About Religion or about Stateness? • Peace of Augsburg (1555) • 1618 Deposition • Costs and External Powers
The Peace • Terms • Political Consequences • A Nation-State System