70 likes | 181 Views
Results for France. Regulations have to be developed, but few changes are needed on the NPPs for harmonizationOver two third of the ?reference levels" are not formally required according to the study's definitionVery few ?reference levels" have to be addressed for implementationThe result of the
E N D
2. Results for France Regulations have to be developed, but few changes are needed on the NPPs for harmonization
Over two third of the “reference levels” are not formally required according to the study’s definition
Very few “reference levels” have to be addressed for implementation
The result of the benchmark is not a surprise
French situation : one operator of NPPs, State-owned
ASN’s requirements have been mostly expressed in individual letters to the licensees
The licensees have also implemented safety provisions on their own
3. Examples of points to be addressed regarding implementation Issue E – Safety Verification
Provide means for the control of combustible gases
In 2001, ASN decided that all NPPs shall be equipped with passive autocatalytic hydrogen recombiners by the end of 2007
Implementation in progress
Issue O – Probabilistic Safety Assessments
PSA shall cover all hazards such as fire or earthquake
There are level 1 PSA for all French plants, but they do not deal with all hazards ; development of “Fire PSA” in progress
It was considered that the results of PSA for external hazards contain too much uncertainties to be used in the safety demonstration
Need to discuss how to take into account this reference level
4. Comments on the results regarding regulation
Two issues are relatively well covered by specific French regulations
O – PSA (basic safety rule for level 1 PSA)
S – Internal fires (ministerial order)
On the other topics
Parts of existing French regulations have been judged equivalent to some “reference levels”
Nevertheless, ASN intends to write new regulatory documents to cover all the “reference levels” in a consistent way
5. Actions towards harmonization (1) The work has already begun
New structure for the regulation
Ministerial orders (legally binding) : safety objectives
Guides (not legally binding) : recommended means
5 new orders and guides to be drafted, modification of the existing regulation on fire
Safety management, quality (all nuclear installations)
Emergency preparedness (all nuclear installations)
Safety approach for nuclear power plants
Design of PWRs
Operation of PWRs
6. Actions towards harmonization (2)
Consultation of the stakeholders on the draft documents, including WENRA
Discussions needed with French stakeholders to see how to achieve implementation of the “reference levels” that are still not implemented
7. Concluding remarks