190 likes | 439 Views
CROSS-COUNTRY WORKSHOP FOR IMPACT EVALUATIONS IN AGRICULTURE AND COMMUNITY DRIVEN DEVELOPMENT Addis Ababa, April 13-16, 2009. Ethiopia Nile Irrigation and Drainage Project Impact Evaluation. CROSS-COUNTRY WORKSHOP FOR IMPACT EVALUATIONS IN AGRICULTURE AND COMMUNITY DRIVEN DEVELOPMENT
E N D
CROSS-COUNTRY WORKSHOP FOR IMPACT EVALUATIONS IN AGRICULTURE AND COMMUNITY DRIVEN DEVELOPMENT Addis Ababa, April 13-16, 2009 Ethiopia Nile Irrigation and Drainage Project Impact Evaluation
CROSS-COUNTRY WORKSHOP FOR IMPACT EVALUATIONS IN AGRICULTURE AND COMMUNITY DRIVEN DEVELOPMENT Addis Ababa, April 13-16, 2009 Impact Evaluation Team Members: Israel Tessema _ Agronomist Gossaye Fanta- Economist Kinnon Scott- Survey Expert Badre Lanedri- Irrigation expert
PROJECT AREA Title
PROJECT COMPONENTS Title • Component 1: Irrigation Development Develop irrigation infrastructure for 20,000 ha and ascertain future irrigation potential in 80,000 ha. Directly benefit participating households, expected to number approximately 12,600 in Megech at Seraba and Ribb. • Component 2: Agricultural and Market Development Sustainable intensification and commercialization of agriculture on the irrigation schemes • Component 3: Irrigation Management Enhance management and financial sustainability of irrigation infrastructure through PIM (WUA) and PPP • Component 4: Project Management Manage resources to timely and effectively implement the project
PRIORITIES FOR LEARNING: INTERVENTIONS Title • Impact of irrigation on productivity • Effect of agricultural and market support on productuvity and households incomes • Sustainibility of alternative fees collection mechanisms • Health implications of irrigation/water supply
EVALUATION QUESTIONS Title • Irrigation and Agriculture • Irrigation and Health
EVALUATION QUESTIONS Title • Irrigation and Agriculture • What is the effet of irrigation on land use, agricultural output and hushold income? • What is the effect of agricultural/market support/incentives on cropping intensity and farm productivity/incomes? • What is the most suitable institutional arrangements to achieve higher fees collection performance?
EVALUATION QUESTIONS Title • Irrigation and Health • What is the effect of irrigation on health outcomes? • What is the effet of irrigation on the availibility of water for domestic use? • How to increase the safety of irrigation water for demoestic use?
EVALUATION DESIGN Title • Phase 1 will see the construction of the main irrigation canals and some secondary and tertiary canals. • Phase 2 will see the finalization in the construction of all secondary and tertiary irrigation canals.
Phase 2: Construction of Secondary Canals C’ B’ Treatment/ Control R E S E R V O I R Phase 1: Construction of Primary Canals A C Control/ Treatment Treatment/ Control A’ B EVALUATION DESIGN Title Content D :out of scheme
SAMPLING AND DATA Title • Sampling should consider the land size (small, medium, large) • Sampling should consider the irrigation experience of farmers • Sampling should consider land ownership by gender and youth • Sources of data: cadastral survey, future households survey, irrigation system feasability studies, cost financial data from each fee collector (WUAs, Cooperatives, Traders.), testing water quality, gov. Bureaus.
IMPACT EVALUATION TEAM: STAFFING Title National Project Team: Impact-Eval. specialists (Governments, World BanK) Agronomist Economist Survey expert Social and Gender specialist Irrigation and water expert Health/sanitation specialist
BUDGET Title We do not Know currently but we are working on this. It may be costly as the design is ambitious but the learning opportunities warrant the expenditure.
EIDP: Visual rendering Title
EIDP: Visual rendering Title Thank You for your attention