200 likes | 352 Views
AUTHOR INFORMATION. Presented by: Dr Gregor UrbasFaculty of LawAustralian National UniversityGregor.Urbas@anu.edu.au Co-author:Paul WilliamsSocial Research ProgramAustralian National University Paul.Willliams@anu.edu.au . PAPER FOR CONFERENCE PRESENTATION HANDOUT. Heroin Ov
E N D
1. WITNESSES TO ILLICIT DRUG OVERDOSES:Rights, Risks and Responsibilities Innovations Conference :
Promising Practices in Criminal Justice Responses to Victims and Witnesses
University House
Australian National University
23-24 October 2003
2. AUTHOR INFORMATION Presented by:
Dr Gregor Urbas
Faculty of Law
Australian National University
Gregor.Urbas@anu.edu.au
Co-author:
Paul Williams
Social Research Program
Australian National University Paul.Willliams@anu.edu.au
3. PAPER FOR CONFERENCE PRESENTATION HANDOUT Heroin Overdoses and Duty of Care
P Williams and G Urbas
Trends and Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice
No.188 (February 2001)
http://www.aic.gov.au
4. PRESENTATION OVERVIEW Research Context – Illicit drugs policy
5. PRESENTATION OVERVIEW Research Context – Illicit drugs policy
Particular Finding – Non-reporting of drug overdoses
6. PRESENTATION OVERVIEW Research Context – Illicit drugs policy
Particular Finding – Non-reporting of drug overdoses
Legal Question – Position of witnesses
7. PRESENTATION OVERVIEW Research Context – Illicit drugs policy
Particular Finding – Non-reporting of drug overdoses
Legal Question – Position of witnesses
Duty of Care – Basis and circumstances
8. PRESENTATION OVERVIEW Research Context – Illicit drugs policy
Particular Finding – Non-reporting of drug overdoses
Legal Question – Position of witnesses
Duty of Care – Basis and circumstances
Criminal Liability – Homicide offences
9. PRESENTATION OVERVIEW Research Context – Illicit drugs policy
Particular Finding – Non-reporting of drug overdoses
Legal Question – Position of witnesses
Duty of Care – Basis and circumstances
Criminal Liability – Homicide offences
Public Health Message – Call for an ambulance!
10. THE NON-REPORTING PROBLEM National Drug Strategy Household Survey 1998 revealed:
Over 80,000 males and 100,000 females witnessed at least one heroin overdose
Majority witnessed from 1 to 4 overdoses
Overwhelming majority of witnesses were also injecting drug users
64% always called for medical assistance
12% sometimes called for assistance
24% never called for medical assistance
11. REASONS FOR NOT CALLING FOR ASSISTANCE Did not want to get involved (22%)
Capable of handling overdose (40%)
Afraid of police involvement (33%)
Capability (54%) and police involvement (41%) higher for injecting witnesses
Concerns included:
outstanding warrants and
fear of manslaughter charges in event of lethal overdose
12. ARE WITNESSES’ FEARS WELL-FOUNDED? Legal position of witnesses depends on:
whether duty of care owed
whether duty of care breached
whether death / injury result from overdose
availability of medical assistance
police / prosecution discretion
public health considerations
particular circumstances / criminal background of witnesses
13. RISK FACTOR SCALE Injecting another person Supply of injecting equipment / drugs Encouragement / advice Inadequate post-overdose assistance Ownership / control of premises Mere presence at overdose Mere presence after overdose