Religious Education Congress Sunday, March 2, 2008 Felix Just, S.J. catholic-resources

1. Exciting “New” Gospels?What Catholics need to knowabout the Gospel of Judas and other apocryphal writings Religious Education Congress Sunday, March 2, 2008 Felix Just, S.J. http://catholic-resources.org

2. Introduction: Apocryphal Books • There are MANY ancient Jewish or Christian writings not found in the OT or NT! • Have you read the entire text of… • …the Gospel of James? …of Peter? • …the Gospel of Thomas? (both?) • …the Gospel of Mary (Magdalene)? …of Judas? – really? • …the Letter of Barnabas? …the Didache? • …the 1st Book of Enoch? …the Book of Jubilees? • Have you read ALL of the four NT Gospels? • The whole NT? The whole OT?

3. Introduction: Apocryphal Books • Should Catholic-Christians read these books? • Yes!(If you wish!) But for what purpose? • Historical knowledge: Jesus & apostles? – NO! • Historical knowledge: How early Christian beliefs developed in the first few centuries? – Yes! • Theological understanding: Our faith today? – – Only indirectly! (learning about anything helps us) • It's OK to read non-canonical books! • Some suppressed/neglected in past (dangerous?) • Widely available today; popular in some circles • Yet OT & NT are still much more important!

4. I) Important Definitions • "gospel" = "good news" = oral preaching • from Gk. Ευ̉αγγέλιον = Evangelion(cf. Eng. "Evangelist")eu = "good"; angelos = "messenger" • "Now after John was arrested, Jesus came to Galilee, proclaiming the good news of God, and saying, 'The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God has come near; repent, and believe in the good news.' " (Mark 1:14-15; NRSV) • "Paul, a servant of Jesus Christ, called to be an apostle, set apart for the gospel of God, which he promised beforehand through his prophets in the holy scriptures, the gospel concerning his Son…" (Romans 1:1-3; NRSV) • "But the birthday of the god (Caesar Augustus) was… the beginning of the good news for the world…" (Prien inscription)

5. I) Important Definitions • "Gospel" = "written account about Jesus" • Mark was first to use "gospel" in this sense: • "The beginning of the good news of Jesus Christ, the Son of God." (Mark 1:1) • NT Gospel Titles(added in 2nd Cent.): • "Gospel according to Mark; Gospel according to…" • "Canon" • "Official List" of writings ("scriptures") considered foundational by some group: HB canon, NT canon… • Usually religious, but not only:e.g. Shakespearean canon

6. I) Important Definitions • Four "Canonical Gospels" • Matthew, Mark, Luke, John • Dates: 1st century (60's – 90's) • Order? Mark probably first, then Matthew, Luke; John last • "Non-canonical Gospels" • Many other short books • mostly from 2nd to 4th cent. • about Jesus' life and/or his teachings.

7. I) Important Definitions • "Apocryphal" = "hidden, secret" • Cf. English "crypt," "cryptic" • MANY ancient Jewish or Christian books outside of HB or NT, overall called "Apocrypha" • Apocryphal Gospels, Acts, Epistles, Apocalypses • Not "canonical"; i.e., not in anyone's Bible • Caution: Protestants refer to OT "Apocrypha": • Tobit, Judith, 1 & 2 Maccabees, Wisdom, Eccl., Baruch • Called "Deutero-canonical" by Catholics & Orthodox • Don't confuse with "Apocalyptic" • "Revelation"; lit. "uncovering, revealing, opening"

8. I) Important Definitions • "Pseudepigraphic" • Writings "falsely attributed" to famous figures of the past (esp. biblical, but not only) • Actual authors anonymous; written (much) later • "Gnostic" • Religious systems related to Judaism & Christianity • Dualistic: good vs. evil; spirit vs. matter; M vs. F ! • Human life = "divine spark" trapped in mortal body • Salvation = freeing soul/spirit from its bodily prison,by attaining proper (secret/esoteric) "knowledge" of our divine origins & eternal destiny

9. II) Canonization of the NT • Long Process of Development: • writing, sharing, collecting, editing, translating, debating, interpreting the books/letters now in NT 1st Cent. – individual writings composed 2nd Cent. – writings collected (4 Gospels; Paul’s Letters) 4th Cent. – early canon lists • some with fewer than books: 2 Peter? Revelation? • some with more: Didache, Shepherd of Hermas, etc. • 367 – Easter Letter of St. Athanasius – first list of all 27 16th Cent. – Council of Trent • First "official" listing of all 46 OT & 27 NT books • In reaction to Protestants(esp. regarding OT Apocrypha)

10. End of Luke & Beginning of John

11. II) Canonization of the NT • Main Criteria for Inclusion: 1) Apostolic Origin – • attributed to and/or based on preaching/teaching of first-generation apostles (or their closest companions) 2) Universal Acceptance – • acknowledged by all major Christian communities in the Mediterranean world (by end of 4th century) 3) Liturgical Use – • read publicly along with OT when early Christians gathered for Lord's Supper (weekly worship services) 4) Consistent Message – • containing theological ideas compatible with other accepted Christian writings (incl. divinity & humanity Jesus)

12. II) Canonization of the NT • Reasons for Non-Inclusion in NT Canon(opposites of the four criteria): • Apostolic Origin? – written by later generations • Universal Acceptance? – rejected by some communities • Liturgical Use? – too esoteric, obscure, private • Consistent Theology? – present God/Jesus differently • Christology (Who is Jesus?): • Catholic:Both/And:Both HUMAN and DIVINE • Jewish or Adoptionist: Human, not really divine • Gnostic or Docetist: Divine, not really human

13. III) Non-canonical Gospels • We know of at least 30 "Gospels" not in NT • many different origins, styles, theologies • some positively influenced Church tradition • others rejected as "Gnostic" and/or "heretical" • some texts complete, others badly damaged/ fragmentary, others known only by title!

14. III) Non-canonical Gospels (See the bibliography, on back of the handout.)

15. III) Non-canonical Gospels • Some of the most famous or influential: • Gospel of James:mid-2nd Cent. • mainly about Mary (of Nazareth) as the mother of Israel's salvation • Gospel of Peter:late 2nd Cent. (discovered 1886) • earliest non-canonical narrative account of Jesus' passion & resurrection • Infancy Gospel of Thomas:late 2nd Cent. • strange & miraculous events from Jesus' childhood,from ages 5 to 12 • Sayings Gospel of Thomas:2nd – 3rd Cent. • (more below)

16. III) Non-canonical Gospels • Nag Hammadi Library: • Over 50 texts in 13 codices, Coptic, mostly gnostic, discovered in 1945 near Nag Hammadi, Egypt • Gospel of Thomas: • Orig. 2nd – 3rd Cent.; some old fragments in Greek;Collection of 114 short sayings & teachings of Jesus • Gospel of the Egyptians • Gospel of Philip • Gospel of Truth • Many other books, including various Acts, Dialogues, Treatises, Apocalypses, etc.

17. Nag Hammadi Codices

18. Nag Hammadi – Codex IV

19. III) Non-canonical Gospels • More recent texts: • Secret Gospel of Mark(1958, Morton Smith) – forgery? • Gospel acc. to Peanuts(1965, Robert L. Short) • Gospel acc. to the Simpsons(2001/2007, Mark I. Pinsky)"Bigger and Possibly Even Better! Edition: With a New Afterword Exploring South Park, Family Guy, and Other Animated TV Shows" • Gospel acc. to Harry Potter(2002, Connie Neal)"Spirituality in the Stories of the World's Most Famous Seeker" • Gospel acc. to Doctor Seuss(2004, James Kemp) • Gospel acc. to Martha(2000, Barbara Murphy)

20. III) Non-canonical Gospels • "Are you serious?"(I hear you cry!) • How are these modern texts related tothe ancient Apocryphal Gospels? • Similarities: they are mostly authors’ attemptsto understand the teachings or meaning of Jesus, or of other spiritual themes more broadly • Differences: most modern texts are not forgeries; modern authors' names known

21. Excerpts: Gospel of James (mid-2nd Cent.; Engl. trans. Andrew Bernhard) Chap. 1: In the histories of the twelve tribes of Israel, Joachim was an extremely rich man . . . As the great day of the Lord was drawing near and the children of Israel were bringing their offerings, however, Reubel stood in his way, saying, "You cannot offer your gifts first because you have not conceived a child in Israel." . . . Then, Joachim was extremely frustrated and did not appear to his wife, but gave himself to the desert and pitched his tent there. He fasted forty days and forty nights. All the while, Joachim was saying to himself, "I will not go down for food or drink until the Lord my God visits me; prayer will be my food and drink."

22. Excerpts: Gospel of James Ch. 2: Then, his wife Anna mourned and lamented greatly for two reasons, saying, "I lament that I am a widow and I lament that I am childless."…she petitioned the Lord, saying, "God of my ancestors, bless me and hear my prayer, just as you blessed our mother Sarah and gave her son Isaac to her." Ch. 4: Suddenly, an angel of the Lord stood in front of her, saying, "Anna, Anna, the Lord God has heard your prayer. You will conceive and give birth and your child will be spoken of everywhere people live." And Anna said, "As the Lord God lives, whether I give birth to either a male or a female child, I will bring it as an offering to the Lord my God and it will be a servant to him all the days of its life."

23. Annunciation to Joachim & AnnaGaudenzio Ferrari(1544–45) Next, two angels came, saying to her, "Look your husband Joachim is coming with his flocks." For an angel of the Lord had gone down to Joachim, saying, "Joachim, Joachim, the Lord God has heard your prayer. Go down from here. Look, your wife Anna has conceived in her womb."

24. Excerpts: Gospel of James Ch. 5: …After nine months, Anna gave birth and she said to the midwife, "What is it?" The midwife said, "A girl." Anna said, "My soul exalts this day." And she put her baby to bed. After her days were completed, Anna cleansed herself and gave her breast to the child and gave her the name Mary. Ch. 6 – At 6 months, Mary walks. At one year, she is blessed by the high priests. Ch. 7 – At age 3, Mary is taken to live in the temple. Ch. 8-9 – At age 12, Mary is given to Joseph, a widower. Ch. 11-12 – At age 16, Mary is visited by the Angel Gabriel; then she visits her cousin Elizabeth. Ch. 13-14 – Joseph discovers her pregnant; Joseph's dream Ch. 15-16 – Mary & Joseph are questioned before the court.

25. Excerpts: Gospel of James Ch. 17-18 – They go to Bethlehem, and Jesus is born. Ch. 19-20 – A midwife attests that Mary is still a virgin. Ch. 21-22 – Magi come visit; Herod kills all the infant boys near Bethlehem; Mary hides Jesus; Elizabeth hides John Ch. 23-24 – Still seeking John, Herod murders Zechariah(see Matt 23:35 & Luke 11:51 – "…the blood of Zechariah son of Zarachiah, whom you murdered between the sanctuary and the altar. Ch. 25 – "I, James, wrote this history when there was unrest in Jerusalem, at the time Herod died. I took myself into the desert until the unrest in Jerusalem ceased. All the while, I was glorifying God who gave me the wisdom to write this history. And grace will be with all who fear the Lord. Amen.“ Birth of Mary / Revelation of James Peace to the writer and the reader

26. Gospel of James • Evaluation of this text: • Not accepted as "canonical" – but why not? • Yet also not "gnostic" nor "heretical" • Popular / traditional / influential in Christian history • Parallels parts of Matthew 1–2 and Luke 1–2 • But also adds material (both earlier & filling in gaps): • Birth of Mary to Joachim & Anna • Some episodes in Mary's childhood • Her marriage to Joseph • More details surrounding her pregnancy • More episodes re. Herod killing children & Zechariah

27. Infancy Gospel of Thomas (Mid-2nd Cent.; Engl. trans. Andrew Bernhard) (1) I, Thomas the Israelite, am reporting to you, all my brothers from the nations, to reveal the childhood and the greatness of our Lord Jesus Christ, what he did in my country after he was born. This is the beginning of it. (2) When the boy Jesus was five years old, he was playing in a narrow part of a rushing stream. He was gathering the flowing waters into ponds, and immediately they were made clean, and he ordered these things with a single word.

28. Infancy Gospel of Thomas (2) (2 cont.) And after he made clay, he molded twelve sparrows from it. And it was the Sabbath when he did these things. . . Then, a certain Jew saw what Jesus was doing while playing on the Sabbath. Immediately, he departed and reported to Jesus' father, Joseph, "Look, your child is in the stream and he took clay and formed twelve birds and profaned the Sabbath?" And Joseph went to the area and when he saw him, he shouted, "Why are you doing these things that are not permitted on the Sabbath?" Jesus, however, clapped his hands and shouted to the sparrows, "Depart, fly, and remember me now that you are alive." And the sparrows departed shrieking. When the Jews saw this, they were amazed. . .

29. Infancy Gospel of Thomas (3) (3) The son of Annas the scribe was standing there with Jesus. Taking a branch from a willow tree, he dispersed the waters which Jesus had gathered. When Jesus saw what had happened, he became angry and said to him, "You godless, brainless moron, what did the ponds and waters do to you? Watch this now: you are going to dry up like a tree and you will never produce leaves or roots or fruit." And immediately, this child withered up completely. Then, Jesus departed and returned to Joseph's house. The parents of the one who had been withered up, however, wailed for their young child as they took his remains away. Then, they went to Joseph and accused him, "You are responsible for the child who did this."

30. Infancy Gospel of Thomas (4-8) (4) Next, he was going through the village again and a running child bumped his shoulder. Becoming bitter, Jesus said to him, "You will not complete your journey." Immediately, he fell down and died. Then, some of the people who had seen what had happened said, "Where has this child come from so that his every word is a completed deed?" And going to Joseph, the parents of the one who had died found fault with him. They said, "Because you have such a child, you are not allowed to live with us in the village, or at least teach him to bless and not curse. For our children are dead!" (5-8) Jesus, at age 5, is already wiser than teachers.

31. Infancy Gospel of Thomas (9) (9) And after a few days passed, Jesus was up on a roof of a house. And one of the children playing with him died after falling off the roof. . . When the parents of the one who had died came, they accused Jesus, "Troublemaker, you threw him down." But Jesus replied, "I did not throw him down, rather he threw himself down. When he was not acting carefully, he leaped off the roof and died." Jesus leaped off the roof and stood by the corpse of the boy and cried out with a loud voice and said, "Zeno," - for that was his name - "rise up, talk to me: did I throw you down?" And rising up immediately, he said, "No, Lord, you did not throw me down, but you did raise me up." And when they saw this, they were overwhelmed. The parents of the child glorified God on account of the sign which had happened and they worshipped Jesus.

32. Infancy Gospel of Thomas (10-11) (10) – another miracle, after which the witnesses worship him (11)When Jesus was six years old, his mother sent him to draw water to carry into the house. But he accidentally let the water go in the crowd, and crashing, the water jar broke. But unfolding the cloak which was thrown around him, he filled it with water and carried it to his mother. When his mother saw the sign he had done, she kissed him and treasured in her heart the mysterious things she had seen him do.

33. Infancy Gospel of Thomas (12-15) (12)Then again, in the season of sowing, the child went with his father to sow grain in their field. And as his father was sowing, the child Jesus also sowed one measure of grain. And after he harvested and threshed it, it produced one hundred measures. And calling all the poor of the village to the threshing floor, he gave them grain freely. And Joseph carried the remaining grain away. Jesus was eight years old when he did this sign. (13) – another miracle, after which Joseph is grateful (14-15) – more stories of Jesus being wiser than teachers

34. Infancy Gospel of Thomas (16-19) (16) Then, Joseph sent his son James to tie up wood and bring it into his house, but the child Jesus also followed him. And while James was collecting the bushes, a viper bit his hand. And as he lay on the ground dying, Jesus approached and blew on the bite. And immediately, his anguish ceased and the animal broke apart and at once James was healthy. (17-18) – more miracles, after which everyone is amazed (19) – Jesus, at age 12, goes to Jerusalem with his parents(see Luke 2:41-52) Conclusion: "And Jesus continued to grow in wisdom and age and grace. To him be the glory forever and ever, amen."

35. Jesus in the Temple at age 12Gustave Doré

36. Infancy Gospel of Thomas • Evaluation of this text: • Fills in biblical gaps: Jesus' childhood (esp. ages 5-9) • Not accepted as "canonical" – Why not? • How does it portray the young Jesus? • Cruel? Curses people, and they immediately die? • Powerful? Miraculous healings & raising the dead! • Wise? Better than anyone who tries to teach him! • What can we learn from this text? • Anything about (the historical) Jesus? – No! • Some early Christians' beliefs about him? – Yes!

37. Gospel of Peter (late 2nd Cent. text; discovered 1886; fragmentary begin & end) • The text begins near at the end of Jesus' trial,narrates the crucifixion fairly briefly, with some elements similar to the canonical Gospels, but some different. • Jesus is condemned to death (Herod gives the orders!) • Joseph (of Arimathea) asks for Jesus' body (before he dies!) • Jesus is mocked & scourged, is crucified, and dies. • His body is taken down from the cross and buried. • Jewish leaders & people lament and repent. • The elders ask Pilate for soldiers to guard Jesus' tomb. • On the sabbath, a crowd comes to see the sealed tomb. • New details about the morning of the resurrection:

38. The Empty TombGustave Doré

39. Excerpts: Gospel of Peter • Par. 9-10 (trans. Sam Gibson):During the night before the Lord's day dawned, as the soldiers were keeping guard two by two in every watch, there came a great sound in the sky, and they saw the heavens opened and two men descend shining with a great light, and they drew near to the tomb. • The stone which had been set on the door rolled away by itself and moved to one side, and the tomb was opened and both of the young men went in. • Now when these soldiers saw that, they woke up the centurion and the elders (for they also were there keeping watch).

40. Excerpts: Gospel of Peter • While they were yet telling them the things which they had seen, they saw three men come out of the tomb, two of them sustaining the other one, and a cross following after them. • The heads of the two they saw had heads that reached up to heaven, but the head of him that was led by them went beyond heaven. • And they heard a voice out of the heavens saying, "Have you preached unto them that sleep?" The answer that was heard from the cross was, "Yes!"

41. Excerpts: Gospel of Peter • The story continues: • Soldiers report back to Pilate; he tells them to say nothing. • Mary of Magdala & other women go to the tomb to weep: • They're afraid of being seen by the Jews;and wonder who will roll away the stone for them. • They find the tomb open, and see a young man inside. • Final paragraph: • Now it was the last day of Unleavened Bread, and many were returning to their homes since the feast was ending. But we, the twelve disciples of the Lord, continued weeping and mourning, and each one still grieving for what had happened, left for his own home. But I, Simon Peter, and Andrew my brother, took our fishing nets and went to the sea. With us was Levi, the son of Alphaeus, whom the Lord...(text breaks off here)

42. Gospel of Peter • Evaluation of this text: • Again, fills in a few biblical gaps (esp. Easter morning) • Not accepted as "canonical" – Why not? • What can we learn from this text? • What really happened on Easter morning,how Jesus was raised from the dead? – No! • Some early Christians' beliefs about Jesus? – Yes!

43. Ex: Coptic Gospel of Thomas • Greek fragments from 2nd – 3rd Cent.;4th Cent. Coptic text discovered 1945 near Nag Hammadi • Collection of 114 Sayings of Jesus; excerpts here from "The Scholar's Translation," by S. Patterson & M. Meyer. 0) These are the secret sayings that the living Jesus spoke and Didymos Judas Thomas recorded. 1) And he said, "Whoever discovers the interpretation of these sayings will not taste death."

44. Ex: Coptic Gospel of Thomas 2) Jesus said, "Those who seek should not stop seeking until they find. When they find, they will be disturbed. When they are disturbed, they will marvel, and will reign over all. [And after they have reigned they will rest.]" 3) Jesus said, "If your leaders say to you, 'Look, the (Father's) kingdom is in the sky,' then the birds of the sky will precede you. If they say to you, 'It is in the sea,' then the fish will precede you. Rather, the kingdom is within you and it is outside you. When you know yourselves, then you will be known, and you will understand that you are children of the living Father. But if you do not know yourselves, then you live in poverty, and you are the poverty."

45. Ex: Coptic Gospel of Thomas 4) Jesus said, "The person old in days won't hesitate to ask a little child seven days old about the place of life, and that person will live. For many of the first will be last, and will become a single one." 6) His disciples asked him and said to him, "Do you want us to fast? How should we pray? Should we give to charity? What diet should we observe?" Jesus said, "Don't lie, and don't do what you hate, because all things are disclosed before heaven. After all, there is nothing hidden that will not be revealed, and there is nothing covered up that will remain undisclosed."

46. Ex: Coptic Gospel of Thomas 7) Jesus said, "Lucky is the lion that the human will eat, so that the lion becomes human. And foul is the human that the lion will eat, and the lion still will become human." 8) And he said, The person is like a wise fisherman who cast his net into the sea and drew it up from the sea full of little fish. Among them the wise fisherman discovered a fine large fish. He threw all the little fish back into the sea, and easily chose the large fish. Anyone here with two good ears had better listen!

47. Ex: Coptic Gospel of Thomas 9) Jesus said, Look, the sower went out, took a handful (of seeds), and scattered (them). Some fell on the road, and the birds came and gathered them. Others fell on rock, and they didn't take root in the soil and didn't produce heads of grain. Others fell on thorns, and they choked the seeds and worms ate them. And others fell on good soil, and it produced a good crop: it yielded sixty per measure and one hundred twenty per measure.

48. Ex: Coptic Gospel of Thomas 48)Jesus said, "If two make peace with each other in a single house, they will say to the mountain, 'Move from here!' and it will move." 56)Jesus said, "Whoever has come to know the world has discovered a carcass, and whoever has discovered a carcass, of that person the world is not worthy." 77)Jesus said, "I am the light that is over all things. I am all: from me all came forth, and to me all attained. Split a piece of wood; I am there. Lift up the stone, and you will find me there."

49. Ex: Coptic Gospel of Thomas Last saying (possibly added late): 114) Simon Peter said to them, "Make Mary leave us, for females don't deserve life." Jesus said, "Look, I will guide her to make her male, so that she too may become a living spirit resembling you males. For every female who makes herself male will enter the kingdom of Heaven."

50. Coptic Gospel of Thomas • Evaluation of this text: • Not accepted as "canonical" – Why not? • Heretical? Gnostic? Not universally accepted. • How does it portray the teachings of Jesus? • Familiar? Strange? • What can we learn from this text? • Anything about (the historical) Jesus? – Yes, a bit! • Some of the 114 sayings may date to the 1st Cent.;similar in wording and style to the Synoptics • Others are later, more gnostic in theology.