1 / 12

Estimating Update

Estimating Update . Transportation Improvement Conference 2011 Christine Krall, P.E. Bid Letting Review. FHWA guidelines: 50% of estimates should be within 10% of low bidder 29% of estimates were within 10% of low bidder in fiscal year 2010

tana
Download Presentation

Estimating Update

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Estimating Update Transportation Improvement Conference 2011 Christine Krall, P.E.

  2. Bid Letting Review • FHWA guidelines: 50% of estimates should be within 10% of low bidder • 29% of estimates were within 10% of low bidder in fiscal year 2010 • 32% of estimates were within 10% of low bidder in fiscal year 2009

  3. Justification Letters • Designers are asked to justify estimates when estimate falls outside of 10% range • Justification is also needed for the governor’s approval when estimate is 5% low • Want designer’s perspective on estimate • Use justifications to: • Review project • Review trends in monthly letting • Review estimating resources used by designer

  4. Justification Letter Questions • What is your reasoning the total bid price is lower than the project estimate? • Why are significant bid items different than the estimate? What is unique about these items? • What specific adjustments could you have made to the estimate to be more accurate? • Are the plan quantities accurate on items where the engineers estimate and the bid prices vary significantly? • What tools or sources did you use to determine the estimate prices? • What tools/data sources/resources could the department provide to help you create more accurate estimates?

  5. Unbalanced Bid Analysis • Analysis is performed • when department becomes aware of an quantity error in bid document • significant item to the contract is significantly unbalanced • If the project is determined to be materially unbalanced, the contract will be rejected and relet a minimum of two months later • Designer’s should submit an addenda when quantity error is noted to avoid an unbalanced bid (Call Bill McNary or Jan Kinar to discuss individual project issues)

  6. Addenda • Required to change bid letting documents after advertisement • Submit addenda as early as possible (submit by 8am two Thursdays before the bid letting) • Review addenda for accuracy and completeness before submitting • March 2011 stats • 43 addenda issued • 4 proposals each had three addenda • 3 emergency addenda issued (6 in February)

  7. Mobilization • Mobilization revision in ASP 6 • No change from past payment schedule if mobilization as a percentage of original contract amount is less than or equal to ten percent • When mobilization exceeds ten percent of the original contract amount, mobilization will be paid according to WS 6191 • http://roadwaystandards.dot.wi.gov/standards/cmm/forms/ws6191.xls

  8. Mobilization Stats • Mobilization Statistics for CY 2005-2010 • 56% of projects mobilization between 0-5% • Under 10% for 85% of projects • Under 20% for 98% of projects • Summary of mobilization by work class breakdown • Mobilization is the most justified item in estimate • Mobilization is generally estimated too high

  9. Mobilization

  10. Steel Price Adjustment Index • Steel price adjustment added to contracts with more than 50,000 pounds of structural steel • Added by special provision • Paid for using item 801.0910 Steel Price Adjustment • Payment based on bid letting and mill shipment dates • Monthly index numbers located on HCCI website

  11. Questions or Comments Christine Krall, P.E. Estimating Engineer Christine.Krall@dot.wi.gov 608.266.9626

More Related