1 / 43

Record Management, Electronic Discovery, and the Changing Legal Landscape

Record Management, Electronic Discovery, and the Changing Legal Landscape. Dino Tsibouris dino @tsibouris.com (614) 360-1160 www.tsibouris.com. More Trouble for Morgan Stanley E-mail ‘destroyed’ in 9/11 attack is found.

tiana
Download Presentation

Record Management, Electronic Discovery, and the Changing Legal Landscape

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Record Management, Electronic Discovery, and the Changing Legal Landscape Dino Tsibouris dino@tsibouris.com (614) 360-1160 www.tsibouris.com

  2. More Trouble for Morgan StanleyE-mail ‘destroyed’ in 9/11 attack is found • $1.5 billion judgment for failing to produce thousands of backup tapes of digital documents • Paid the SEC $15 million to settle allegations of e-mail mishandling pursuant to SEC investigations • NASD accusing Morgan Stanley of failing to provide millions of e-mail messages to investigators and plaintiffs and falsely claiming the documents had been lost in the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks

  3. Student Marketing Group, Inc. v. College Partnership Inc. • CPI claimed SMG failed to provide student database with 98% accuracy • Data merged into CPI’s master database, but failed to link the source of data in many cases • CPI’s 2 computer experts’ findings unreliable

  4. Lorraine v. Markel Am. Ins. Co Parties asked court for summary judgment To support their request, both parties attached e-mails as their only evidence E-mails inadmissible because neither party had proven reliability/authenticity

  5. Lorraine v. Markel Am. Ins. Co. Reliability/authenticity of ESI must be proven before it will be admitted into evidence Failure to authenticate evidence is a self-inflicted injury The mere existence of ESI does NOT prove its reliability/authenticity

  6. Sources of Electronic Data • 90% of data is created electronically • 30% is never printed • Sources: • Databases - Purchasing, Payables, Receivables, Email, ERP • Hard Drives, Network Backup Tapes • File Slack, Deleted & Encrypted Files • Meta Data & System Logs

  7. Is this your “document retention” system?

  8. THE IMPORTANT SLIDE • Having a Document Retention Policy and Process is essential • A “Cut & Paste” Policy is risky • Policies should be consistent

  9. Best Practices • Destruction of records under a RIM plan reduces discovery costs by 25 – 30% • Categorize documents as “business” and “non-business” communications • Establish the term for document and data retention • System security and access controls enhance reliability of data at trial

  10. Records: Asset or Liability?

  11. Business Drivers

  12. Sarbanes-Oxley • SEC Regulation S-X Rule 2-06 • Audit record retention • Electronic records created, sent or received in connection with the audit or review containing conclusions, opinions, analyses or financial data related to the audit or review • Data integrity = financial integrity

  13. HIPAA • For covered entities • For protected health information • All paper and electronic records must be part of a comprehensive records management program • Security rule

  14. ESIGN Laws • If a law requires record retention, may comply by retaining the records electronically • Accurate reproduction required • Integrity is key

  15. Commercial Standards • Sedona Guidelines • SOX • ISO, COBIT • Emphasis is on your Processes and Procedures

  16. Records Management • Maintain and use an in-house glossary of records management terminology • Business units should use common terms • Technology terms must be part of the glossary

  17. Records Management • Maintain up-to date records & information management policies, procedures and schedules • Audit your procedures • Modify policy & procedures • Document the process

  18. Records Management • Maintain and track policies, procedures & schedules for litigation defense • Document past RM compliance • Consistently follow good faith process • Include documentation of inactive record keeping systems

  19. Records Management • Know where each record series is stored • Know what is the general content of each series • Available formats or media • Identify personnel or experts who can assist with any large electronic systems

  20. Records Management • Help attorneys identify and preserve relevant records • System to track all legal holds • Education/training/tools to preserve records

  21. Records Management • Create tools to automatically suspend all automatic destruction • Assist counsel in identifying and protecting attorney-client privilege

  22. The New Federal Rules of Evidence • Effective December 1, 2006 • Pretrial planning required • “Electronically Stored Information” • Format selection • Litigation holds • Safe harbor for data disposal

  23. IT IS A RECORDS MANAGEMENT ISSUE • IT Terminology now part of discovery process • Where is it stored? • How is it transmitted? • What format is used?

  24. Rule 34 Electronically Stored Information Any party may serve on ... [an]other party a request (1) to produce ... inspect, copy, test, or sample any designated documents or electronically stored information — including writings, drawings, graphs, charts, photographs, sound recordings, images, and other data or data compilations stored in any medium from which information can be obtained — translated, if necessary ... into reasonably usable form ...

  25. Rule 34 Electronically Stored Information • Amended Rule 34(a) • “Documents” includes ESI unless clearly distinguished from “documents" • Requesting party may specify form of production • Network access

  26. Rule 34 Electronically Stored Information • Amended Rule 34(b) • Native File Production provision • Requesting party may specify the form of ESI production • Form more important for ESI • Preserve searchability

  27. Rule 26 Conference to Plan Discovery Except [when] exempted ... parties must, ... confer to ... make or arrange for the disclosures required by Rule 26(a)(1), to discuss any issues relating to preserving discoverable information, and to develop a proposed discovery plan that indicates the parties’ views and proposals concerning: ... (3) any issues relating to disclosure or discovery of electronically stored information, including the form or forms in which it should be produced;

  28. Rule 26 Conference to Plan Discovery • Amended Rule 26(f) • Early attention to discovery of ESI • Describe ESI to be sought • Preservation of relevant data • Form of ESI disclosure • Privilege or protection

  29. Rule 26 Conference to Plan Discovery • Describe what is a “record” in your organization (and why other data is not) • Explain where relevant information kept • List staff to locate relevant information • Can you help determine what is reasonably accessible and what is not?

  30. Rule 26 Initial Disclosures • Amended Rule 26(a)(1)(B) • Each party must disclose before discovery begins a copy or description (by category and location) of all documents, ESI, and things in the other party's possession, custody or control that it may use to support its claims or defenses.

  31. Rule 26 Production Issues and Accessibility • No need to provide ESI if there is an undue burden or cost • Party seeking discovery may move to compel • Party claiming undue burden or cost has burden of proof

  32. Rule 26 Production Issues and Accessibility • Reasonably accessible ESI that is relevant must be produced • Do not need to produce ESI from sources that are inaccessible • Rule does NOT address duty to preserve relevant information on those sources during litigation

  33. Rule 26 Production Issues and Accessibility • Help locate and track confidential or privileged records • Be a primary contact to help manage production • RM = rules, IT = tools

  34. Rule 26 Burden of Proof • Explanations such as "inactive" or "backup" unlikely to suffice • Court can compel party to produce even if they meet burden of proof when there is good cause • Creates a “balancing test”

  35. Rule 26 Privileged and Trial-Preparation Info • ESI includes metadata • Shows the history and context of the information • Links to other information • May reveal privileged or confidential information

  36. Rule 45Subpoena Practice • Subpoena may specify form or forms to produce ESI • ESI default form is "a form or forms in which the person ordinarily maintains it or in a form or forms that are reasonably usable"

  37. Rule 45Subpoena Practice

  38. Rule 37Safe Harbor Absent exceptional circumstances, a court may not impose sanctions under these rules on a party for failing to provide electronically stored information lost as a result of the routine, good-faith operation of an electronic information system.

  39. Rule 37Safe Harbor • Term "routine operation" refers to the way systems are "generally designed, programmed, and implemented to meet ... technical and business needs" • Must exercise “good faith”

  40. Rule 37Protection is Narrow • Procedures must be established, documented and followed • Incentive for destruction? • Coordinate with other regulations • Safe harbor only applies to sanctions "under these rules"

  41. Rule 26 Conference to Plan Discovery • Develop defensible practices • Consistent application of RM procedures • Make high-value records are not compromised or altered • Be able to educate and warn your attorney about “issues”

  42. Questions & Answers

More Related