1 / 17

Opportunities for Preservation of Overleveraged Multi-Family Housing

Opportunities for Preservation of Overleveraged Multi-Family Housing. Presented by: Harold Shultz, CHPC David Walsh, NYSHFA Dina Levy, UHAB. What is an Overleveraged Building?. An Example. Annual Per Apt/Month Total Debt Service $23,957,325 $1,108 Loans of $367 M

urit
Download Presentation

Opportunities for Preservation of Overleveraged Multi-Family Housing

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Opportunities for Preservation of Overleveraged Multi-Family Housing Presented by: Harold Shultz, CHPC David Walsh, NYSHFA Dina Levy, UHAB

  2. What is an Overleveraged Building?

  3. An Example Annual Per Apt/Month Total Debt Service $23,957,325 $1,108 Loans of $367 M O&M (Est) $14,704,320 $680 Total Debt + O&M $38,661,645 $1,788 Gross Income (2007) $17,310,476 $801 Net $(21,351,169) $(987) DSCR = .36 !

  4. Banks and CMBS • Two types of lenders • Banks • Commercial Mortgage Backed Securitized Trust

  5. CMBS Commercial Mortgage Backed Trust Investors Trustee Master Servicer/ Special Servicer

  6. What Will Happen? Extend Mortgage Recast Mortgage Sell Mortgage Foreclose Mortgage

  7. What Will Happen? Capital Starvation M & O cut to the bone Results in: Long term building deterioration Neighborhood deterioration

  8. Extent of the Problem • 2009: Potentially more than 70,000 units of over-leveraged housing in NYC • Rent Regulated • Mitchell Lama • PB S8

  9. Original Owner One Example: 4,000 unit portfolio(Non Securitized) Sale: in March of 2005 $295 million, or $74,000 per unit. 1st Private Equity/LL@ 20% = $59 M 1st Lender @ 80% = $236 M Sale: in May of 2007 $918 million, or $232,000 per unit. 2nd Private Equity/LL @ 20% = $184 M 2nd Lender @ 80% = $734 M DEBT SERVICE TRIPLES IN 2 YRS

  10. Transparency Pricing “Market Watchers” Barriers to Acquisition

  11. - Long-term responsible owners - Supportable debt based on existing income stream - Adequate operating and capital reserves - Use-restrictions (in some cases) Preservation Goals

  12. Administrative and Legislative Proposals: Voluntary Sales Phantom Tax Relief Debt Acquisition Restrictions on PIPP/LLP Restricted Foreclosure Sales? HUD/Treasury MF Preservation Program Opportunities for Acquisition

  13. Types Of Loans • Portfolio Loan – Originated by Lender and sitting on balance sheet. Lender may or may not want to remove loan through sale or securitization process. • CMBS – Loan may be pooled with other loans, transferred into a Trust, which then issues bonds that may vary in yield, duration and payment priority.

  14. CMBS Loan Participants CMBS Participants • Trustee – Holds all loan documents and distributes cash flow received from Servicer to Investors • Servicer – Manages the flow of payments and information and is responsible for communicating with the Borrower • Rating Agency – Establish ratings for each bond class and continually monitor performance • Investors – Rated versus Unrated Pieces

  15. Ownership – Who owns the various loan pieces? Valuation – How much is the property worth? First Loss Position – Who is controlling holder? Servicer – Will the servicer share information with you? Trustee – Trust not looking to sell if loan not in default Challenges with Securitized Loans

  16. Mezzanine Financing - Acquisition of various Mezzanine Loan pieces. Foreclose where collateral is equity ownership entity in the deal. Take subject to first mortgage. (ie: John Hancock Tower – Boston, MA) Alternative Property Usages – Property being reviewed as possible Supportive Housing project where traditional all-affordable deal in major trouble and lender may be willing to make deal. Supportive Housing financing structure may be applicable and may work Strategies

  17. Brokerage Firms – Cushman & Wakefield, Eastdil, Massey Knakal, Banks –Deutsche Bank, JP Morgan, NY Community Bank Law Firms – Dechert, Paul Hastings, Skadden Arps Mortgage Brokers – Ackman-Ziff, Holliday Fenoglio, Meridian Capital, Palisades Financial Opportunities: Where To Look

More Related