100 likes | 241 Views
Michigan LambdaRail (MiLR) Fiber RFP Process. W. Scott Gerstenberger External Networking Manager University of Michigan. MiLR Fiber RFI. RFI for dark fiber issued in May 2003 intended as a discovery process asked for budgetary pricing received 10 responses
E N D
Michigan LambdaRail (MiLR)Fiber RFP Process W. Scott Gerstenberger External Networking Manager University of Michigan
MiLR Fiber RFI • RFI for dark fiber issued in May 2003 • intended as a discovery process • asked for budgetary pricing • received 10 responses • met with many potential providers • initial business plan developed and approved as a result • learned enough to write the MiLR Collaboration Agreement and issue a fiber RFP
MiLR Fiber RFP • Retained fiber acquisition consultant (Victor Braud) • Project Team from the three schools developed RFP with University of Michigan Purchasing • RFP issued in September 2003 • specified 750-mile ring (Detroit-Ann Arbor-Chicago-East Lansing-Detroit), 20-year IRU • 8-page RFP, email only, 2.5 weeks to respond • sent to 30 vendors, received 11 responses • emphasized desire to be flexible, to seek innovative solutions, multiple providers OK
MiLR Fiber RFP Elements • listed desired topology (long-haul, metro, and campus laterals) • left strand count flexible • fiber acquisition by IRUs, but specified separate, 5-year renewable O&M and colocation contracts • specified intent to light with DWDM • evaluation criteria: compliance with specs, ease of metro/lateral interconnects, customer references, and overall cost
MiLR Long-Haul Fiber Selection • Selected two providers to cover all the needed segments • Expected long-haul price points met, O&M cost invariant for 2, 4, or 6 strands • Notified FiberCo/Level 3 and WilTel in November 2003 of intent to award purchase of 6 strands subject to contract negotiation • Retained outside legal counsel to work with the two carriers and the university lawyers • Took ~90 days to negotiate contracts
MiLR Metro Fiber Selection • Metro fiber prices were fairly high • Considered building some Detroit and Chicago segments using WilTel as a contractor (based on use of SBC duct) • Kept Purchasing Departments involved throughout • In November, started to engage other schools for shared Chicago fiber buy • In February, a subset of the CIC CIOs decided to push hard on the idea of a common buy for Chicago fiber
MiLR Metro Fiber Evaluation • With agreement of University of Illinois Purchasing, Michigan issued a fast turn around Addendum to original RFP but only asking for Chicago fiber and in larger quantities • Received much lower pricing for ring strands, strand-count independent lateral charges, and made feasible a new diverse lateral build into StarLight • Group has decided buy 38 pairs on three loops at an average price of $35k per pair including 20 years of maintenance paid up-front
Fiber Acquisition Decisions • Summary of three fiber IRU acquisitions: • FiberCo/Level 3: Detroit-Ann Arbor-Kalamazoo-Chicago (325 miles) plus Detroit metro (45 miles) • WilTel: Detroit-East Lansing-Grand Rapids-South Bend-Chicago (375 miles) • Buying 10 strands in 9-university CIC 76-strand group buy of Chicago metro fiber from Level 3 and Looking Glass (~15 miles)