1 / 24

David L. Douglass, Partner, Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP, Washington, D.C.

Contracting Risks In Emergent Situations: The Custer Battles Case Study. David L. Douglass, Partner, Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP, Washington, D.C. J. William Eshelman, Partner, Tighe Patton Armstrong & Teasdale, Washington, D.C.

verity
Download Presentation

David L. Douglass, Partner, Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP, Washington, D.C.

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Contracting Risks In Emergent Situations: The Custer Battles Case Study David L. Douglass, Partner, Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP, Washington, D.C. J. William Eshelman, Partner, Tighe Patton Armstrong & Teasdale, Washington, D.C. Robert T. Rhoad, Partner, Porter Wright Morris & Arthur, LLP, Washington D.C. Date July 27, 2007 Time 10:45 am (session one) 1 pm (session two)

  2. The Custer Battles Story

  3. The Custer Battles Story • “Duty, Honor, Country” • Scott Custer • Army Ranger • Post Conflict Ethnic Dispute Resolution Scholar • Non-Profit Humanitarian Relief Organization Founder • Mike Battles • West Point • Army Ranger • CIA • Congressional Candidate

  4. The Custer Battles Story • Explosive Growth • 2003 • From A Handful Of Domestic Contracts To 40+ International Contracts • From 5 Domestic Employees To Over 1,500 International Employees And Subcontractors • From One Office To Multiple International Offices With Management, Operational And Legal Needs

  5. And then, the sound no one wants to hear …

  6. The Custer Battles Story • “War Profiteers?” • Whistleblowers • Allegations • Motivations • Government Investigation of Allegations and Non-Intervention • Litigation, Media Campaign, and Congressional Campaign • One Thing To Proclaim; Another To Prove • What Relators Said • What The Facts Established

  7. The Result? • Custer Battles Prevails

  8. The Custer Battles Story • Or do they? • Suspension • Attorneys’ Fees And Expenses • Financial Ruin Of Company/Jobs Lost • Reputational Damage

  9. The Custer Battles Story • In sum, • the “Custer Battles Story” tells how two decorated Army veterans with entrepreneurial spirit, smarts and know-how created a robust company of hundreds of employees and subcontractors serving the emergent wartime needs of the CPA. • What it teaches is how those who take risk and succeed under unimaginable circumstances can be undone by the unsupported allegations of “whistleblowers” who proceed with a case on behalf of the Government despite the fact that the Government itself has elected not to pursue it.

  10. Lessons Learned • Why study the Custer Battles experience?

  11. Lessons Learned: Enforcement Climate • Fraud Task Forces • National Procurement Task Force • Hurricane Katrina Fraud Task Force • Agency Inspectors General • Congress • Whistleblowers • Qui tam actions • Cooperation with government can lead to criminal investigations

  12. Lessons Learned: Contracting Under Emergent Conditions • Custom vs. legal requirements • Contract compliance • Documentation • Multiple Governmental Authorities • Foreign • Domestic • Federal, State, local • Multiple Agency involvement • Foreign Corrupt Practices Act Risks

  13. Lessons Learned: Legal Risks • Contracting is Prospective; Accountability is Retrospective. • Prospective • Speed • Ability Speed not cost was the deciding fact in the selection of Custer Battles. “All [I] wanted was an assurance Custer Battles could handle the contract. Frank Hatfield, Senior U.S. Airport Official in Iraq. • Retrospective • Accountability • Documentation

  14. Lessons Learned: The Contracting Officer • Authority • Knowledge/Expertise • Turnover

  15. Lessons Learned: The Fog of War • What Rules Apply? The tale of the three little contracting officers: • First little contracting officer: “The CB Contract was subject to the FAR.” • Second little contracting officer: “The FAR did not apply to the CB contract.” • Third little contracting officer: “The CB contract certainly was subject to the FAR.”

  16. Lessons Learned: Business Risks • Disruption • Damages • FCA: Treble Damages, penalties and attorneys fees • Goodwill

  17. Risk Management • Preventative Measures • Document • Clarify • Confirm source of funds and identity of your contracting partner • Advice of counsel • Compliance Programs • Remember, in the government’s view profit = fraud.

More Related