1 / 11

Regulatory framework to tackle household financial distress Catarina Frade (FEUC & CES) BEHAVE International Conf

Regulatory framework to tackle household financial distress Catarina Frade (FEUC & CES) BEHAVE International Conference Households in the Financial Crisis: Consumer credit and policy Lisbon, January 17, 2014. Policy and regulation crossroads.

vidar
Download Presentation

Regulatory framework to tackle household financial distress Catarina Frade (FEUC & CES) BEHAVE International Conf

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Regulatory framework to tackle household financial distress Catarina Frade (FEUC & CES) BEHAVE International Conference Households in the Financial Crisis: Consumer credit and policy Lisbon, January 17, 2014

  2. Policyandregulationcrossroads

  3. ContractLawPrinciples /Legal and Judicial culture Relevantcontractlawprinciplesandduties: Thepactasuntservandaprinciple(contracts are to behonored) as the legal groundofthecapitalisteconomycertitude, stabilityandconfidance Goodfaithprinciplein negotiationsandcontractfulfilment(to act with fairness, honesty and consideration for the other contractual partner interests) Information duties (disclosure) prescribed to lenders/sellers aiming to support borrowers/buyers decisions Conditionsfavorable to tradeand long-time commitments

  4. ContractLawPrinciples /Legal and Judicial culture • Consumerlawandtherecognitionoftheinequalitybetween financial institutionsandindividuals (consumers). • General informationduties (disclosure) in consumerprotectionlaw • Reinforcementofinformationdutiesconcerning financial products (v.g.consumercreditlaw; mortgagelaw, ECB andBankof Portugal orders, etc.) • Approach to therebus sic stantibustheory (changeofthecircumnstancestheory) (v.g. art. 6º, V oftheBrazilianConsumerCode) Rebalance of the bargaining power of contractual partners

  5. ContractLawPrinciples /Legal and Judicial culture • Legal and judicial culture(civil law countries like Portugal) • Positivismand rule oflaw • Adversarialspiritanddistrust in ADR mechanisms to solve conflits (negotiation, mediation, arbitration, etc.) • Neglectofconsumerlaw rules in favor of general contractlawnormsandprinciples • Judicial activismregarded with suspicion and criticism Standardized/routinizedlawenforcement

  6. ContractLawPrinciples /Legal and Judicial culture Current legal frameworkand judicial practice favor: an uneven distribution of credit risk, adverse to borrowers; unbalancedsolutionsthatmanynotprovide a satisfactoryprotectionofborrowers’ rightsandinterestsand in themid-termalsoofthosepertaining to lenders.

  7. Theperceptionofreality • What do wesee? • Retreatofpublicprovisionofwelfare(housing, education, health, retirement) • Increasedependenceofmarket, including financial market, for theprovisionofhouseholds´well-being (“financialization” ofsociety) • Increasevulnerabilityofhouseholds to thedynamics/crisisof labor marketandotherlifeevents (micro-level) and to economicand financial downturns (macro-level)

  8. Theperceptionofreality • What do wesee? • Higher exposure to risk from financial institutions due to short term interests of shareholders, the globalization of financial products and practices, and the diversification of customer profiles • Vulnerability of democratic political institutions in monitoring and regulating autocratic economic institutions (a lender/borrower relationship is also common)

  9. Policyimplicationsandchallenges Theshift: Fromindividual responsability(contractlawandtortlaw, financial literacy) to more a collectiverisksharingapproach (independentdebtcouselling, debtadjustment regimes, bankruptcy, responsiblelending) Balancingpactasuntservanda(freedomofchoice, autonomyofwill) withretibus sic stantibus (changeofcircumstancies)? More doctrineandjurisprudencediscussionisneeded!

  10. Policyimplicationsandchallenges Theshift: From monolithic solutions (one size fits all) to multi-level and customized solutions ‘regulatory mix’ combined with co-operation and co-responsiveness of public institutions, market, society and individuals Centralizedregulation versus deregulation versus decentralizedregulation ? Discussiontowardsgovernanceandlegitimacyissues!

  11. Policyimplicationsandchallenges Theshift: Fromcristalized rules andprocedures to more adaptative policies, lawsandprocedures « deterranceandcompliance debate « judicial activism? Fundamental economicand social rights in a contextofpublicresources deficit? The reinvention and reaffirmation of fundamental rights towards human dignity and freedom (constitutional law)!

More Related