Download
1 / 12
120 likes | 369 Views
Logical Fallacies. What are they?. Common errors in reasoning that will undermind your argument. Typically, fallacies lack evidence that supports the c laim . There are a lot more where these came from…. Common Fallacies. Slippery Slope.
E N D
What are they? • Common errors in reasoning that will undermind your argument. Typically, fallacies lack evidence that supports the c laim.
There are a lot more where these came from… Common Fallacies
Slippery Slope • If we ban Factory Farming, then we will be condemning millions of Americans to die of starvation. • While this statement might not be false, it is still fallacious, since the conclusion based on the premise that if A happens, then eventually through a series of small steps, through B, C,..., X, Y, Z will happen, too, basically equating A and Z.
Hasty Generalization • Organic Farming is more sustainable because the animals are treated better. • This is a conclusion based on insufficient or biased evidence. In other words, you are rushing to a conclusion before you have all the relevant fact.
Genetic Fallacy • The FDA must be corrupt since it is ran by the former CEO of Tyson Industries. • As with others, this statement might be true, but it is still fallacious given that the conclusion is based on an argument that the origins of a person, idea, institute, or theory determine its character, nature, or worth. Simply working for the meat industry doesn’t make you evil.
Circular Argument • Factory Farming is environmentally friendly because it leaves a small carbon footprint. • This restates the argument rather than proves it.
Either/or • We can either put an end to factory farming, or destroy the earth. • Similar to slippery slope, this over simplifies the argument by reducing it to two sides.
Ad hominem • Factory Farming is not the most effective because the big corporations that run them are only concerned about profit. • Again, could be true. Still, not supported with real facts. Instead, the attack is on people, instead of the issue at hand, i.e. what could be a more effective use of space/money/etc.?
Ad populum • Factory Farming is the most effective because cheap food is an American right. • This appeals to the emotionality of a concept, not to the real issue. Sure, cheap food is essential to some, but the check stand price of food belies its larger cost.
Red Herring • Granted, some of the practices of factory farming are unsavory, but what about the people who need to support their families? • Still, no speaking to the issues of health. Instead, the emotional appeal regarding jobs diverts the reader’s attention away from the real issue at hand.
Straw Man • People who support factory farming do not care about the health of themselves or others. • As with others, this oversimplifies. The claim attributes a motive to the oppositions view point that is more than likely not true.
