230 likes | 567 Views
Maus:. A Graphic Novel’s Use and Depiction of Satire. Fall 2010 Satire in Literature Laura McCalla. Learning Graphic Novel Terminology. Panel : A visual or implied boundary where the content within tells a piece of the story. Word panel Image panel Word and image panel.
E N D
Maus: A Graphic Novel’s Use and Depiction of Satire Fall 2010 Satire in Literature Laura McCalla
Learning Graphic Novel Terminology • Panel: A visual or implied boundary where the content within tells a piece of the story. • Word panel • Image panel • Word and image panel
Learning Graphic Novel Terminology • Gutter: The space between the panels. • Balloons: An area within the panel where the words are placed. • Story balloons • Thought balloons • Dialogue balloons • Sound effect balloons • Balloonless balloons
Learning Graphic Novel Terminology • Balloonless balloon example
About the Author Art Spiegelman
Maus: A Graphic Satire • Juvenalian satire is more contemptuous, and abrasive than its counterpart, the Horatian. By addressing social evil through scorn, outrage and ridicule, Juvenalian satire is usually errs on the side of pessimism and is full of irony and biting sarcasm.
Maus: A Graphic Satire • Maus, though not outwardly sarcastic or indignant, is a Juvenalian satire for two distinct reasons… • The novel addresses a great social evil, the Jewish Holocaust. • The novel uses anthropomorphist characters to express the author’s personal invective.
Maus’s Anthropomorphist Characters • Mice • The Jewish people are depicted as mice in order to satirize the German portrayal of Jewish people as vermin. However, by using mice to depict this group, the author also shows the group’s resourcefulness.
Maus’s Anthropomorphist Characters • Cats • The Nazis are depicted as cats, the natural predator of mice and thereby the Nazis are the natural predator of the Jewish people. This relation of a predator/prey dynamic as it happens in nature also gives way to the ideology that latent anti-Semitism will inevitably lead to violence.
Maus’s Anthropomorphist Characters • Dogs • The Americans, who many (including the author and his family) believe were responsible for liberating the prisoners of the concentration camps, are depicted as dogs. This is because dogs chase away cats, but at the same time most dogs only have a quickly passing fascination with mice.
Maus’s Anthropomorphist Characters • Pigs • German Nationals, specifically the Polish, are depicted as pigs because of the author’s perceived selfishness of these people in their actions towards the Jewish people during the reign of Nazi Germany.
Maus’s Anthropomorphist Characters • Frogs • The French are depicted as frogs, partially a nod to their much used moniker, However, this is was also done to markedly exhibit the centuries of anti-Semitism that the French participated in. • Fish • British people are depicted as fish, possibly as a nod to their great Naval tradition, but most likely a satire of the author’s perception of British people’s cold persona.
Maus’s Anthropomorphist Characters • Gypsy Moths • The Roma gypsy population is depicted as gypsy moths. • Reindeer • Swedish people are depicted as Reindeer.
Two Views on Maus’s Anthropomorphism as a Satirical Device… There are commonly two schools of thought on Spiegelman’s anthropomorphist characters and how/why they are effective satirical representations of nationalities
Two Views on Maus’s Anthropomorphism as a Satirical Device… View 1 View 2 • The animals used are supposed to give a harsh reality check as to the failings of each group, as well as a more mild hailing of their strengths. The idea behind this school of thought is that stereotypes are based on some measure of truth, and because of this, those used in the book will hold up throughout time. • The animals used are supposed to show that stereotyping any group of people leads to offensive and rude generalizations that ultimately do not hold true. The stereotypes used in the book are meant to self-implode to show that people cannot be held into a singular group.
Two Views on Maus’s Anthropomorphism as a Satirical Device… View 1 View 2 • The animals used are supposed to give a harsh reality check as to the failings of each group, as well as a more mild hailing of their strengths. The idea behind this school of thought is that stereotypes are based on some measure of truth, and because of this, those used in the book will hold up throughout time. • The animals used are supposed to show that stereotyping any group of people leads to offensive and rude generalizations that ultimately do not hold true. The stereotypes used in the book are meant to self-implode to show that people cannot be held into a singular group.
Bibliography • http://www.andthevalleyshook.com/2008/8/9/590193/the-great-media-maus-a-sur • http://knutlarsson.blogspot.com/2010/09/16-reasons-why-im-not-at-book-fair.html • http://sasidhar.org/blog/page/2/ • http://ghostofthetalkingcricket.squarespace.com/graphic-novel-course-spring-08/ • http://www.grovel.org.uk/maus/ • http://yareviews.wikispaces.com/Review+4 • http://letmelearnyou.wordpress.com/2008/11/04/maus-1-and-2/ • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Art_Spiegelman • http://trcs.wikispaces.com/Aspects+in+Discrimination's+and+Family+towards+Maus • http://blog.art21.org/2010/07/01/on-view-now-mind-the-gap-thoughts-on-representing-the-holocaust-through-comics/ • http://robot6.comicbookresources.com/2010/03/twilight-graphic-novel-sells-well-sun-to-rise-in-east-tomorrow/