220 likes | 273 Views
Zimbabwe’s Agrarian Reform and Prospects for Recovery. Sam Moyo 29 June 2009 Presented at University of South Africa , “ UNISA African Visiting Scholars Lecture Series” (28-30 June 2009) Pretoria South Africa.
E N D
Zimbabwe’s Agrarian Reform and Prospects for Recovery Sam Moyo 29 June 2009 Presented at University of South Africa, “UNISA African Visiting Scholars Lecture Series”(28-30 June 2009) Pretoria South Africa
1. Political Aspects: National healing; Integration and Deepened Democracy and Rights 2. Economic Policy Framework Liberalisation of Prices, Capital and Current Account • Investment Policy (BIPPA’s, Indigenous) • Partial Trade liberalisation • Regional trade and economic policy harmonisation, and integration ( SADC, COMESA) 3. Agricultural Policy /Agrarian Reform: Bi- Modal Agrarian Development Strategy • Promote diverse production and marketing systems; allow diversity; national interests • Liberalisation of inputs and outputs (Commodity) prices; and Parastatal monopoly • Reform of State interventions (Marketing, new subsidies; public support) 4. Land Reform Irreversibility Framework: Accountability without reversing the redistribution • Recognise the New Land Holding Structure and address Exclusions • Equity Target: Gender, farm workers, ethnic - landless poor, whites and foreign • Tenure System Transformed: Diversity of forms need security • New: Leaseholds, Permits, Freeholds BIPPA’s + CA • Security of four rights (use, transfer, exclusion and protection) and collateral • Sustainable Land Use Regulation • Agricultural uses with support, conservancies, forestry and effective natural resource management systems • Compensation for acquired forms needs negotiation 5. Normalise international relations • Isolation (Investment, trade credit, promotion, tourism) • Sanctions (access to international financial and institutions – loans NEED EMPIRICAL GROUNDING Global Political Agreement (GPA) FRAMING THE DEBATE Sam Moyo
1.0 PERSPECTIVES ON ZIMBABWE’S AGRARIAN REFORM (1.1): PRE-2000 Sam Moyo
1.2 Perceived post Fast Track land and agrarian outcomes Sam Moyo
New agrarian structure Farm types/numbers Farm type: Area
Overall Land Redistribution Issues 2.3.1 Overall distribution outcome Sam Moyo
2.2 Social differentiation of beneficiaries (origins, jobs, labour) 2.2 Social differentiation of beneficiaries (origins, jobs, labour)2.2.1 Origins of the beneficiaries Sam Moyo
2.2.2 Employment histories of beneficiaries: class background? *Pvt – Private, CS- Civil Servant ; **Other – Farm worker, domestic worker, informal, student/diaspora Sam Moyo
2.2 Gender dimensions of access to redistributed land Sam Moyo
2.5.2 Foreign owned farms a key battle (500 000 ha) Sam Moyo
Figure 4.3: Land Use Trends: Maize production in Zimbabwe Sam Moyo
Fig. 4.6: Soya beans, groundnuts, beans & sunflower output trends Sam Moyo
5.0 UNDERSTANDING AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION DECLINE5.1 Dominant Perspectives on Causes of Agricultural Decline Sam Moyo
Chart 5.1 Policy matrix: factors affecting agricultural production Sam Moyo
Fig 5.1: Zimbabwe Fertilizer Production and Consumption: 1999 - 2008 5.2 Proximate Causes and Factors of Decline Sam Moyo
6.1 Dominant Perspectives on Agrarian Decline & Recovery Sam Moyo
A sustainable agrarian reform: • Ensure national ownership of the strategy and implementation • Embedded in equitable designed integration • Agenda requires more research and analysis than is so far evident CONCLUDING COMMENT Sam Moyo