Download
1 / 14
140 likes | 269 Views
Software Verification 1 Deductive Verification. Prof. Dr. Holger Schlingloff Institut für Informatik der Humboldt Universität und Fraunhofer Institut für Rechnerarchitektur und Softwaretechnik. Example: Binary Search.
E N D
Software Verification 1Deductive Verification Prof. Dr. Holger Schlingloff Institut für Informatik der Humboldt Universität und Fraunhofer Institut für Rechnerarchitektur und Softwaretechnik
Example: Binary Search • Extend the notion of “program variable” to indexed variables (v[i] for 1=1..n) • Input: a sorted array x[0..n-1] (i (x[i-1]<x[i]) and a value a to search for • Result: index i s.t. a>x[j] for 0<=j<i and a<=x[j] for i<=j<n
Binary Search Program : i=0; k=n; while (i<k) { s=(i+k-1)/2; //integer division if (a>x[s]) i=s+1 else k=s } Show {n>=0 i(0<i<n (x[i-1]<x[i])} {0<=i<=n j(0<=j<i x[j]<a j(i<=j<n x[j]>=a}
Invariant for Binary Search • x is sorted • 0 : i(0<i<n (x[i-1]<x[i]) • i is changed such that • 1 : 0<=i<=n j(0<=j<i x[j]<a) • k is changed such that • 2 : 0<=k<=n j(k<=j<n x[j]>=a) • additionally • 3 : i<=k Let = 0 1 2 3
Hoare Proof for Binary Search {n>=0 i(0<i<n (x[i-1]<x[i])} i=0; k=n; {} while (i<k) { { i<k} s=(i+k-1)/2; //integer division if (a>x[s]) i=s+1 else k=s {} } { i>=k} {i=k 0<=i<=n j(0<=j<i x[j]<a) j(k<=j<n x[j]>=a)} {0<=i<=n j(0<=j<i x[j]<a j(i<=j<n x[j]>=a)}
: 0 <= i <= k <= n j(0<=j<i x[j]<a) j(k<=j<n x[j]>=a) { i<k} s=(i+k-1)/2; { i<k s==(i+k-1)/2} if (a>x[s]) i=s+1 else k=s {} holds since { i<k s=(i+k-1)/2 a>x[s]} {[i:=s+1]} i=s+1 {} { i<k s=(i+k-1)/2 a<=x[s]} {[k:=s]} k=s {} proof: see next
: 0 <= i <= k <= n j(0<=j<i x[j]<a) j(k<=j<n x[j]>=a) Show: i<k s=(i+k-1)/2 x[s]<a [i:=s+1] i<k s=(i+k-1)/2 x[s]<a 0<= s+1 <= k <= n j(0<=j<s +1 x[j]<a) i<k s=(i+k-1)/2 x[s]<a (i+k+1)/2<= k j(0<=j<=(i+k-1)/2 x[j]<a) holds since i<k i+k<k+k i+k+1<=2*k (i+k+1)/2<=k x[s]<a j=s x[j]<a 0 x[s]<a j<s x[j]<a
Last Example: Bubblesort • Given an array x [0..n-1] of integers, the task is to sort x • Bubblesort repeatedly exchanges “unordered” elements in x, e.g.: • 6 – 3 – 8 – 4 – 1 • 3 – 6 – 8 – 4 – 1 • 3 – 6 – 8 – 4 – 1 • 3 – 6 – 4 – 8 – 1 • 3 – 6 – 4 – 1 – 8 • 3 – 6 – 4 – 1 – 8 • 3 – 4 – 6 – 1 – 8 • 3 – 4 – 1 – 6 – 8 • 3 – 1 – 4 – 6 – 8 • etc.
Bubblesort Algorithm : :i=n; :while (i>1) { :i=i-1; k=0; :while (k!=i){ :k++; :if (x[k-1]>x[k]) swap(x[k-1], x[k]) :} :} :
Specification of Sortedness • x is sorted • sorted(x): i(0<i<n x[i-1] <= x[i]) • x is a permutation of the input array ? • For sake of simplicity: • assume all elements in x are pairwise unequal: diff(x): i,j(0<=i != j<n (x[i]!=x[j])} • in this case, x is a permutation of y iff perm(x,y): a(i x[i]==a i y[i]==a) • Specification {x==y diff(x)} {sorted(x) perm(x,y)}
Invariant for Bubblesort Invariant for loop at : after first iteration: x[n-1] at correct position after second iteration: x[n-1] and x[n-2] at correct position after third iteration: x[n-1] .. x[n-3] at correct position ... ordered(x, i): 1<=i<=n j(i<=j<n x[j-1] < x[j]) j(0<=j<i <n x[j] <= x[i]) then we have: • ordered(x, n) T • ordered(x, 1) sorted(x) I: diff(x) perm(x,y) ordered(x,i)
Proof of Outer Loop x==y diff(x) perm(x,y) : x==y diff(x) : x==y diff(x) i==n x==y diff(x) i==n diff(x) perm(x,y) ordered(x,i) : x==y diff(x) : I : I : I (i<=1) provided that : I (i>1) : I perm(x,y) ordered(x,i) (i<=1) perm(x,y) sorted(x) : I : sorted(x) perm(x,y) : x==y diff(x) : perm(x,y) sorted(x) that is, {x==y diff(x)} {sorted(x) perm(x,y)}
Inner Invariant It remains to show: : I (i>1) : I Invariant for loop at : perm(x,y) ordered(x,i+1) remains stable goal of the inner loop: maximal element from x[0]...x[i-1] is moved to x[i-1] after each step: 0<=k<=i j(0<=j<=k x[k]>=x[j]) I: perm(x,y) ordered(x,i+1) 0<=k<=i j(0<=j<=k x[k]>=x[j])
Proof of Inner Invariant : I (i>1) : perm(x,y) ordered(x,i+1) k==0 perm(x,y) ordered(x,i+1) k==0 I : I (i>1) : I : I : I (k==i), provided that : I (k!=i) : I I (k==i) perm(x,y) ordered(x,i+1) j(0<=j<=i x[i]>=x[j]) : I (i>1) : I it remains to show: : I (k!=i) : I • perm(x,y) remains unchanged • ordered(x,i+1) is not modified • : 0<=k<=i j(0<=j<=k x[k]>=x[j]) k!=i : 0<=k<=i j(0<=j<=k-1 x[k-1]>=x[j]) • : I (k!=i) : 0<=k<=i j(0<=j<=k x[k]>=x[j])
