90 likes | 238 Views
Top 5. As a group discuss and write down what you top 5 tips would be for someone about to sit a Paper 2 History exam paper. L.O. To learn how to answer ‘Are you surprised’ questions. This is the best question to use cross-referencing.
E N D
Top 5 • As a group discuss and write down what you top 5 tips would be for someone about to sit a Paper 2 History exam paper
This is the best question to use cross-referencing. • Think about it – if the source that the question is about is saying one thing – and there is a source on the paper saying the opposite – USE IT!
Are you surprised by what this source tells us about the Black Death? Source A An historians account of the attempts to stop people catching the Black Death. It was written in 1961.
Level 2: Surface detail of the source.Yes I am surprised - why would they fire muskets? • Level 3: Surprise linked to your knowledge or other sources. I am surprised – other sources show that people thought it was sent by God. • Level 4: Surprise or lack supported by your own knowledge AND cross reference.I am not surprised as I know that they thought the plague was caused by miasmas (link to a source). On the other hand – it does surprise me as source B shows me they also believed God caused the plague ….
Level 5: Surprise AND lack, supported by own knowledge AND cross reference. • I am not surprised as I know that they thought the plague was caused by miasmas, I can see that C shows a man trying to clear the air too. On the other hand – it does surprise me as source B shows me they also believed God caused the plague and I know that this was a common belief.
Are you surprised by what this source tells you about medieval public health? • Source X: A plan of the design of the water system on Canterbury Cathedral, drawn by the engineer who designed it in 1153. Water Pipes Water Tower Are you surprised by what this source Toilets
Level 2: Surface detail of the source. Yes I am surprised - I did not know they had a water system. • Level 3: Surprise linked to your knowledge or other sources. I am surprised – other sources show that people did not know that medieval people had clean water systems. Source Y shows that they had terrible public health systems. • Level 4: Surprise or lack supported by your own knowledge AND cross reference. I am not surprised as I know that they had a good water system as I know that monasteries were healthier places to live. Source Y shows that the monks were much healthier as they had better ways of cleaning and cooking.
Level 5: Surprise AND lack, supported by own knowledge AND cross reference.AS ABOVE + I am not surprised as I know that they had a good water system as I know that monasteries were healthier places to live. Source Y shows that the monks were much healthier as they had better ways of cleaning and cooking. • On the other hand – it does surprise me as source Z shows me that ordinary people lived in very bad conditions. I know that the towns were very unhealthy places to live.