260 likes | 397 Views
Alcohol use by Irish Children. Sept 2010 Dr Bobby Smyth. Content. Adolescent development Rates of alcohol use by children Why we worry about children drinking. Adolescent Development. Confidence Competence. Why teenagers mess up?. Aristotle ( 384 BC – 322 BC )
E N D
Alcohol use by Irish Children Sept 2010 Dr Bobby Smyth
Content • Adolescent development • Rates of alcohol use by children • Why we worry about children drinking
Adolescent Development Confidence Competence
Why teenagers mess up? • Aristotle (384 BC – 322 BC ) “Youth are heated by nature as drunken men by wine”
The Adolescent brain – a work in progressGiedd et al, 1999, Nature Neuroscience, 2, 861-863 http://www.nimh.nih.gov/press/prbrainmaturing.cfm
…..nevertheless most do fine But is it really different now……..
Spend on Alcohol * Census 2006
ESPAD 2007 - Alcohol among Irish 15-16yo • In the past year, due to their alcohol use • 17% had suffered an accident or injury • 14% reported negative impact on school work • 14% reported serious problems with friends • In the past month • 28% of girls have bought spirits on-premises • 27% of girls have bought spirits in off-licence • Drunkenness • By age 13, 16% have been drunk at least once • At 16, 26% drunk in past month
Parental concern • 90% concerned if their son/daughter to drink 4 pints on one night per month • Wealthier parents are the most permissive • Smyth et al (2010) BMC Public Health, 10(1):297.
Alcohol and Accidental Deaths Bellis M, Bolster MA & Doyle CT. (2009) The Role of Alcohol in Deaths Presenting to the Coroner’s Service in Cork City & County. Ir Med J, 102, 13-15.
Confidence Competence mismatch • Alcohol (and drugs) has the effect of increasing confidence while simultantaneously reducing competence • To paraphrase Aristotle, many Irish youth are heated by nature AND by wine, alcopops, Smirnoff, Budweiser…. • Hence, accidents happen………
Council on Scientific AffairsAmerican Medical Association "Underage alcohol is associated with brain damage and neurocognitive deficits, with implication for learning and intellectual development" Zeigler DW et al (Preventive Medicine, 2004)
At what age is that Irish people loose their ability to have the ‘craic’ without alcohol?
Moral language and discourse around alcohol “Drink Responsible” “Drink Moderate” “Drink Sensibly”
Young Irish Adults • Young adults, mean age 21yo • 22% Alcohol dependent • A further 14% alcohol abuse • Nobody described themselves as “Drinking heavily” *Cleary et al, Irish J Psych Med (2007), 24, 139-144
Burden of proof • Burden lies with those who profit from alcohol to prove to us that what they do causes no harm.