410 likes | 431 Views
LNCD. Vulnerabilities in Neurocognitive Processes in Adolescence. Beatriz Luna, PhD Laboratory of Neurocognitive Development University of Pittsburgh. Control of Behavior. Exo genous Elicited by “external” guides External Stimuli, Emotional States Not guided by a planned response
E N D
LNCD Vulnerabilities in Neurocognitive Processes in Adolescence Beatriz Luna, PhD Laboratory of Neurocognitive Development University of Pittsburgh
Control of Behavior • Exogenous • Elicited by “external” guides • External Stimuli, Emotional States • Not guided by a planned response • Reflexive Behavior • Endogenous • Voluntary • Guided by internal plans • Overrides exogenously-guided behavior • Cognitive Control of Behavior / Decision Making • Can be adult like in adolescence
Conclusions: Adolescence • Adolescents can demonstrate adult-level cognitive control of behavior • Behavioral Studies • Brain mechanisms that support adult-level behavior in adolescence are immature • fMRI studies • Adolescent cognitive control of behavior is immature and vulnerable to error • Conclusions
Brain Maturation in Adolescence Synaptic Pruning Myelination • Improved Brain Function • Increased efficiency of local computations • Increased speed of neuronal transmission
Cognitive Development: Core Processes • Voluntary Response Inhibition (Paus 1990, Levin 1991, Ridderinkhof 1997, Fischer 1997, Munoz 1998, Luna 2004) • Working Memory (Zald 1998, Demetriou 2002, Luna 2004)
Oculomotor Studies of Cognition • Direct Measure of Cognitive Control • Minimal strategy formation • Well-delineated Neural System • Anatomically & Physiologically • Simple Cognitive Tasks • Appropriate for Developmental Studies
Methods • 245 subjects • 8-30 yo (93 Female/152 Males) • Tasks • Speed of Processing • Response Inhibition • Working Memory Child Development 2004
Direct current electro-oculography (EOG) -24 deg -16 deg -8 deg 1 meter 0 deg 8 deg 16 deg 24 deg Darkened Room 20
Non-visible Target Locations Illuminated Targets Correct Gaze Location Visually Guided Saccades Central Fixation (1.5-2.5s) Saccade Saccade to Target (1.5s) -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 Degrees of Visual Angle
Antisaccade Task 3 - 5 sec Central Fixation Saccade away from 1.5 sec Peripheral Target Feedback 1.5 sec -24 -16 - 8 0 8 16 24 Illuminated Targets Degrees of Visual Angle Correct Gaze Location 19
ODR/ Memory Guided Saccade Task 1.5-2.5s Central Fixation 0.1 s Target Location to be Remembered 1,2,4,8 s Delay Period Saccade to Remembered Location 1.5 s 2.0 s Feedback Illuminated Targets -27 -18 - 9 0 9 18 27 Correct Gaze Location Degrees of Visual Angle
Response Inhibition Working Memory Visually Guided Saccades Speed of Processing
Working Memory: Accuracy Initial Saccade Final Saccade
Conclusions • Cognitive control of behavior matures in adolescence • What develops is the sophistication of responses not the appearance of an ability
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + fMRI Capillary Bed - - - - baseline - - - - - - - activation - -
MR Imaging Methods: • Subjects (N=36) • 8-13y (N=11) • 14-17y (N=15) • 18-30y (N=10) • fMRI Studies • 3.0 Tesla GEMS scanner • Gradient-Echo EPI, TR = 5000 • In-plane resolution 3.125 mm2 • 23 - 3 mm slices, 2 mm gap • Standard anatomic imaging (SPGR)
Antisaccade: Block Design 36 sec. 36 sec. Antisaccades Prosaccades 36 sec. • Tasks Repeated for 7.5 cycles Prosaccade Trial Antisaccade Trial Fixation Fixation 15
Adults > Adolescents and Children Adults Children Adolescents R L FEF PEF Sup Coll Lat Cer 14
Adolescents and Children > Adults Adults Children Adolescents PPC R L DLPFC 13
Event Related Antisaccades Saccade Fixation + + Prosaccade Trials Antisaccade Trials + Cue + + 10
Preparation to Inhibit a Response: Adults Children Adolescents FEF R L 9
Antisaccade Preparation: FEF • Children • Adolescents • Adults • Adolescents, like children, do not reach adult-level activation for correct responses. • Adolescents, like adults, do show a second peak of activation. 7
Preparation to Inhibit a Response: Adults Children Adolescents DLPFC VLPFC R L 9
Antisaccade Preparation: DLPFC • Children • Adolescents • Adults • Adolescents, like children, show a delayed peak of activation. • Adolescents, like adults, show a similar magnitude of activation. 6
Conclusions: Response Inhibition • Maturation is characterized by the emergence of an integrated collaborative brain system. • Adolescents are not as efficient at activating brain regions supporting response planning • Adolescents compensate for immature brain systems by recruiting PFC 12
Methods: ODR task VGS Trials Saccade Saccade Delay 4s Fix 1250 ms time Cue 75 ms + + Fix 2425 ms 30 sec. 30 sec. + + Memory Guided Visually Guided 30 sec. • Tasks Repeated for 10.5 cycles Working Memory Trials 15
Working Memory Children Adolescents Adults Basal Ganglia: Caudate & Putamen DLPFC Superior Temporal Gyrus
Working Memory: Encoding and Maintenance
Methods: ODR task + + + + Spatial Working Memory Trials Saccade Delay 2.5 or 10 time + VGS Trials Saccade Cue 75 ms Baseline Fix 2425 ms Fix 1250 ms Jittered 2.5-12.5s
Prefrontal Cortex: Maintenance LNCD Children 8-12yo Adolescents 13-17yo Adults 18-30yo 2.5s Delay BA9 10s Delay BA10 BA9 PFC supports WM maintenance and is on line at all ages
Hippocampus: Encoding Children 8-12yo Adolescents 13-17yo Adults 18-30yo 2.5s Delay 10s Delay • The hippocampus supports encoding and is only recruited by adults
Conclusions: Working Memory • Adolescents are not efficient at recruiting regions that support encoding information in working memory. 12
Take Home Message • While adolescents behave similarly to adults the brain processes supporting cognitive control of behavior are not mature • Adolescence is a still unstable stage that is vulnerable to immature processing 2
Why? • Adolescence is a crucial and necessary period of plasticity when brain circuitry and behavior is beginning to be established. • Risk-taking behavior and novelty seeking may provide a mechanism for increasing exposure to the environment necessary for successful sculpting of the system. end
Laboratory of Neurocognitive Development Dr. Bea Luna PI Dr. Miya Asato Dr. Suzy Scherf Matt Costello MA Krista Garver BA Chuck Geier MA Emi Yasui BA Melanie Wilds BA