210 likes | 339 Views
Underwater light and eelgrass – what is wrong with the Secchi disc?. Søren Laurentius Nielsen Roskilde University. Apparently eelgrass needs more and more light?. Light attenuation is the sum of absorbance and scattering: Attenuation = Absorption + Scattering
E N D
Underwater light and eelgrass – what is wrong with the Secchi disc? Søren Laurentius Nielsen Roskilde University
Light attenuation is the sum of absorbance and scattering: • Attenuation = Absorption + Scattering • Absorption depends on water, particles and colored dissolved matter: • Abstot = Absw + Abspig + Absdet + AbsCDOM • Scattering depends on water and particles: • Scatttot = Scattw + Scattpart
An absorbed photon is gone • A scattered photon is still available for photosynthesis, but… • Scattering might be away from eelgrass on the bottom (upwards, horizontal) • Scattering enhances the probability of absorption (longer pathway)
PAR sensors measure the true available light – you get Kd • Secchi discs are however a different matter
Secchi depth (Zsd) is a measure of image attenuation rather than light attenuation • Zsd is much more sensitive to scatter than Kd • Kd is often estimated from Zsd, assuming that Kd*Zsd is constant (often ≈ 1.44)
Modified from Davies-Colley & Vant, Water Resources Bulletin, 1988
(based on eelgrass depth limits corresponding to 10 % of incident light)
Conclusions: • Systematic changes in the relative contribution of particles and colored dissolved matter during eutrophication/oligotrophication → • Systematic changes in scatter/absorption ratio → • Systematic changes in Zsd * Kd → • Use of Secchi discs lead to overestimation of improvements in light availability and thus potential eelgrass re-colonization during oligotrophication • In Roskilde Fjord 0.5 – 1.5 m
: Extrapolated, sandy : Actual, sandy : Extrapolated, muddy : Actual, sandy
Summary: • Estimations of available light from Secchi disc measurements in the water column may overestimate actually available light due to • Changes in relative contributions from particles and colored dissolved matter (and thus b/a) during oligotrophication • The presence of a fluffy layer close to the bottom