180 likes | 316 Views
Harry Potter Discussion ?s. Chapters 1-2. Why start with Snape? Where do we see the theme of racism in this chapter? Death Eaters’ motivations and relationship Voldemort as a villain Importance of the Malfoy’s status now Biblical allusions Allusions to WWII
E N D
Chapters 1-2 • Why start with Snape? • Where do we see the theme of racism in this chapter? • Death Eaters’ motivations and relationship • Voldemort as a villain • Importance of the Malfoy’s status now • Biblical allusions • Allusions to WWII • What is the mentor/high fantasy relationship here? • Symbolism of Harry’s actions n this chapter • Internal versus external struggles
Chapters 3-4 • What qualities of the epic hero are here? • How do we see Harry mature here? • How do we see the scope of V’s power? • Why is it important? • What’s the importance of Hedwig dying here? • How do we see Snape as Judas • What elements of mystery are here? • How do we see Harry’s mercy and innocence? Tie to Bible. • How do we see the theme of racism here? • Why do the others sacrifice themselves for Harry? Tie to Bible. Why is it important that Harry tries to stop them? • Significance of the number 7
Chapters 5-6 • Where do we see the battle of adulthood versus childhood here? Why does it matter? • What do Harry’s choices tell us about his preparations for the quest and his maturity? Why does all that matter? • Why do the innocent have to be the ones to stop V? • Why is it important that V can fly? • Biblical allusion with the lost ear… • What’s the importance of the number 3? • What conflicts do we see in this chapter (all of them)? • What are we supposed to learn from the wedding still going on? Why is the wedding even in here?
Chapters 7-8 • Why does D leave behind such objects without giving clear instructions? Why not just give it all to Harry when he was still alive? • What’s the importance of Harry and Ginny’s love? • Why is the Ministry of Magic not focusing on the real problems? • What do we see about Harry's maturity level in this chapter? • How do Muriel’s claims differ from Dodge’s claims about D? • Why are her claims so important? • Why is Harry’s doubt so important? What lesson are we to learn from it? • Beginning of the quest proper
Chapters 9-10 • Why does Harry feel unclean and why is that significant? • How is sympathy for the Malfoy’s created here and why? What literary device is this? • How do Harry and Malfoy compare? • What problems do we see in this chapter with the three being on their own? Why is this important? • How do we see the mystery trait of danger here? • In chapter 10, how do we see the connection between Pettigrew and Judas? • How do we see the theme of racism here? What are we to learn from this chapter? • Why is it important that the first horcrux was so easy for them to get? What does this imply about the others to the three? To us? • Why does Regulus betray V? what does this imply will happen?
Chapters 11-12 • Why is it important that V is making it seem as though Harry killed Dumbledore? • How does V exploit Harry’s weaknesses in chapter 11? • Why does Harry reject Lupin and react so poorly? • Why is the sizable challenge of entering the ministry important in the Dumbledore/Harry conflict? • How has society changed for the worse since V took over? Why it important that we learn about it now? • How do we see Kreacher’s devotion in chapter 12? • How do we see that Harry has turned from Dumbledore for good in chapters 11 & 12?
Chapters 13-14 • How do we see racism in the Ministry of Magic? Why is this important? • How does Umbridge differ from V as a villain? What’s her motivation? • In what ways are Umbridge and V alike? • What do Dementors symbolize? • 12 and 13 both highlight the magnitude of the quest. Tie to the Harry/Dumbledore conflict. • Where do we see the allusions to Nazi Germany in this chapter? • Why do those who work for the Ministry continue to support it? • What character traits does Harry display in the ministry? • Is it hypocritical to leave Kreacher? Would they have left Ron or Hermione? What theme does this highlight( aside from racism)? • How does the leaving of Kreacher highlight the theme of racism? • They mystery evolves in chapter 14– how? • Where do we see the theme of the power of evil in chapter 14? • What is Hermione’s role in this quest (aside from being very talented)? Why is it necessary the boys have her? • Where do we see the theme of sacrifice here?
Chapters 15-16 • Ron is NOT Judas – why not? • Free will is a big theme in the novel – how do we see it here and what should we learn from it? • How do we see the theme of sacrifice manifested in chapter 15? How are H & H different from Ron? • Harry fully feels betrayed by D in these chapters. Why don’t Ron and Hermione? How does this affect the quest? • The quest comes to an abrupt halt in chapter 15 – why? • How does chapter 15 highlight the importance of three instead of two? • Without him, we clearly see what Ron’s strength was. What was it? • How are the scriptures on page 325 and 328 important? How does Harry misread them? • How does visiting Godric’s Hollow help Harry in the long run? • Harry’s fully matured in this chapter. He makes no more really rash, immature decisions. What happens to bring this about? • What’s the significance of the Goblin betraying V?
Chapters 17-18 • The idea that people and things can be possessed is strong in chapter 17. However, how does this not interfere with the idea of free will? • What happens in chapters 17-18 that firmly turns Harry from Dumbledore? Are Harry’s claims valid? • Why is there such a rift between Harry and Hermione? • How does Dumbledore’s personality change over the years (from teenage to death)? How does this relate to the Bible? • Based off what we see of Bathilda, what do we know for sure about Rita? Why can’t Harry see it?
Chapter 19-20 • What does the Doe symbolize? (think how it affects Harry) • Why is it significant that it comes along now? • How does this tie to the divine? • Why doesn’t Hermione accept Ron back? How is his betrayal of her worse than his betrayal of Harry? • Who is Ron from the Bible in these chapters? Who else? (there’s two) • How do we see Dumbledore in the God-like role here? • Why is it important that Ron is the one who destroys the horcrux here?
Chapters 21-22 • This is the start of a new quest. What is it and how is it important? Tie to the Bible • How does Harry tie to Jesus in this chapter (think about his ancestry) • What each of them desire says something about their personality – what is it? • Based on Lovegood’s story, how do we know that Harry should not follow the hallow quest? Why did D hint at it with his gift to Hermione? • What does Harry’s desire for the stone show about him? Why would he want it? • Based on events in chapter 22, we see that Harry’s quest for hallows is doomed. Why doesn’t he see it? • Is Lovegood justified in what he does?
Chapters 23-24 • How do Voldemort’s followers differ from Dumbledore’s (not just in who they follow)? • Racism is clearly big here. How do we see it? How does it differ from previous instances? • Peter as Judas is VERY clear here – how? • Why doesn’t Draco simply out Harry in the manor? • FINALLY, Harry is mature and returns to horcruxes. Why the sudden shift? • How does Harry’s kindness make all the difference in chapter 24? • Why is Griphook willing to help Harry even though goblins generally stay out of wizard affairs? • Here we see the moral of the elder wand story in full force. What is it? Why wasn’t that the case for Dumbledore?
Chapters 25-26 • Based off what we see in chapter 25, Harry’s renewed faith in Dumbledore restores him to his proper quest. How do we see the change in the quest as a result of this? • What does Griphook’s response about wizarding arrogance in the conversation about the sword foreshadow will happen? • Why is it significant that Harry lies about giving Griphook the sword? • What does Lupin’s news about the baby do for Harry? • What we see in Diagon Alley furthers the quest how? How do we see Voldemort has further changed the world negatively? • Chapter 26 signifies the beginning of the end. How? • What is the significance of Harry using the Imperio curse?
Chapter 27-29 • How is the true story of Dumbledore important? Why does the true story of Dumbledore not really matter at this point? • What connections are there between Voldemort and Dumbledore? • Harry is viewed differently in this chapter and all chapters following. How so? • We finally see why Dumbledore dabbled in the dark arts. Is it justified? • Was his desire to take over muggles justified based off the story of Ariana? • Is Aberforth right in saying that Dumbledore tricked Harry into this quest by not telling him the truth? • Aberforth says, “How can you be sure you aren’t dispensable, just like my little sister?” Is it possible that Harry was just a tool to Dumbledore? And is it reasonable to sacrifice one teenager for the good of the whole world? • Is Aberforth the “better” brother in some ways? How so? • Through Dumbledore’s story we see a theme relating to pride. What is it? • We finally see Hogwarts through Neville. How has Harry changed Hogwarts? What does this imply will happen? How is Neville’s sudden character change important? • Why is it important that Harry takes others into their confidence?
Chapters 30-31 • Why does the entire castle sacrifice themselves for Harry? • The Weasley’s reconciliation and unification brings us a new slant on a theme we’ve already seen a lot – what is it? • Harry uses the third unforgivable curse in chapter 30 and McGonagall uses one as well. How is this significant? • Mrs. Weasley is quick to dismiss the DA as a “teenagers” gang. Why is this unfair and how does it tie to a theme we’ve seen throughout the novel? • How do we see the power of unification in chapter 31? • Why does Draco try to support V at the last minute? What theme does this tie to? • Through Ravenclaw’s story we see that there is justice in the world. What does this imply will happen? • In chapter 31 we see the scope of the battle and experience our greatest personal loss. How is this important? • How does Percy relate to the Bible?
Chapters 32-33 • What is the significance of Voldemort killing Snape? How is it not a punishment for Snape? • Finally the mystery of Snape is solved. What theme does his motivation tie to? What are his main character traits? • What action does Harry take in chapter 32 shows he is fully mature and that he is ready for his fight with Voldemort? • How do we see that Harry is far more powerful than Voldemort in chapter 32? • We learn a serious lesson about racism in chapter 32 with the creatures that join the fight. What is it? • What do we learn about salvation and forgiveness in chapter 33? How do we learn this? • Is it a betrayal that Dumbledore never told Harry he had to die? Why did he wait until the last moment to have someone tell him? • Did Dumbledore never love Harry at all?
Chapters 34-36 • How is the connection to Jesus exceptionally clear here? • Why is Harry worthy of the resurrection stone now? How is he a far better wizard than any other we’ve seen? • Theme of love again – what’s the new lesson? • Dumbledore as God is also very clear here. How? • How is this semi-hell for Voldemort? why is it so different for Harry than Voldemort? • How does Harry’s resurrection tie to Voldemort’s lack of power? How does that tie to the bible? • Why does Harry feel no pain after coming back? • What’s the lesson we should learn about selfishness here? • Though it is frustrating at times, Harry’s mercy is rewarded here. How?