1 / 10

2013/14 Cold Weather Operations

May 15, 2014. NYPSC Technical Conference. 2013/14 Cold Weather Operations. One of the Nation’s Largest and Most Diverse Generation Portfolios. Oil 23%. Renewables . Gas 31%. Solar 8%. Wind 3%. East. West. Coal 45%. Gas 90%. Coal 31%. Gas 54%. Nuclear 7 %.

yan
Download Presentation

2013/14 Cold Weather Operations

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. May 15, 2014 NYPSC Technical Conference 2013/14 Cold Weather Operations

  2. One of the Nation’s Largest and Most Diverse Generation Portfolios Oil 23% Renewables Gas 31% Solar 8% Wind 3% East West Coal 45% Gas 90% Coal 31% Gas 54% Nuclear 7% Represents net capacity ownership Totals may not sum to 100% due to rounding EME acquisition included NRG Yield: Conventional 1033 MW (included) Renewable 414 MW (included) Thermal 1,346 MWt (not included) Renewables Wind 8% Gulf Coast National Footprint with Diverse Fuel & Merit Order Units

  3. New York Generation • NRG has over 4000 MWs in New York. • Both in-city, Lower Hudson Valley, and rest-of-state units. • Arthur Kill – Station Island – 850+ MW Natural Gas • Astoria – Queens – 525 MW Natural Gas and Oil • Bowline – Haverstraw – 750+ MW Natural Gas and Oil • Dunkirk – Dunkirk – 75 MW Coal • Huntley – Tonawanda – 380 MW Coal • Oswego – Oswego – 1628 MW Oil • The units are comprised of a diverse fuel mix: • Over 2000 MWs of natural gas; • Close to 2500 MWs of oil; and • Over 400 MWs of coal. • Of the gas and oil plants, two are dual-fuel unit and one is oil (1628 MW).

  4. Cold Weather Operations • Overall, the system worked very well. • Spikes in gas prices have revealed a few cracks in our energy markets, but the foundation remains strong. • Cold snap reflected a desire for a higher level of reliability than the established targets upon which the markets are operating. • The market is working to attract more efficient least cost generation but there are other needs for fuel diversity and storage to address the risks of just-in-time delivery of an all gas system that are not being addressed. • Fuel diversity was critical to keeping the lights on. • Oil units had record runs and were critical to system reliability.  • Natural gas curtailments and high natural gas costs led to unprecedented run times for oil units during NRG’s ownership. • Recommended changes: • Incent Dual-Fuel Units to retain and enhance oil firing capability. • Break up weekend natural gas packages.

  5. NRG’s Winter Preparations Worked • Fleet-Wide Comprehensive Response Contributed to Reliable Operations • Pre-winter: NRG built up on-site liquid fuel. • Plant Operations were stressed as cold weather operations persisted into multiple weeks: • Employees from less affected areas outside the region were sent East to provide additional coverage and rapid response to any issues. • Senior Plant Operations were deployed on-site during cold snap. • Plants implemented “Conservative Operation & Maintenance Alerts.” • None of NRG’s New York units ran out of natural gas or liquid fuel. • NRG experienced one curtailment in New York due to challenges faced by the gas system, but there was natural gas at the plant.

  6. Cold Weather Observations: Oil & Other Liquid Fuels Critical to Keeping the Lights on in Winter 2014: • Burned over 1.1 million barrels of liquid fuel in January 2014. • Compared to ~800,000 barrels in all of 2013. • Burned approx. 8.5 million gallons of liquid fuel at Astoria, Bowline and Oswego in January 2014 as compared to 7.5 million gallons for all of 2013. • From January 1, 2014 to April 17, 2014, NRG delivered 168 trucks of liquid fuel to Astoria compared to 92 trucks in all of 2013. • Collectively referring to ULSK, No. 2, No. 6 and kerosene.

  7. Cold Weather Observations: Oil & Other Liquid Fuels (Cont’d) • Oil was priced out of the market as a power plant fuel in the 2000s, and the infrastructure is gradually fading away. • Infrastructure for delivery of liquid fuel is limited. • Barges diverted to other uses due to lack of demand; • Limited trucking capacity and availability of drivers; • Sought emergency waivers of trucking regulations to allow additional fuel deliveries. • Out-of-town truck drivers were positioned close to delivery points. • Frozen rivers and lack of dredging (outside –NY) hampers barge deliveries;and • Less power plant spec liquids in refining of U.S. domestic crude oil.

  8. Cold Weather Observations: Oil & Other Liquid Fuels (Cont’d) Future is Grim for Oil-Fired Units: • “Carrying costs” of oil is extremely high. • Delivered fuel cost is high and inventory turnover is low • Difficult to predict necessary inventory levels. Utilization of oil-fired capacity is typically extremely high during narrow windows or extremely low for most of the year, or for a number of years as has been the case recently. • By way of example, NRG’s Bowline facility burned circa 2007 oil this winter. • Not all dual-fuel units are created equal: • Modern dual-fuel units are permitted with tight run hour limitations and as a result, their ability to operate on back-up fuel is limited by permits. • On-site liquid storage is sized accordingly and disproportionately small compared to cold weather demand. • Not well suited to support a persistent weather event. • Older dual-fuel and oil units typically do not have run time restrictions in their permits, have numerous, very large tanks on site, and historically have had significant storage capability. • But they have become extreme peaking units with very low capacity factors so suppliers and shippers have turned to other markets. • Power plant spec fuels are less available and the infrastructure for rapid-resupply is no longer in place.

  9. Recommendation # 1 – Incent Oil Inventory • Create market approach to incent liquid fuel inventory. • Current wholesale electric markets do not support the large capital investment necessary to develop or retain large quantities of storage that exceed reasonable expectations of demand. • Newly permitted dual fuel units have extremely limited operating hours on fuel oil and often even smaller on site liquid storage. • Fuel diversity is needed and the infrastructure for rapid resupply of liquid fuels is no longer in place. • ISO-NE fuel inventory program worked as a stop gap but not ideal from a integrated market design standpoint. • Need market mechanism to allow cost recovery. • Create a market-product to encourage dual-fuel units to continue operation. • New dual-fuel units will have limited operations and limited storage due to permitting requirements. Winter cold-snap highlighted the need to retain existing oil-fired units. • New ancillary service under which dual fuel units would receive additional payments. • Market design changes that penalize oil and dual-fuel units (i.e., NYISO fuel redundancy proposal and ISO-NE Performance Incentive Proposal) will work counter to incenting the oil and dual-fuel units to remain in the market.

  10. Recommendation #2: Split Weekend Packages • Natural gas trades on Friday for Saturday, Sunday and Monday (and Tuesday on long weekends). • Single price, even though the value and volume requirements of Monday gas is far higher. • Solutions: • Require separate indexes for Sat/Sun and Monday packages: • Each would trade on Friday. Ensures that prices reflect higher load on Monday and lower loads over the weekend. • NYISO can provide Advisory DA Reliability Unit Designations when an OFO situation occurs going into the weekend.

More Related