210 likes | 379 Views
Preventing Fractures in Nursing Home Residents. Cathleen Colon-Emeric, MD, MHSC and Kenneth Lyles, MD: Duke University. Osteoporosis in Maryland SNFs. Zimmerman SI, Osteoporos Int 1999. Epidemiology of Fractures in SNF. 1.5 falls/bed/year 4-10% result in a fracture
E N D
Preventing Fractures in Nursing Home Residents Cathleen Colon-Emeric, MD, MHSC and Kenneth Lyles, MD: Duke University
Osteoporosis in Maryland SNFs Zimmerman SI, Osteoporos Int 1999
Epidemiology of Fractures in SNF • 1.5 falls/bed/year • 4-10% result in a fracture • 1/3 of all hip fracture cases in Australia admitted from SNF1 • Risk of fracture 3-6 times higher than community dwellers1,2 1Cumming, 1996 2Ooms, 1994
Fracture rates, Wisconsin SNFs Kane et al. 1995
From Cummings SR, Nevitt MC, Browner WS et al. NEJM 1995;332:767-73.
Which SNF Residents are at highest risk to fracture? Ambulatory Visual impairment More independent and active Female Faller Wanderer Prior fracture Cognitively impaired Anxiolytic user Colón-Emeric, 2003
DEXA scans • Gives T score = standard deviations above/below mean for healthy young adults • T score < -2.5 indicates osteoporosis • T score < -1.0 indicates osteopenia
Lessons from the Risedronate-HIP Trial • Women aged 70-79 with osteoporosis benefit from risedronate (RR hip fracture 0.6, NNT 77) • Women over 80 with risk factors, but unknown BMD, did not benefit • Bottom line: Need BMD measurements before starting therapy unless resident has a previous fracture McClung, 2001
Risk of subsequent fractures in patients with low-trauma fractures • After vertebral fracture: 2 x increase1 • After hip fracture: 2.5 x increase, >10%/year2 • BMD declines nearly 5% in year after hip fracture3 1Klotzbuecher, 2000 2Colón-Emeric, 2003 3Fox, 2000
Calcium and Vitamin D • Given to all residents regardless of BMD, decreases risk of all non-vertebral fractures by 25%1 • If you treat 21 residents for 18 months, you will prevent 1 fracture • Effect rapidly lost when discontinued2,3 1. Chapuy et al, NEJM 1993 2. Dawson-Hughes et al, NEJM 1997 3. Dawson-Hughes et al, Am J Clin Nutr 2000
Bisphosphonates • Given to women with osteoporosis1 • Decreases fracture risk 50% • Treat 30 women for 2 years, prevent 1 fracture • Usually given weekly • Can cause hypocalcemia in vitamin D deficient patients2 • Safety and efficacy demonstrated in nursing homes3 1. Cranney, 2002 2. Rosen, 2003 3. Greenspan, 2002
Safe administration of bisphosphonates • Must give fasting with full glass of water • Have resident sit upright for 1 hour after dose to prevent esophageal irritation • GERD (reflux) is NOT a contraindication • IV preparations on the way
Calcitonin • Given to women with osteoporosis1 • Decrease spine fractures 30-40% • Treat 12 women for 2 years to prevent 1 spine fracture • Does not reduce non-spine fractures • Generally well tolerated • May have analgesic properties in acute spine fractures2 • Side effect is nasal congestion 1. Chestnut, 2000 2. Silverman, 2002
Raloxifene • In women with osteoporosis • Reduces spine fractures 30-40% • Treat 16-50 women for 2 years to prevent 1 fracture • Does not reduce non-spine fractures • Increased risk of venous thromboemolism • May reduce breast cancer risk Ettinger, 1999
Parathyroid hormone • In men and women with osteoporosis • Decreases spine and non-spine fracture risk 30-60% • Treat 11-29 subjects for 18 months to prevent 1 fracture • Given as subcutaneous injection • Osteosarcoma risk? • Hypercalcemia, nausea, dizziness, cramps Neer, 2001
Combination Therapy • Combining alendronate and parathyroid hormone does not improve BMD over either alone • Alendronate may attenuate the effect of PTH • Other combinations of medications may increase BMD but have not been shown to be effective in reducing fractures Black, 2003
External Hip Protectors • Meta-analysis suggests 60% decreased risk of hip fracture • In patients who are fully compliant, decreases risk by 90% • If you have 24 residents wear hip protectors for 1-2 years you will prevent 1 hip fracture • Staff and resident education interventions greatly increase compliance 1. Kannus et al. NEJM 2000 2. Cochrane Collaboration, 2000
Summary and Recommendations • Osteoporosis is highly prevalent in nursing home residents • Adequate Calcium and vitamin D supplementation is very important for all residents • Residents with prior osteoporotic fractures need effective anti-osteoporosis medications and/or hip protectors • Consider screening others who are at high risk