1 / 19

Can Foreign Aid reduce poverty?

Can Foreign Aid reduce poverty?. By Jeffrey Sachs, from the Earth Institute of Columbia University (YES) & Georges Ayittey, from the American University (NO) Congressional Quaterly, 2009 Presentation by Stéphanie Carret 08.12.09. The planning for today. Review of the paper: main ideas

zanthe
Download Presentation

Can Foreign Aid reduce poverty?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Can Foreign Aid reduce poverty? By Jeffrey Sachs, from the Earth Institute of Columbia University (YES) & Georges Ayittey, from the American University (NO) Congressional Quaterly, 2009 Presentation by Stéphanie Carret 08.12.09

  2. The planning for today • Review of the paper: main ideas • Jeffrey Sachs answers YES • Georges B.N Ayittey answers NO • Analysis of illustrative graph • What questions can we raise?

  3. The Debate • Can foreign aid reduce poverty? • 3 billion people live with less than $2/day • Millions of children lack of lifesaving immunizations • 1 billion people lack access to adequate water supplies • Important improvements in East Asia… • …but extreme poverty increased in Sub-Saharian Africa • The main question always asked: • How can extreme deprivation be seen next to material excess?

  4. The Debate • Principal multilateral institutions: UNDP, the World Bank, IMF & OECD’s DAC aid • US aid started with the Marshall Plan in 1947 & in the 1960’s, USAID was created • Lately, this aid has been mainly used as an impediment to terrorism (Afghanistan & Iraq) • UN Dev.Millenium Goals set up in the 2000 Summit: goals have to be reached by 2015 • One important commitment: wealthy nations have to contribute with an aid = 0.7% of their GNI: not reached • 0.7%= for the UN MG + emergency relief & post-reconstruction • Often, aid motivated by internal politics • Disagreements on aid: just an instrument of foreign policy? What type of aid are efficient? What are the other forms of economic activities providing development?

  5. The UN Millenium Goals • Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger • Achieve universal primery education • Promote gender equality and empower women • Reduce child mortality • Improvematernal health • Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and diseases • Ensure environmental sustainability • Develop a global partneship for development

  6. Jeffrey D. Sachs: YES (1) • His answer is based mainly on the role of US Aid • For the past 50 years, reducing poverty with aid has been successful, except in sub-Saharan Africa • Green Revolution in the 1960’s • Decrease in diseases burdens • Family planning support: population decrease • Manufacturing successes (Thailand, Korea, Malaysia…) • Development Assistance: a tool for the promotion of economic development • Formed of public and private contributions • Aid from public sector: Official Development Assistance (ODA) • Best successes came from Public-Private Parterships (PPP’s) • Ex: Green Revolution in India • Aid as a complement and often as a precondition for market forces: International Trade and FDI inflows: « Aid for Trade »

  7. Jeffrey D. Sachs: YES (2) • What works and doesn’t work with ODA • Usual debate: where is the correlation between aid & growth • 6 interventions points yield development successes • Based in powerful & low-cost technologies • Easy to deliver • Rightly adapted to the scale • Reliably funded • Multilateral • Specific inputs, goals and strategies (+LT indirect goals) • 21st Century: modernizing US D.A • Goals: MDGs + focusing on the poorest regions • Techologies: set of efficient core interventions • Delivery systems: auditing against corruption • Financing: donor aid should be half-half for bilateral and multilateral initiatives: critical need in infrastructures

  8. Jeffrey D. Sachs: YES (3) • Structure of US D.A • Today, USAID part of Department of State • Too focused on SR foreign policy emergencies • More efficient: creation of DfISD • Regrouping USAID, PEPFAR and other initiatives… • Regrouping goals and talents • Financing of US D.A in next administration • Worldwide official D.A = $100billion (1/4 for Africa) • Not enough to achieve the MDGs: pledges not fulfilled • CSQS: difficult for developing countries to count on LT reliable aid in order to start investments • Fragmented aid

  9. Jeffrey D. Sachs: YES (2) • US recognized that aid must be organized as a multilateral effort with common goals • In the US: 3 pillars of national security are Development ($22.7billion), Defense ($611billion) and Diplomacy ($9billion): 1stpb of disproportionnality • US Aid allocated to bilateral and multilateral aid • 2d pb: 3/4 of the aid is devoted to emergencies and US political aims • 3d pb: US has the lowest ODA contribution, as a % of GNI

  10. Graph Analysis (1)% of total population living on less than $1.08/day, 1981-2001

  11. Graph Analysis (2)Net official Development assistance given by OECD Development Assistance Commitee (DAC), 1960-2000

  12. Graph Analysis (3)Net ODA in 2007 - amonts

  13. Graph Analysis (4)Net ODA in 2007 - in % of GNI

  14. Gerges B.Ayittey: NO (1) • The authors focuses on the case of Africa • Africa remains a big paradox: huge potential but weak economic progress • Seems to be a 10-year-attention-deficit-cycle • Pledges of erase part of the $350 billion debt • $25 billion aid per year ($450 billion since 1960) • The shape of aid for Africa has lost rationality in favor of post-colonial guilt • Africa does not need aid: it already has the ressources and needs political and economic reforms

  15. Gerges B.Ayittey: NO (2) • Africa’s leaky begging bowl • « Aid in Africa is like pouring more water in a bucket that leaks horribly »: FDI inflows and exports revenue effects are canceled by imports, corruption and civil wars • Need for Africa to look in its territory to build capital formation with a strong continental union • Need for $50billion annually for capacity building • Africa mustn’t rely on the outside • Capital flight to foreign banks (usually illegal revenus & corruptions & suspicious businessmen): $20billion/year • African leaders may have stolen $140billion during last decades • African Report: $148billion lost annually because of corruption • $15billion/year spent for arms purchase and army maintenance • Losses with civil wars • Difficulties for Africa to feed itself: huge imports

  16. Gerges B.Ayittey: NO (3) • Monumental leadership failure • Aid business as a massive fraud, known even by Western governments: strong example of Nigeria • Post-colonialism leaderships: dirigism and dictatorships enhanced corruption and one-party states: governments were no more institutions, risk of « coconut republic » • The richest: most powerful and corrupted, rarely judged • Acrobatics on reform • In African countries, reforming has a different meaning • Out of 54 countries: 16 democratic, 8 economic successes • Better ways of helping Africa • Smart aid: empowering of civil society (aid monitoring i.e) • Needed institutionnal tools: independent media, judiciary, electoral commission, central bank; efficient civil service, neutral armed force : NEED FOR POLITICAL SPACE. Ex: Egyptian judge • NGO’s cannot always interfere: role of emigrated people (paper) • Distinction between goverments and people: a new Solidarnosc?

  17. Table Analysis (1)Causes of Africa’s Loss of Money

  18. Debate • Is the development improvement in Asia really due to aid • Isn’t it more the cultural & geographical particularities of the region that promoted economic & social development? • To what extent can colonialism be blamed for Africa’s woes? (civil wars, corrupted elites, dictatorships, import dependency for food…)

  19. Questions? Thank you.

More Related