E N D
1. National Saltwater Angler Registry Program
Report for the
Pacific States Marine Fisheries Commission
September 18, 2007
3. Executive Steering Committee Fishery Management Councils
Kitty Simonds (WPFMC)
Miguel Rolon (CFMC)
Interstate Commissions
Vince O’Shea (ASMFC)
Larry Simpson (GSMFC)
Randy Fisher (PSMFC)
Federal Advisory Committee
Bob Fletcher (MAFAC)
NOAA Fisheries
Doug Mecum (NMFS – AKRO)
Nancy Thompson (NMFS – NEFSC)
John Boreman (NMFS – ST, Chair)
Tom Gleason (NMFS – MB, Executive Secretary)
4. Registry Team Members Federal
Gordon Colvin, NOAA Fisheries Service (chair)
Ken Richkus, US Fish and Wildlife Service
State
Phil Anderson, Washington DFW
Erik Barth, Virginia MRC
George Lapointe, Maine DMR
Ron Regan, Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies
Mark Robson, Florida FWCC
Spud Woodward, Georgia CRD
Brad Spear, Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission
Council
Ed Ebisui, Western Pacific Fishery Management Council
Constituent
Dick Brame, Coastal Conservation Association
Jim Donofrio, Recreational Fishing Alliance
Eric Schwaab, MAFAC Liaison, MD DNR
5. Registry and MRII Principles Inclusive
Collaborative
Transparent It’s good to say that we’re going to be these things…but I’m skeptical of people who say they’re going to be something. I’d rather them demonstrate it…so that I, as the listener, I can make my own determination about how inclusive or transparent you’re being. Can we provide examples throughout the presentation? For instance, you can mention how important this is when you list the members of the Team…that’s a very inclusive list. You could refer back to these ideas when you talk about the proposed rule and how we intent to develop it.
Instead, I’d insert some slide that states to overall goal of the group...take the key core message from the talking points as an example… “One important element of the new Marine Recreational Information Program is a national angler registry to account for all saltwater anglers.” This helps remind people of the big picture. It’s good to say that we’re going to be these things…but I’m skeptical of people who say they’re going to be something. I’d rather them demonstrate it…so that I, as the listener, I can make my own determination about how inclusive or transparent you’re being. Can we provide examples throughout the presentation? For instance, you can mention how important this is when you list the members of the Team…that’s a very inclusive list. You could refer back to these ideas when you talk about the proposed rule and how we intent to develop it.
Instead, I’d insert some slide that states to overall goal of the group...take the key core message from the talking points as an example… “One important element of the new Marine Recreational Information Program is a national angler registry to account for all saltwater anglers.” This helps remind people of the big picture.
6. Background: Basis of Registry National Research Council
Establish “a comprehensive, universal sampling frame with national coverage.”
…by creating a “national registration of all saltwater anglers” or “through new or existing state saltwater license programs that would allow no exemptions and that would provide appropriate contact information from anglers fishing in all marine waters, state and federal.”
My reactions was that there’s a lot of text on these slides. What you want to do is put the sideboards on the discussion. Perhaps we could get those parameters across with fewer words. We just want them to skim the slide while they’re listening to you. That said, I think it’s also good for people to see the exact language. It wouldn’t take long to put together a quick 1-2 page handout that includes that language. Nothing fancy but it’d be easier for them to read, I think. Just a suggestion. My reactions was that there’s a lot of text on these slides. What you want to do is put the sideboards on the discussion. Perhaps we could get those parameters across with fewer words. We just want them to skim the slide while they’re listening to you. That said, I think it’s also good for people to see the exact language. It wouldn’t take long to put together a quick 1-2 page handout that includes that language. Nothing fancy but it’d be easier for them to read, I think. Just a suggestion.
7. Basis of Registry (cont.) Magnuson-Stevens Act
Federally established national/regional registry
Fishing in EEZ or for anadromous species
No fee before January 1, 2011
Vessels included?
States may be exempted
8. Basis of Registry (cont.) The secretary shall exempt from registration under the program recreational fishermen and charter fishing vessels licensed, permitted or registered under the laws of a State if the Secretary determines that information from the state program is suitable for the Secretary’s use or is used to assist in completing marine recreational fisheries statistical surveys, or evaluating the effects of proposed conservation and management measures for marine fisheries.”
9. Registry Team Schedule Select the Approach for creating the National Saltwater Angler Registry and adopt a Development Plan that incorporates that Approach by September 30, 2007.
Adopt a final rule to implement the program by January, 2008. Complete Exemption Agreements with qualifying states by January, 2009.
Establish the process for registering anglers from non-exempted states by December 31, 2008.
Begin to register anglers and to receive angler identification and contact information from exempted states, and to input that data into a new national saltwater angler registry data base, by January, 2009. I think numbering here works better than astericks. It makes it more like a “to-do” list. This way I see…ah ha, there are 3-4 things that they’re working on. I think numbering here works better than astericks. It makes it more like a “to-do” list. This way I see…ah ha, there are 3-4 things that they’re working on.
10. Getting to Exempted State Status State provides NOAA with a license or registry-based frame of anglers and for-hire vessels including identification and contact information; OR
State uses registry-based information in a regional survey accepted by NOAA
-This has come to be known as the Hybrid Approach
11. POTENTIALLY:
Youths < 14 to 16
Seniors > 60 (initially)
Fishing on licensed piers or for-hire vessels
Disabled anglers
Active military
These are some possible exemptions currently being considered. What State License Exemptions Will NOAA Accept?
12. State License Exemptions We’re Concerned About Fishing on a licensed private boat
Fishing from private property
Shore and public pier fishing exemptions
Exclusion of some marine waters
13. Challenges to a Complete Sampling Frame Lifetime or long-term licenses
to retain Exempted State status, states would commit to a time frame to refresh licensees’ data
Combination licenses
states would commit to a time frame for earmarking saltwater anglers
Senior license
states would commit to a time frame for recovering ID and contact info for exempted seniors
Data delivery
assure state registry data is available and deliverable in a usable format within a specified time frame
14. Survey-based Exemptions State survey data is part of a Regional survey. Define the regions as: Western Pacific: Alaska; Pacific (i.e. Pacific RecFIN); Gulf (i.e. RecFIN SA); Caribbean; Atlantic (i.e. ACCSP).
Surveys utilize angler registry frames.
Surveys are determined by NOAA Fisheries to meet national survey design and data collection standards
15. State-Federal Communications Regular progress reports to states; no surprises
We will invite states to participate in outreach and communication actions
Upon request, Registry and Operations Team will be available to brief state agencies, legislators and state marine fishery council members
16. Questions and Comments Website:
http://www.st.nmfs.noaa.gov/mrii/angler_registry.html
Email to cyberfish@noaa.gov
Gordon Colvin contact info:
301-713-2367 ext. 175 (office)
240-357-4524 (cell)
gordon.colvin@noaa.gov
19. Operations Team Membership Fishery Management Councils
Paul Dalzell (WPFMC)
Graciela García-Moliner (CFMC)
Jason Didden (MAFMC)
Interstate Commissions
Dave Donaldson (GSMFC)
Russ Porter (PSMFC)
Megan Caldwell (ASMFC)
Dick Brame (ASMFC/CCA)
States
Richard Cody (FL)
Bob Clark (AK)
Mike Armstrong (MA)
Mark Fisher (TX)
Federal Advisory Committee
Rob Kramer (IGFA)
NOAA Fisheries
Gary Shepherd (NMFS – NEFSC)
Guillermo Diaz (NMFS – SEFSC)
Cindy Thomson (NMFS – SWFSC)
Ron Salz (NMFS – ST)
Rob Andrews (NMFS – ST)
Pres Pate (Chair)