1 / 29

SENTENCING: NEW AND RENEWED APPROACHES

Judge Deborah Bail. SENTENCING: NEW AND RENEWED APPROACHES . OUR GOAL: PROTECTING THE PUBLIC BY CHANGING LIVES . STARTING POINTS. In the last decade, prison spending has increased by $22 billion.

Olivia
Download Presentation

SENTENCING: NEW AND RENEWED APPROACHES

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Judge Deborah Bail SENTENCING: NEW AND RENEWED APPROACHES

  2. OUR GOAL: PROTECTING THE PUBLICBY CHANGING LIVES

  3. STARTING POINTS • In the last decade, prison spending has increased by $22 billion. • The rate of ex-cons returning to crime within three years of release has only slightly budged from 45% to 43% • 1 in 100 American adults are behind bars • 1 in 31 adults are either incarcerated, or on probation or parole • Spending on corrections has quadrupled in the last two decades. • Only Medicaid has grown faster in state budgets. Source: Pew Center on States Recidivism Study, August, 2011

  4. STARTING POINTS • In 2006, 69% of all people convicted of a felony in a state court were sentenced to incarceration • 41% to state prison • 28% to local jails • Average prison sentence = 4 yrs and 11 months • 83% of all people incarcerated are male • “Felony Sentences in State Courts, 2005—Statistical Tables, Rosenmerkel et. al., Bureau of Justice Statistics, December, 2009

  5. Idaho Statistics • A prison bed costs $52.22 per day as of fiscal year 2010 • Probation or parole costs $4.00 per day • District Court criminal filings increased 14% from 2009 to 2010 • Felony Driving Under the Influence filings increased by 25% in 2010 • For the calendar year 2010, there were 11,884 criminal cases filed in District Court • Sources: Idaho Department of Correction FY 2010 annual report; Idaho Supreme Court FY 2010 annual report.

  6. Idaho Statistics • In Idaho (August, 2011) • 7,555 people were incarcerated • 480 were released • 14,008 were on supervised release • 88% of those incarcerated were male • 74% of those incarcerated were white • 16% were Hispanic

  7. STARTING POINTS • Felonies are crimes which are punishable by more than one year in jail. • Felonies carry the most serious collateral consequences: • Limited employment options, loss of right to bear arms, registration requirements on some cases, deportation. • 94% of all people charged with a felony plead guilty to one or more charges • The name of the offense doesn’t give you enough information.

  8. SENTENCING • The sentencing process begins with plea or verdict • Pre-sentence investigations take 6-8 weeks in felony cases, often more, depending upon assessments • Assessments: domestic violence, mental health, substance abuse

  9. PRESENTENCE REPORTS • Name(s), date(s) of birth, social security number(s) • Official version of the crime • Defendant’s version of the crime • Victim’s version of the crime or statement • Prior Record • Family background and contact info • Defendant’s description of childhood • Interests; activities (including gang involvement)

  10. PRESENTENCE REPORTS • Education • Current and prior employment • Military record • Health (physical and mental) • Substance abuse • TCU drug screen • Income and expenses • Self evaluation • Investigator’s assessment and recommendation

  11. What information is critical? • Multiple aliases • First description of offense • Third party information • Family members, investigating officers, employers, etc. • Prior record • Frequency of offenses, seriousness of offenses, gaps • Did the defendant drop out of school? Get a GED later? • Employable skills

  12. Critical Information • Detail on past offenses • Substance abuse: type of drug, level of habit, age of onset • Blood Alcohol level • Attitudes and values • Existence and type of support network

  13. ASSESSING OFFENDERS • Variety of assessment instruments: LSI, Gain, Sassi • Rough classes of offenders: • High risk/High needs • Low risk/low needs

  14. LSI-R: The level of service inventory - Revised Risk ranking

  15. ASSESSING OFFENDERS • High Risk, high needs • Background of turmoil • Leaves school early • Early drug use and heavy drug use • Lots of criminal friends and thinking patterns • Lengthy record including juvenile record • No employment • Most worrisome: antisocial personality • “I do what I want when I want.” • No empathy, impulsive, arrogant, aggressive, adventure seeking, no real desire for self control, pattern of criminal thinking

  16. SENTENCING OPTIONS • Split sentence: probation and jail, withheld judgment • Jail—thinking errors; substance abuse treatment, work release, SILD • Retained jurisdiction (Rider) Cottonwood program which addresses multiple risk factors; CAPP • Prison

  17. The Impact of Treatment Varies by Offender Risk Level Impact of Treatment (“Treatment Effect”) Low Risk Low/ ModerateRisk ModerateRisk High Risk

  18. What Doesn‘t Work to Reduce Recidivism • Punishment, sanctions, or incarceration* • Specific deterrence, or fear-based programs, e.g., Scared Straight • Physical challenge programs • Military models of discipline and physical fitness - Boot Camps • Intensive supervision without treatment • *if high risk, works for low risk

  19. PERMANENT EXIT Relapse (Skills to maintain w/o relapse) Maintenance (Doing something i.e. treatment) Pre-Contemplation (Denial) Action ENTER HERE (Ready for change) TEMPORARY EXIT Contemplation (“yes but...”) Stages of change

  20. PERMANENT EXIT Relapse Maintenance Pre-Contemplation Action ENTER HERE TEMPORARY EXIT Contemplation Responses to change Avoid Demoralization Relapse Prevention Promote Self-Diagnosis Practical Strategies Increase Ambivalence

  21. NEW APPROACHES • Target the population • Consider other options: • Drug Courts • Mental Health Courts • Domestic Violence Courts • Alternate option • Bridge Court

  22. DRUG COURTS • Idaho has 56 drug and mental health courts • All are at capacity • In fiscal year 2010, there were 1,783 offenders in drug courts • 84% were retained or graduated • 16% failed • Proven record of reduction of recidivism • Target population: high risk, high needs

  23. DRUG COURT APPROACH • Judicial supervision of an integrated team • Close coordination of providers • Frequent random testing • Treatment • multiple life areas: employability, thinking errors, living situations • Accountability

  24. ADA COUNTY DRUG COURT • Option for felony possession offenses and substance abuse crimes but not crimes of violence • Screened at the preliminary hearing stage or guilty plea phase • Openings for 212. Not open to non-residents (unless self-pay); dealers • 80% graduate

  25. GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS OF TARGETED COURTS • Multi-disciplinary teams under the supervision of the judge • Strong communication • Staged treatment • Structured sanctions • Screening tools generally used to assign offenders • Identified target population

  26. APPLYING THE MODEL MORE BROADLY • Commitment by the Judge • Clear goals • Accountability • Smaller sanctions; more quickly imposed • Community resources utilized to reduce risk of re-offense

  27. PRINCIPLES re: violations • One size does not fit all • Adjusted level of risk • Severity of violation • Nature of the condition: Treatment or Control • Extent of prior compliance • Graduated continuum of both sanctions and services • Swift, certain, and proportionate sanctions for technical violations: Administrative sanctions policy that allows flexibility by probation • Incentives for compliance: 4 rewards for every sanction

  28. BOTTOM LINE • People can and do change • The system can help them want to change and make change more possible • Ultimately, change is a choice each offender must make • Finally, it’s worth trying.

  29. RESOURCES • Idaho State Judiciary www.isc.idaho.gov • Pew Center on the States www.pewcenteronthestates.org • National Drug Court Institute www.ndci.org

More Related